Choose one of your friend’s cocks

“So I think since you’ve enjoyed being the focus of our game so much, you should repay us for our generous attention. So puppy, I dare you to choose one of our cocks to give your first BJ!”

The others hooted and began to reveal themselves as the shock of what that meant washed over you. Despite knowing you were turned on, you still considered yourself straight. You’ve been rationalizing the rest away by saying anyone would like fetish gear, and even Tony playing with your ass is just biological pleasure. But if you give a blowjob, let alone ended up liking it, you could never call yourself straight again...

Your three tormentors sat separated so you would have to crawl To the cock you chose. Scott has unzipped his monster and pulled it out. Just as he was bigger than everyone else, your best friend’s cock was as well. It was long and thick, already fully hard at likely ten inches long and three fingers thick. He was the only uncircumcised one as well, the hooded cock glistening in his hand.

Mark sat to your right, his cock pulled out of his leather pants. It was the shortest, only about 5 inches in length, but was unique in two ways. His cock seemed to be the thickest of the three, probably the width of your wrist. The most unique part though was the metal ring piercing the circumcised tip, which shouldn’t surprise you seeing his other piercings.

Finally was the one belonging to your earlier penetrator Tony. Tony’s seemed somehow almost fiminine compared to the others. It was completely hairless, long and slender. It actually has a somewhat dramatic upward curve along its 8 inch length, maybe allowed because it was only the width of two fingers.

You knew you were going to have to choose, and didn’t know if you should by the cock or the man attached. They’ve all likely been wanting this moment, and honestly you hated that they were making you actively choose this yourself.