Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 27 by UF UF

What's happening elsewhere?

Cabin of Lust

Spending most of the evening mingling with the other contestants, Peter found himself enjoying getting to know some of the people who would be staying with him that week and it was just as he finished a conversation with Sara that he found himself being interrupted by none other than Heather.

"Hey, care to talk a walk?" Heather asked Peter who nodded in agreement, and he bid Sara goodbye before stepping away with Heather.

Together the pair found themselves leaving the building and making their way out into the night, walking towards the cabins Peter noted.

"So, what's been going on with you? You certainly have been busy since the last time I saw you," Peter wondered. "I mean, you didn't have a relationship with your cousin the last time we met."

"Well, someone reminded me that family is important the last time we met," Heather commented.

"It is, I don't know what I would do or who I would be without Elsa and the others," Peter admitted.

"I don't know, I think you'd be okay," Heather reassured Peter. "No matter what universe or what happens, some things like your heart don't change and you've got a good heart. What's going on with you?"

"Nothing, stuff like this gets you thinking, you know?" Peter shook his head. "Rex and Tish they're doing this to establish a legacy for themselves. Handpicking the next generation of detectives and speaking to some of them, it does make you wonder what kind of legacy you want... The legacy your parents left for you..."

"I get that. You know I do..." Heather told Peter who nodded in agreement, knowing of the brunette's ambition to continue her family's business of running Ravers Enterprises. "But we have time to decide what kind of legacy we want to leave behind and who we want to leave it behind for."

"I know and I know you said you're not seeing anyone but the way you said that, has someone caught your eye back home? Or has Andrew finally caught some sense and decided he wants you?" Peter curiously said causing Heather to laugh.

"No..." Heather shook her head. "And what about you? You broke up with your girlfriends you said and now you’re on a team with all girls and you seem close to nearly all of them."

"What's that supposed to mean?" Peter responded.

"Just you have a rep..." Heather shrugged.

"One of them is my sister, don't forget?" Peter reminded Heather.

"Certainly wouldn't stop you, right?" Heather told Peter.

"You speaking from experience, Heather?" Peter fired back at her. "Something you want to tell me about you and Zack?"

"God, no! That would be weird." Heather shook her head causing the pair to laugh.

"I've missed you. We certainly don't see each other as often as we should." Peter admitted.

"Yeah, but it makes this that much sweeter..." Heather playfully said as she leaned in to give Peter a soft kiss which he began to return until finally they parted, and Heather looked over her shoulder at the cabin behind them. "Cabin one's empty, am I right?"

"If I remember correctly," Peter responded.

"Come on..." Heather said as she took Peter's hand and began to lead him up the steps of the cabin. "It's time for us to get reacquainted..."

Making their way inside, Peter and Heather found that the layout of the cabin was similar to their own cabins but was caught off guard by the two naked blondes, one of whom Peter knew all too well as they made out with one another. Kelsey McNamara and Rachel White.

“Oh, we didn’t realise this cabin was taken…” Heather said out loud, getting the two blondes' attention who slowly parted from one another.

“Don’t be. It’s good to know we’re not the only ones with the right kind of idea.” Rachel responded.

“And it seems the stars are aligning,” Kelsey said.

“What do you mean by that?” Peter said curiously.

“Someone was a little curious about one of the recruits,” Kelsey said while eyeing Peter and indicating to Rachel with her head. “Luckily for her, I had taught him everything he knew so I was telling her about his very impressive tool and well one thing led to another and he’s standing before us…” Kelsey spoke before looking over at Heather. “And he brought a very scrumptious friend…”

“Heather Ravers is scrumptious,” Rachel agreed. “And Peter Grayson is a lot more impressive in person… He must be one hell of a fuck…”

“He is. I taught him everything…” Kelsey reminded the other blonde.

