Call for backup

Even as you were trying to avoid throwing a naked orgy at the new girl, you inadvertently flash the poor thing. She is looking at you from her periphery as your hands are up in response to her holding out the bear spray. Of course, she doesn’t want to stare at you right now. Realizing this, you coverup again.

Things have escalated quicker than you expected. You wanted to apply some charm and guile to the situation but fell flat on your face before you even took your first step! You could try and talk her down, but one wrong word and you’ll be tasting pepper and burning for the next hour or so. You fall back to plan B and call out, “Chelsea…!”

“Hahaha!” Chelsea blurts out as she spills out of the bedroom. Skylar and Sabrina file out too, putting a little more effort in hiding their mirth. Olivia is surprised to see her friend alive and well.

“What’s going on here?!” the mace wielding avenger demands, glancing at Chelsea, Skylar and a girl she’s never met before, all in various stages of undress. Her eyes dart back to you, still not completely assured everything is well in this apartment.

“Liv, it’s OK, John is a friend!” Skylar explains.

“Will someone explain what the heck is going on here?!” Olivia asks, looking like she is on the verge of freaking out. “And it better not start off with a ‘it’s not what it looks like’! Because I don’t know what this looks like!” She staggers back and forth, not sure whether she should run or not.

“Calm down, Liv, it’s alright…” Chelsea soothes. “Remember when I texted you about checking in on some peeps Skylar was meeting up with?”

“Yeah…” Olivia replies warily.

“Well, she was meeting up with them for a hookup..” Chelsea explains.

“Totally consensual!” you find it fitting to add.

“Oh God… DId I walk in on an orgy?!” Olivia gasps.

“It’s content! For Onlyfans!” Skylar informs her enthusiastically.

“Onlyfans? What?” Olivia is even more confused now.

“It’s a collab… Sabrina has a page and Skylar contacted her to see if they wanted to do videos together…” you explain further. She is still wary of you but she looks like she’s listening.

“So you’re with her?” she asks.

“It’s not like that!” Sabrina pipes in. She looks a little flustered and shocked at her own outburst. “I mean… we’re… friends…?” She seems to be debating how much of your relationship she’s willing to reveal, like that you go to the same school and intern at the same law office. Still, friends status is closer than you were before getting together. You give her a nod of affirmation. She gives a meek smile, then adds, “Also, he is helping me with my page. Editing, videography, and… well… performing…”

Olivia gazes over at you with a stern eye. She is no longer self conscious about opening gandering at your full monty. You cover up even more and shift around in place anxiously. “Hmm… so that would explain that…” she surmises.

“Don Juan here thought he would try and swoon you into joining in!” Chelsea chuckles.

“By greeting me naked?” Olivia asks.

“Poor Icarus tried to fly too close to the sun,” Sabrina laughs. “Everyone here was so eager to get him undressed, it must have gotten to his head that it was all he needed to do to get into your panties!”

“John wanted to fuck all of us and ended up holding his own dick in his hand!” Skylar smugly notes. You look down and realize that she’s right.

“Aww, it’s true!” you roll your eyes back and lament. As everyone shares a giggle, Olivia is no longer on edge.

“Wait…” Olivia says, holding her finger up and waving it at both of her friends. They look awfully conspicuous to her wearing next to nothing. “Were you two… with him? Before I came in?” Skylar and Chelsea give guilty smiles and squirm a bit. “OH MY GOD!” Olivia says in complete shock. “At the same time?!” Chelsea covers her face and Skylar looks up. “OH MY GOD!”

You can’t help but feel a little embarrassed at the new girl’s revelations. You don’t know how intimate her relationship is with her two friends and this could be quite the truck drop on her.

“So you want to join us?” Skylar invites.

“What?” Olivia gasps.