Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 123 by Samus1001 Samus1001

What's next?

Body Pillow

The smell of bacon and eggs frying is what woke Caleb. He lifted his head off Sonia's breast and looked toward the kitchen, but couldn't quite see inside from where he lay. He tried to pull his morning wood out of Sonia without waking her, but was unsuccessful.

She pulled him back down, forcing his cock back inside her and kissed him. "Good morning, my love. I hope you slept well."

She released him and he got off of her as he chuckled, "Yeah, you make a great pillow. What about you though? It couldn’t have been comfortable with me on top of you all night.”

She laughed as she stretched and giggled, “Best nights sleep ever. You left a load of cum in me. With its power to heal, there was no chance you sleeping on me would leave me sore or kink my muscles.”

She kissed him again and headed to the guest room. Over her shoulder she snickered, "You might wanna take a quick shower before breakfast. As much as I love your manly scent, we don't want to break your mom's table with all of us fighting to get you inside us."

Standing under the spray of the shower, Caleb took his time washing as he went over the events of the previous day. He was surprised by the sheer number of times he came, but the fact that he bred over half a dozen women as well boggled his mind.

His thoughts were interrupted by Kathy stepping into the shower with him. She pulled him to bend slightly so she could kiss him passionately. One of her hands wrapped around his cock and she began to jack him as she playfully said, "So, I noticed Sonia's breasts are bigger. You got something you wanna tell me, Mister Stretcher King?”

He stammered as she placed his hardened cock between her huge breasts. Thanks to the differences in their height, and the humongous size of her breasts, she was short enough to give him a titty fuck without the need to kneel or even bend over very much. She looked up at him expectantly as she rubbed her massive knockers along his shaft.

She laughed at his failure to speak and decided to be merciful, sweetly saying, “I spoke to her just before I came in here. I’m not mad you know. I figured it was only a matter of time before you claimed her. It doesn’t bother me that you planted a baby in her either, the whole house knew she wanted it. Did you forget that you put one in mine and Angie’s moms. I can’t really complain, now can I? We figure you’ll claim Amelia soon and probably April and Melissa too. I didn’t expect to have a servant though.”

She bent down to lick the tip of his cock as it poked out from between her jugs. She waited in that position patiently swirling her tongue around his cockhead until he said, “I figured she’s been a big help with the harem, so she belonged to be in it. Besides, you need someone to be in charge when you're not around.”

Kathy resumed jerking him with her tits so her mouth was free to speak. “That’s what I thought. So she’s more like my second in command then. You know, I’m very jealous that you slept with your cock inside her. I’m almost tempted to let you breed me, just so we can sleep like that.”

The mental image of him sleeping on her giant marshmallows put him right on the verge of cumming. Suddenly she released his cock from her cleavage. She laughed at his expression and said, “We need to save that load for breakfast. We gave the last of your cum as gifts to our guests last night. You didn’t do a very good job of saving any yesterday with all the breeding and healing you did.”

All of a sudden Kathy became pensive. She looked up at the man she had devoted herself to. "Caleb, you know I love you right? That I'm yours forever and always? That you can ask me for anything?"

He pulled her close and held her to him, "Hey, what's all this? Of course I know you love me. I love you too. Why the sudden dreary mood?"

Kathy hugged him tight, resting her head on his chest and said, "I know you asked Sonia if you could do anal with her. I just... I... I wanna be perfect for you and..."

Caleb laughed loudly and said, "That's what's bothering you. That I asked someone else."

He bent down to kiss her and said, "I didn't ask her as some kind of snub to you. I asked her because I was curious to know if I'd like it, and she knows more about sex than all of us put together. Besides, I like looking at you when we have sex. I like looking into your eyes, or see the cute faces you make when you cum. Haven't you noticed I only ever do you doggy style when you're eating someone out? I didn't ask you because you're too special to me to do you in the butt. And would you even want to? Don't say yes just because you think it's what I wanna hear. A perfect girlfriend would tell me what she wants, no matter what she thinks I want. So turn honesty to on, and tell me, do you want me to do you in the butt?"

Kathy could feel her heart lift. She smiled up at him as she said, "I do not want you to fuck my ass. Ever. But, I do want you to be more aggressive with me. Grab my titties and play with them whenever you want, no matter where we are, or what we're doing. Pull my clothes off and just take me. You could fuck me on a table in the Pit and I'd love it. You're a Stretcher King. My Stretcher King. And I'm your girlfriend, the leader of your harem. Use me for your pleasure, and love me when you're done. Use my body as your bed and my titties as your pillow. If there is something you want, ask me. It's my job to get it for you, even if I'm not the one who does it."

