Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)
Chapter 3
by
ManRayMansker
What's next?
Convert?
Nearly all the women in the room took a drink. Only one girl abstained with a shy smile. None of the other guys drank. Then I slowly raised my glass and took a long sip.
The room went quiet for a beat before erupting.
Mia’s eyes locked onto me instantly. She ignored everyone else and focused completely on me, her smile turning sharp and hungry.
“You drank? You are the only guy here who has worn a butt plug?” she purred, clearly thrilled. “Oh we have been waiting for someone like you.”
All the women turned toward me at once. Their expressions shifted from surprise to eager, predatory delight. Sarah bit her lip. A couple of the others giggled and started whispering while staring straight at me.
Mia stood up and walked over slowly. “The only man in the room with experience and you have been hiding it all this time? That ends tonight. We are claiming you.”
She reached into her black box and pulled out a thick, bright pink vibrating butt plug with a flared heart-shaped base. “Here is what is going to happen, princess. You are going to stand up right now, drop your pants and underwear in front of all of us, and bend over the couch. I am sliding this pretty pink vibrating plug deep into your ass while everyone watches. Then I keep the remote for the rest of the night.”Her voice dripped with excitement as she continued. “We are turning you into our personal sissy. Every time it vibrates you will moan and thank us like a good girl. We are painting your nails, forcing you into panties, and giving you a cute girl name. You will admit how much you love having your ass filled. By the end of the night you are going to be our plugged, blushing, feminized little slut who begs us not to stop.”
Mia stepped closer and held the shiny pink plug right in front of my face.“You are the only guy who has done this, so you do not get to act macho anymore. We all want to see exactly how well that ass of yours takes a real toy. So tell me…”
She tilted her head, eyes gleaming with wicked delight.“Are you going to be a good girl, drop your pants, and let us start feminizing you right now… or are you going to try to pretend you are still one of the boys while we all know what you really are?”The room waited. Every woman was staring at me with intense, teasing hunger. A few were already discussing nail polish colors, what panties would look best on me, and how loud they could make me moan.Your move:Do you submit, stand up, and bend over for them?
Do you admit past details while they prepare the plug?
Do you try to negotiate or resist their feminization plans?
Or do you have a completely different reaction?
Your continuation. Take it wherever you want. The women are very eager to play with their new favorite toy.
What's next?
- No further chapters
- Add a new chapter
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)
A Compilation Tale of Never Have I Ever
Play the game contributions welcome
Each Chapter is begging for you to take the challenge
Updated on Jun 27, 2026
by ManRayMansker
Created on Jun 27, 2026
by ManRayMansker
- 7 Likes
- 636 Views
- 3 Favorites
- 1 Bookmarks
- 26 Chapters
- 3 Chapters Deep
Comments moved below the chapter.
Comments