“Wait… Taught him… You’re Kelsey McNamara? Peter’s first…” Heather said in realisation. “I should thank you. He’s shown me some good times…”

“I bet he did,” Kelsey grinned before proudly telling Peter. “Attaboy,” Kelsey smiled before asking Heather. “Care to share him?”

“Erm… Of course…” Heather nervously spoke while she had no prior experience of sharing a guy with another girl, the heiress was open to new experiences and she could already tell with Rachel and Kelsey around she would never be in a more comfortable environment.

At the same time, Peter found himself surprised that this was happening, especially since he didn’t think his time at the challenge would ever bring up such an opportunity and he watched as Kelsey and Rachel went back to making out with one another while exploring each other’s bodies and he turned to look at Heather who just simply smirked at him.

“I guess this is what it’s like to be in your orbit full-time, huh?” Heather commented.

“God, no…” Peter shook his head. “If it was, I don’t think I would survive…”

“Shall we find out?” Heather teasingly responded before leaning in and treating Peter to a soft kiss that he returned, their tongues meeting in a frenzied battle as they began to undress one another so that they were just as naked as the two blonde bombshells who were now sixty-nineing on one of the beds.

Growing rock-hard at the sight before him and the raven-haired beauty who was still kissing him and just as naked as he was and felt Heather wrap her hand around his member and he moved his hands from her waist and up to her heavenly large breasts, taking them both into his hands, teasing his old lover and flicking her nipples causing Heather to close her eyes while Peter began to pepper kisses along the milky skin of her neck.

“I’ve missed you… And how good you make me feel…” Heather admitted softly as Peter continued his actions, moving from her neck to her cleavage, taking one of her nipples into his mouth, eliciting a moan from the brunette.

Enjoying the feeling of Peter’s attack on her breasts, it was after a few minutes of him enjoying that feeling and Heather jerking him off as he did, that the pair parted, and Peter watched as Heather slowly sank to her knees so that she was face to face with hard cock.

Teasing his head with her tongue, swirling around and causing Peter to groan, Peter watched as Heather slowly took his dick into her mouth, inch by inch until it hit the back of her throat, just after taking half of his length into her mouth and he watched as Heather’s blue eyes met his as she started to bob her head up and down his length while using her hands to jerk off whatever she couldn’t fit into her mouth.

“Fuckin’ hell, Heather,” Peter groaned out in pleasure as he caressed her brown hair. “You’re still one of the best cocksuckers I know…”

“It helps you’ve got a really good dick…” Heather responded as she took her mouth off Peter’s lengthy dick for a breath of air before moving her mouth back to his member trailing it with kisses. “Such as nice, big, hard dick…”

Peter watched as Heather took his dick back into her mouth, bobbing up and down his length while he caressed her hair, guiding his old friend and lover as she sucked his dick and he also noticed that his old friend was now playing with her pussy as she did.

“Oh fuck, Kelsey…” Rachel moaned out, alerting Peter to the two blondes who were now scissoring each other on the bed and action Peter couldn’t deny was really hot and he found himself instinctively sinking another inch of his dick into Heather’s mouth, causing the brunette to gag along his length.

Turned on by the sight of Kelsey and Rachel and Heather’s blowjob, Peter removed his cock from Heather’s mouth and helped the heiress to her feet before treating her to another kiss, cupping her curvy ass and lifting her up into the air. Heather immediately wrapped her legs around Peter’s waist, continuing their kiss as Peter brought them to the bed where Kelsey and Rachel both were and dropped the brunette onto the bed just before they were and without wasting any more time Peter slammed his cock into her wet hole.

“Holy shit, Peter! I forgot how big you were!” Heather moaned as Peter slowly began to unsheath his cock before slamming it back into her warm pussy.

Thrusting his dick in and out of Heather’s pussy, Peter used one of his free hands to tease her clit while the other went to one of her breasts, flicking and teasing her nipples causing his lover to moan out loud. At the same time, Peter noticed that Kelsey and Rachel had stopped their own actions and instead were watching the two teens fuck and it was then that they moved.

