Bring both girls to the office

“Alice you’re coming with me too,” you say. “You know those undies aren’t allowed. Both of you girls follow me. Erica, don’t think you’re being let off easy. You will still have your inspection in my office along with your punishment for bullying.”

The girls follow you to your office. It’s up to you how you want to proceed with their punishments. Anything that happens in your office is carefully monitored and recorded. Teachers, faculty, and even students might be able to view the punishments located in a punishment folder. There is no privacy in your office. You have an extra camera to take photographs for your record which also aren’t private.

You also have multiple means of punishment whether it be paddling, caning for serious instances, hairbrushes, or whatever you deem is appropriate punishment.

But you can only punish one girl at a time. So who do you decide to punish first? Erica or Alice?