Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 2 by newbeforeold newbeforeold

What story’s next?

Crystal's New Religion

Mike had an all-consuming crush on his friend Crystal for years, but she always rejected him. She just wanted them to remain friends, and didn’t really feel attracted to him at all. Not only that, she was very religious, and saving herself for marriage:

Please log in to view the image

This had been the story of every girl Mike had been interested in: he always ended up in the friend zone. They never thought of him “that way.” And many of the girls he knew just didn’t seem to be interested in sex. Mike had never discovered his biggest asset: his enormous magic cock. He had never really thought about how far out of his dad’s league his mother was, but his father had managed to land her because he had the same condition: his cock was perfect. Whenever a woman saw his cock, she would immediately have an irresistable need to fuck him, and when she fucked him, she would fall deeply in love and lust with him forever.

But Mike had never showed any of his female friends his cock, especially not the super-religious Crystal. This all changed one day when she came over to his house unannounced and Mike’s incredibly hot mom let her in. Crystal walked in on Mike coming out of the shower, and even with his perfect cock covered with a towel, she couldn’t resist its pull. She fell to her knees and pulled off his towel.

Please log in to view the image

The change was immediate. “Oh my God!” Crystal exclaimed, and she didn’t mean the God she usually prayed to, she was talking about Mike’s incredible cock. She rubbed her face against it. She had to fuck it. She needed it inside of her so bad. Mike was shocked, but wasn’t about to say no.

Before long, Crystal was on her back, rubbing her clit as Mike’s cock pounded her.

“Please! Please don’t stop! Keep fucking me! I need your cock. Your cock… Ohfuckohfuckohfuck!”

Crystal’s eyes rolled up in her head and she quivered in ecstasy as she came on his cock. That was the day that Crystal discovered her true religion, the worship of Mike’s cock. She followed it faithfully the rest of her life.

Please log in to view the image

Crystal played by Kristen Scott

What's next?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)