Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 15 by rnlrnl rnlrnl

What does Sam ask for?

Can I put it in you?

"YES!" Carrie shouts in response to the whispered question. "God Sam, I have wanted this ever since that night we watched that movie. Maybe earlier. I knew you were beautiful but I had no idea how ... much you had to offer."

"I'm a virgin"

"I would be honored to be the first person to take your perfect cock."

"Really? It's not weird?"

"No, it's the most beautiful cock I have ever seen and that is no small feat." The two laugh at the double entendre. "Enough talking, it's important for you to learn foreplay but I am sopping wet and need to feel this inside me so we will hold off until you fuck me."

You are stunned, usually Carrie takes _some_ prep to take your little thing to say nothing of a member of Sam's almost grotesque size. She must be so turned on, or mad at you, or both. Your dick feels like it could drill a hole on it's prison, tunneling to freedom. But of course, it doesn't. It just throbs with a reminder of your, indefinite you now realize, denial. You are so **** for stimulation that you feel your kegels clench and you wish, for the first time you are consciously aware of, that you had something to fill your ass. "One thing at a time," you think. You banish the thought, though not completely.

You can hear Sam, "Your pussy is beautiful, Carrie!" She must have removed your girlfriends pants and her skimpy thong.

"Thanks babe, a great match for this perfect cock. Now, how do you want your first time to be?"

"Can you bend over? You have such an amazing ass and I have wanted to touch it since we met."

"You can do more than touch it," Carrie promises. You hear them arrange themselves and then a sultry voice from your girlfriend beckon, "Go ahead, babe."

Silence follows for what feels like a lifetime but, realistically, could only be seconds followed by a shriek of pleasure "Oh, Sam!"

"I'm sorry, should I pull out?"

"DON'T YOU FUCKING DARE!" Carrie responds with a desperation you have never heard your normally composed and cool girlfriend evince. What follows is some of the most brutal sex sounds you could imagine. Carrie cries out for God, Jesus, anybody who could help her get just one more inch of your sister's giant cock into her pussy.

"Oh my God, I can't believe this is happening," your sister exclaims. You can recognize in her voice the strain of trying to last as she is feeling things she could previously only imagine. "Are you sure you want me to put the rest in?"

"YES!" Comes the immediate cry.

They both just strain and then you hear it, almost a whisper. "It's in."

Carrie meekly says, with some pain but equal amounts pleasure "Just wait a second and then start moving."

More silence and then the squeaking of your sofa. The moans of your sister. The gibbering of your girlfriend, driven to ecstasy.

It takes forever and yet also no time at all but eventually Sam says, "I am gonna come."

"Don't pull out, just cum in me. It'll be okay, I'm on the pill I just want you to stay inside of me."

Your eyes widen. This is it, your last chance to do somethi--

"GAH"

"FUCK ME SAM"

"OH CARRIE"

You hear one last bestial roar forming from the two lovers cries as they each reach climax. You can't believe it, it's done.

"I love you Carrie."

"... Sam"

You feel an orgasm shoot through your body even as your limp cock is pressed into the tight cage. You collapse right there by the door, the entirety of the last 24 hours hitting you all at once and the three of you enter a long and well-deserved sleep.

The next day

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)