Peter watched as Rachel approached making her way to Heather’s head before leaning in and kissing the brunette, an action that made Peter thrust harder into Heather. The sight of the two heiress kissing was enough to spur Peter on who continued to fuck away at her increasingly wet hole and it got even hotter for the teen when the two finally parted.

“Care to help a girl out?” Rachel asked Heather as she indicated to her own glistening snatch and Heather’s eyes followed.

“I’ve never… But I guess tonight is a night for firsts…” Heather answered.

“ A girl like you, you’ll be fine…” Rachel responded as she lowered her pussy down to Heather's mouth and Peter watched as Heather’s hands took hold of Rachel’s smooth legs while her tongue darted out to eat the older blonde out.

At the same time, Peter felt arms around his waist to feel his rock-hard abs while a head sat on his shoulder as he continued to thrust in and out of Heather.

“Have I ever told you, you were my best student?” Kelsey told Peter.

“Every damn time we get together…” Peter grunted before mashing his lips against Kelsey’s, their tongues meeting in a wild passionate kiss that spurred Peter on to fuck Heather even harder.

“Oh shit, Heather! That’s it!” Rachel moaned out only for her to squeal out as Heather pushed the blonde off of her head.

“Oh my God, Peter! I’m cummiinnngggg!” Heather yelled out as her orgasm washed over her and Peter could feel her juices coating his length.

Allowing the brunette some respite as she recovered from her orgasm, Peter stopped thrusting and slowly began to pull out, only to find himself being pushed flat onto the bed by Kelsey who gave him one last kiss before going lower to join Rachel who was already staring at his hard cock.

“You weren’t kidding Kels, Peter Grayson does have a really nice cock…” Rachel told the blonde.

“And it’s coated in Heather Raver’s honey… I bet it is just as sweet…” Kelsey admitted.

“You should try her out, she’s a natural at eating pussy…” Rachel suggested.

“Must be my Ravers genes…” Heather joked as she joined the two blondes who were now teasing Peter’s hard length with their hands.

“Holy fuck…” Peter said in awe of the three beauties who were now face to face with his length, a dream he was certain many would kill to be in and he couldn't believe it when Kelsey took his length into her mouth while Rachel and Heather began to tease his balls.

Peter watched and groaned in pleasure as the three gorgeous women took turns sucking his dick, each one passing to the other while the other two teased his sack and he couldn’t help but enjoy the feeling each time two of the girls swirled their tongues along his tip as they swapped over and he couldn’t believe when Rachel took his dick into her mouth, hitting the back of her throat around the halfway point of his length and Kelsey and Heather used their tongues to tease the rest of his length.

It was after a few minutes of having the three women sucking his dick, Peter knew that he would need his cock back in a warm hole and as if she sensed his need, Peter found Rachel climbing up, turned around so he could see her ass and sank his length into her well-turned-on pussy while he found his hands moving to her waist, guiding her down his length until she took all of him.

“You’re tight…” Peter groaned, surprised by the way the blonde’s walls hugged his length.

“I’ve… Never had something big in there… In a while…” Rachel breathed out.

Letting the blonde get used to his length for a few seconds, Peter’s hands moved from her waist. lifting the blonde up and then slowly sinking her back down. At the same time, Rachel’s hands moved back to lean on Peter’s pecs and it was in-between moans and Peter’s actions that the blonde finally met Peter’s actions and began to bounce up and down his length unaided and Peter too began to thrust in and out of Rachel’s tight hole while fondling her ass.

“That’s it… Fuck me, Peter. Fuck me with that massive dick…” Rachel moaned before yelling out and saying. “Oh shit, that’s it, Heather…”

Curious Peter looked over to the side of Rachel to see Heather on all fours where Peter and Rachel’s joined and was now teasing the blonde’s heiress’s clit with her tongue which turned Rachel on even more and as a result continued to bounce up and down Peter’s length even faster. Peter also found it curious as to where Kelsey had gone but quickly found the answer when the blonde kissed Peter once more.

