Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 3 by ManRayMansker ManRayMansker

Which would you choose?

Challenge Accepted

I stared at the sleek metal chastity cage dangling from Mia’s fingers. My heart hammered so hard I could feel it pounding in my throat and echoing in my ears. The entire room had gone dead silent. Every pair of eyes was locked on me. Jake, my best friend, had that smug, amused grin on his face like he was enjoying my discomfort way too much. Sarah was leaning forward on the couch, her eyes bright with excitement. The other three girls in the group looked equal parts curious and turned on.

But my cock was already twitching in my jeans, making the decision for me.

“Okay,” I said, my voice coming out rough and low. “I’ll do it. I accept the challenge.”A collective ripple of surprised murmurs and excited whispers swept through the room. Mia’s dangerous little smile stretched into something hungry and triumphant. She looked like she had just won the lottery.“Good boy,” she purred, her voice dripping with approval. “Strip from the waist down. Right here in the middle of the room. Let’s see what we are locking up.”

My hands shook as I stood. I unbuckled my belt, popped the button on my jeans, and shoved them down along with my boxers in one motion. My heavy cock flopped out into the open air, thick and heavy even while completely soft. It swung between my thighs like a thick piece of meat.

Gasps filled the room.

Sarah’s mouth actually fell open. “Holy shit…”Mia stepped right up to me, holding the small metal chastity cage next to my soft dick for scale. The contrast was ridiculous. The entire tube of the cage looked tiny against my flaccid length. She tried anyway, pressing the cold metal ring behind my heavy balls and attempting to stuff my thick soft shaft into the short tube.

It would not even come close.The head of my cock barely touched the opening before it stopped, my girth too wide and my length already exceeding the cage by a good three inches while soft. Mia laughed in disbelief, trying to force it again, but my cock just pushed the device away.

“Oh my fucking god,” Mia breathed. “This cage is never going to fit. Not even if you were completely soft for a week.”The girls crowded around me, staring openly. Jake stood up, looking competitive and a little defensive. “No way it is that big. Let me see.” He dropped his pants. His cock sprang out, already half-hard. Fully erect, it measured maybe four and a half inches. Respectable for some, but nothing impressive.

Mia immediately lifted my heavy, soft cock and laid it directly on top of Jake’s stiff one. Mine completely covered his erection and still had thick inches left over. The girls burst into giggles and shocked laughter.“Look at that,” one of the girls named Lena said, pointing. “His soft dick is bigger than Jake’s full hard-on.”

Tyler, stepped up next. His cock was above average, maybe six inches when rock hard. He stroked himself to full mast, clearly trying to compete. Mia pressed my soft cock against his erection. Even flaccid, I was longer and noticeably thicker. Tyler’s face flushed with embarrassment as the girls teased him.

“Damn,” Sarah whispered, wrapping her hand around my thickening shaft. “You are massive. The rest of these boys look tiny next to you.”My cock continued to swell under all the attention, rising and thickening until it stood proud and heavy, veiny and intimidating. Eight and a half thick inches with a fat mushroom head already leaking a bead of precum. The girls did not wait for permission.

Sarah dropped to her knees first, both hands wrapping around my shaft. “I need this in my mouth.” She leaned in and took the head between her warm, wet lips, sucking greedily. Her tongue swirled around the sensitive underside as she bobbed, taking more of me with every stroke. Another girl, Emma, joined her, licking and sucking on my heavy balls while Sarah worked the head and shaft.

The wet, slurping sounds filled the room. I groaned, my hand resting on Sarah’s head as she tried her best to deepthroat me, gagging softly when I hit the back of her throat. She pulled off with a gasp, strings of saliva connecting her lips to my cock.

Mia stripped quickly, revealing her tight, toned body and smooth shaved pussy already glistening with arousal. “My turn. I want this monster raw. Right now, in front of everyone.”She pushed me back onto the large sectional couch and climbed on top of me. The other girls kept licking and stroking my cock and balls as Mia positioned herself. She rubbed my fat cockhead up and down her soaked slit, coating me in her juices, then slowly sank down.

“Fuuuuck,” she moaned loudly as my thick head stretched her open. “You are so much bigger than any of the other guys. I can feel every inch.”

She worked herself down gradually, her tight pussy gripping me like a velvet vice. Inch after inch disappeared inside her until she bottomed out, her ass resting against my thighs. Her belly visibly bulged slightly from my size. Mia started riding me, rolling her hips, her perky tits bouncing with every movement.The other girls watched, touching themselves or each other. Jake and Tyler stroked their smaller cocks, looking

humbled but turned on.Mia rode me harder, her moans turning into sharp cries. “I am going to cum already. Your cock is hitting spots no one else reaches.” Her pussy clenched violently around me as she came the first time, soaking my balls with her juices. She kept bouncing through it, chasing another.I grabbed her hips and started thrusting up to meet her, pounding deep and raw. The wet slapping sounds echoed. Mia came a second time, screaming, her body shaking as her walls fluttered and milked my cock.

“Flip me over,” she begged. “Fuck me like a slut in front of everyone.”I lifted her off and put her on all fours on the couch. I slammed back into her from behind in one smooth thrust, burying every inch. My heavy balls slapped against her clit with every powerful stroke. Mia pushed back against me, moaning like a pornstar. I reached around and rubbed her clit while I fucked her deep and hard.She came a third time, squirting slightly down my thighs, her legs trembling. “Don’t stop. Fill me up. Cum inside me raw.”

I could not hold back any longer. I gripped her hips tight and drove into her with long, powerful strokes. My balls tightened and I exploded deep inside her. Thick, heavy ropes of cum pumped into her womb, filling her until it started leaking out around my cock with every thrust. I kept fucking her through my orgasm, pushing my load deeper.When I finally pulled out, a flood of my cum dripped from her stretched pussy onto the couch. Mia collapsed forward, panting and smiling blissfully.

The other girls were not done with me.Lena took Mia’s place, sucking my cum-covered cock clean before riding me reverse cowgirl so everyone could watch my thick shaft stretching her. Emma wanted it doggy style next, moaning about how full she felt. Sarah begged me to fuck her missionary while she looked into my eyes, telling me how no other cock had ever felt like mine.Throughout the night the smaller guys watched, stroking themselves. Their cocks looked tiny in comparison, and the girls teased them relentlessly about it while taking turns on my massive dick.Mia eventually dangled the useless little chastity cage again, laughing. “This thing was never going to fit you, was it? You are way too much man for a cage.”She wore the key on a chain between her breasts anyway, a trophy as I continued fucking the girls one after another, raw and deep, filling whoever wanted it.

By the end of the night I had lost count of how many orgasms the women had. My cock was sore but satisfied, and the group’s “Never Have I Ever” game had turned into an all-out orgy centered around my size.

What's next?

Comments

      More fun
      Want to support CHYOA?
      Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)