Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)
Chapter 5
by
zankoo
What's next?
Claire hypothesizes what being a roommate might be like
"I mean, hypothetically speaking," Claire continued, her voice taking on a musing quality as she refilled her wine glass, "what would it be like if I were the roommate instead? Like, imagine if Rachel and I weren't dating, and I was just living here with you two."
Abbie blinked, caught off guard by the sudden shift. "That's ... a weird hypothetical."
"Is it though?" Claire's eyes had taken on a slightly glassy quality from the wine, and there was something playful yet intense in her expression. "I mean, think about it. Rachel's absolutely gorgeous, right? Those eyes, that smile ..." She gestured toward Rachel, who was looking increasingly uncomfortable. "If I were just some roommate, sharing a bathroom, seeing her in pajamas every morning, watching her cook dinner ..."
"Claire," Rachel said quietly, a warning in her voice.
"No, but seriously," Claire pressed on, leaning forward. "You're telling me that if someone that beautiful was your roommate, you'd never once think about ... crossing a line? Never wonder what it would be like to kiss her?"
Abbie felt heat rise in her cheeks, but she smiled in a way that might suggest she enjoyed the rush. "I bet kissing her would be glorious."
Claire's eyes lit up with something that looked like triumph mixed with mischief. "Right? And after a few glasses of wine like this, when you're both feeling relaxed and a little buzzed ..." She gestured to their nearly empty glasses. "I think I'd find myself unable to resist. Like, the boundaries would just ... dissolve."
Rachel shifted uncomfortably in her seat. "Claire, what are you doing?"
"I'm just saying," Claire continued, her voice dropping to something more intimate, "if I were hypothetically living here, sharing space with someone as beautiful as you, I think I'd eventually find myself leaning over ..." She moved closer to Rachel, her hand sliding along the counter. "And I wouldn't be able to stop myself from trying to kiss you."
The kitchen seemed to hold its breath. Abbie watched, fascinated despite herself, as Claire's hypothetical scenario began to blur with reality.
"Just like this," Claire murmured, and before Rachel could respond, Claire closed the distance between them, pressing her lips to Rachel's in a slow, deliberate kiss.
It wasn't their usual quick peck or casual affection. This was something deeper, more intentional, performed as much for Abbie's benefit as for Rachel's. Claire's hand found the back of Rachel's neck, fingers tangling in her dark hair as she deepened the kiss.
Rachel's initial surprise gave way to something else entirely. Her eyes fluttered closed, and despite the strange circumstances, she found herself responding. Her lips parted slightly, and Abbie could see the subtle way Rachel's shoulders relaxed into the kiss.
The moment stretched longer than it should have, charged with wine and whatever game Claire was playing. When they finally separated, both women were breathing a little harder, and Rachel's cheeks had flushed pink.
"See?" Claire said, her voice slightly breathless but triumphant. "That's what would happen. Hypothetically."
Abbie realized she'd been holding her breath. The kitchen suddenly felt smaller, the air thicker. She took a large gulp of wine, trying to process what she'd just witnessed.
"That was..." Rachel started, then stopped, touching her lips with her fingertips.
"Inevitable," Claire finished, her eyes still locked on Rachel's face. "If we were just roommates, I mean. The attraction would be too strong." She turned to Abbie with a knowing smile. "You understand, right? How impossible it would be to ignore someone like her?"
Abbie felt caught between fascination and discomfort. There was something deliberate about Claire's performance, as if she were trying to prove a point or extract some kind of confession. "I... yeah, I guess I can see how that might happen."
"Can you?" Claire's voice carried a new edge of curiosity. "Have you ever thought about it? About Rachel, I mean?"
The question hung in the air like a challenge. Rachel looked sharply at Claire, her blue eyes flashing with something between embarrassment and anger. "Claire, stop."
"What? It's just a question," Claire said, though her smile had turned predatory. "We're all adults here. We're talking about attraction, about boundaries ..." She gestured between them with her wine glass. "I'm just curious if those boundaries have ever been ... tested."
What's next?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)
Always, Abbie
She'll do anything you want -- just ask!
No matter the situation, Abbie Andrews is always willing to help out. Giving, generous, kind, never a complaint. Everyone likes her, and she likes everyone. In fact, it seems that no matter what anyone asks here, she says yes. When someone jokingly asks a different kind of question, Abbie begins to learn what she's really made of.
Updated on Apr 8, 2026
by zankoo
Created on May 14, 2022
by zankoo
- 16,836 Likes
- 4,537,046 Views
- 1,661 Favorites
- 1,140 Bookmarks
- 1,101 Chapters
- 198 Chapters Deep
- All Comments
- Chapter Comments