“Such a fucking stud…” Kelsey told Peter. “Now care to show me if you remember everything I taught you…”

“Gladly.” Peter grinned before watching as the blonde lowered her wet hole to his head.

Lost to pleasure and the moans echoing across the cabin, Peter still couldn’t believe he was in a position where Rachel White was riding his cock while Heather Ravers teased her clit and occasionally his cock while at the same time he was eating out Kelsey McNamara’s pussy.

"Holy shit! That's it! Eat me out!" Kelsey moaned as she writhed and moaned. "Fuck, yeah! You're so fucking good at that!" Kelsey softly moaned as Peter began to saw two of his fingers in and out of Kelsey's snug hole, his fingers becoming wet with her juices while Peter began to nibble away at her clit. "My prize student. That's it, Peter..."

The moans continued to echo and Peter started to recognise that both Kelsey and Rachel were both getting close to their own orgasms and so he doubled down on his efforts by adding a third finger into Kelsey’s pussy and he thrust even harder into Rachel until finally, they both let out a wild banshee scream as their orgasms washed over them and Peter could taste Kelsey’s sweet nectar as it leaked out of her pussy and all over Peter's waiting mouth.

Peter then lifted Kelsey off of his head and watched as Rachel finally took his length out of her snug hole and Peter turned to his first-ever lover and brought his lips to hers in a wild frenzied kiss that allowed the blonde to taste her own juices.

"Give me that big, fucking cock... Pound my pussy... Stretch me out. Fill me with your hard dick!" Kelsey yelled out as Peter did as he was told and pushed his rock-hard dick into Kelsey's snug pussy.

"Fuck, yeah..." Peter groaned as he slowly began to thrust his dick in and out of her pussy.

"Oh shit! Fuck me!" Kelsey yelled out. "Holy crap! That's it, baby! Don't stop! Fuck me!" Kelsey moaned and Peter continued to do as his first lover instructed, pounding away into her hole.

At the same time, Heather had wrapped her arms around Peter’s waist while her head rested on his shoulder, similar to the way Kelsey had done to him earlier and Peter felt her breasts squish into his back and mashing her lips against his, treating him to a wild, frenzied kiss. Rachel on the other hand, flanked his left, caressing his well-built, muscular body, peppering it with kisses and showing much attention to his scars and some of his tattoos.

Peter meanwhile started to piston his dick in and out of her pussy, groaning as he moved his cock faster and faster inside of Kelsey’s pussy. Kelsey tried hard not to moan, biting her lip to stop herself and she closed her eyes in pleasure. Peter felt Kelsey clenching her muscles in her nether regions, causing Peter to push in and out harder, relishing in the tightness of her clenched pussy as he continued to pound into her. Kelsey soon began to buck her hips into his thrusts causing her moans to get louder and more chaotic and the bed to squeak louder and louder.

“I’m cumming, Peter… You’re making me cum.” Kelsey screamed as her orgasm washed over her.

Feeling himself getting close too, Peter pulled out of Kelsey and climbed off the bed and watched as the three women followed him, getting on their knees before him, one taking his dick into his mouth while the other two stimulated his balls, swapping between each other and causing Peter to groan out in pleasure until finally, he erupted.

The first spurt splattered across Heather’s face who happened to be in the middle and in a straight direction with Peter’s member with the next hitting Kelsey’s face followed by Rachel’s. Peter continued to erupt, firing rope after rope of cum across the brunette and two blondes' faces and painting a few breasts with his cum too before taking a step back to admire the three beauties.

“Holy shit… I can’t believe we did that.” Heather said in disbelief as if the realisation of what they had all done was now becoming aware to her.

“Believe it..” Kelsey grinned.

What Happens Next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)