Carly

“So, let me see,” I mused looking at each of the girls in turn. I was conscious of the fact that I was only wearing my boxers as I looked around at them and I had given up trying to hide my straining boner. But they were also in various states of undress.

My sister was wearing only her tight gray shorts, I wasn’t sure if she had panties on under them or not. They were so tight I suspected not. Amy had also lost her top and was only wearing her white denim shorts which Beth had already unzipped. Carly was down to just her pink bra and panties. Beth had lost her jeans and was only wearing her top and panties.

But I didn’t want to pick her. I had a better idea. “I pick Carly,” I announced. She looked at me looking a little nervous, expecting I would dare her to take off her bra or panties. But I had a different idea.

“I dare you to take off Beth’s top,” I grinned. She was the only one whose tits weren’t very much on display. “Oh, and maybe lick and suck on them for one minute,” I added.

“Ok,” Carly grinned. “Sounds like fun to me.”

“You’re not going to protest, Beth?” I asked, only a little surprised.

She shrugged her shoulders. “Eh, why should I? It’s not like everybody else isn’t already showing off their goods. I’m not ashamed of my boobs, they’re just as nice as the others.”

Carly turned to Beth and smiled. She grabbed the hem of her pale blue top and swiftly pulled it up over her head. Beth was right, her boobs were just as nice as the others.

“Yep, you were right, Beth,” I said out loud. “Those are some pretty nice tits too. It sure is nice that my sister and all her friends have such pretty tits.” My sister and Amy looked at me and saw that my hand was on the erection trying to poke out of my boxers. They looked at each other and giggled.

In the meantime, Carly had bent her head down and started licking and sucking on Beth’s tits. “Mmmmm, mmmm, mmmm,” she hummed into her friend’s fleshy orbs. “You’re right you got great tits, Beth,” she smiled as she switched from left to right. Beth had her head thrown back and her eyes rolled into the back of her head. “Oh yeah, just like that, girlfriend,” she moaned.

As Carly sucked on one tit and pulled on the nipple with her lips, she massaged the other one with one hand giving it good hard squeezes. In the meantime, Beth had both of her hands on Carly’s head trying to pull her in even closer.

I had started rubbing my cock seriously while watching this girl on girl show and had completely forgotten about the time limit. My sister looked at me and saw what I was doing.

“David!” she exclaimed. “Aren’t you timing them?”

I was startled out of my reverie and let go of my dick and looked down at my watch. It had been almost five minutes! “Time! Time!” I shouted, although I really didn’t want to.

Carly pulled away from Beth with a look that said ‘this is not over’ and moved back to her former position on the sofa. She took a deep breath trying to regain her composure. One of her bra straps had fallen off her shoulder, exposing one boob almost to the areola.

“So I think it’s my turn to pick now, right?”