"Okay my little Harem Queen. I get it. Your upset that I asked Sonia without going through you first."

Kathy opened her mouth to speak but he spun her around and pushed her against the shower wall. He bit her shoulder and reached between her legs. His fingers found her slit and he mashed and rubbed her clit as he growled in her ear, "Is this what you wanted, my little slut? You want me to remind you who you belong to? Hmmm?"

"Oh god yes! Please Caleb! Use me! Use my body to please you. Use it and show me my place."

Caleb ran his free hand down her ass. He reared back and smacked her butt so hard she jumped. He used his foot to push her legs apart. His free hand reached up under her ass and he rammed two fingers in and out of her slit as the other hand rubbed her clit faster and harder. He demanded, "Cum for me. Cum for me and prove you love me. Cum for me and show me you are mine."

Kathy stood on her tip toes as she screamed out. She collapsed against Caleb. He grabbed her around the waist to keep her from falling.

When she was able to stand on her own again, he pecked her on the lips and said, "Feel better now?"

She stuck out her bottom lip and pouted, "No... I'm still not pregnant."

He laughed and said, "Go on. Get out of here my little Harem Queen. You want me to be more aggressive then I will. But that means I get to breed you when I want. No more telling me no."

As she stepped out of the shower she smirked, “Yes my King. Breed me anytime you want, just make sure you breed Chris too, so we can raise our babies together. Now don’t take too long babe. Your harem is starving. We burned a lot of calories last night, and we need your special protein as part of a balanced diet.”

She shook her plump ass at him, her huge wobbling tits visible even from behind, as she grabbed a towel and left the room.

Caleb hurried up in the shower. After he got out he opened the drawer he kept his watch in. Picking it up, he yelped and dropped it again as it burned his fingers. Looking down he saw the seconds hand wildly spinning.

"Oh, shit." he muttered, wondering how and why the seconds hand was going so fast. He hadn't created any new normalities recently. Or he didn't intend to anyway.


“-and that’s when she told me she was a founding member of the Oyster room. She invited you all to attend their next orgy.” Melissa was saying as Caleb entered the kitchen. He noticed that all of the women were in varying states of dress. Amelia, Kathy, and Gabbie were cooking breakfast. Their only articles of clothing were their aprons and high heels. Most of the younger women were wearing just their panties, their breasts on display, a smorgasbord for his eyes. The older women wore a mix of robes and night gowns.

Hazel, seated on Tina's lap, nearly spilled her juice as she exclaimed, “Oh wow! That’s the most exclusive lesbian sex club in the city!”

Angie was bouncing in her seat, causing an amazing jiggle with her breasts, as she said, “Yeah, the only way in is to be sponsored by a member.”

Melissa added, “Well, she said they would waive that requirement for all the harem members as well as the other women Caleb owns. She was practically drooling when she made the offer. They even want Caleb to come.”

Caleb sat at the table and asked, “What’s all this now?”

Kathy, wearing just an apron and high heels, pulled Caleb’s chair away from the table so she could extract his cock from his robe. She began stroking him as she said, “One of the ladies at the cocktail party Melissa went to last night invited all of us to the next orgy at the Oyster room.”

Melissa chimed in saying, “Not just any lady. It was Joanna Dukat. She owns half the lesbian bars in the city, and she also owns the Muff brand of sex toys.”

Angie piped up with, “Hey, I was using one of their strap-ons last night. And aren’t you wearing a Muff brand butt plug Sonia?”

Amelia laughed at the expressions on the faces of some of the women and explained, “Caleb asked Sonia if he could to try anal sex with her, and Sonia said okay, but she’s never done it before. I let her know she needs to stretch herself out a bit first, and helped her put the plug in. He’ll kill her with that huge donkey dick if she isn't ready for it.”

Megumi pointed out, “It’s too bad stretching doesn’t work on our butts like it does on our kitties. I don’t like anal even with small toys. Caleb would split me in half.”

Tina spoke up then, “You can try it out on me if you like Caleb. I love butt sex. You’re only a little bigger than the biggest I’ve had back there. Oh hey, Hazel, why don’t you use a strap-on in my pussy at the same time? I haven’t been DPed in months.”

Hazel rolled her eyes and sarcastically said, “Oh yeah. We can get one of the other girls to wear one too and make you air tight.”

The sarcasm went right past Tina as she shouted, “Oh hell yes! I’ve never done that before, but I’ve always wanted to. Hazel you’re a genius!” Tina pulled her girlfriend in for a very passionate kiss.

Caleb moaned as the mental pictures the ladies painted put him over the edge. Kathy quickly adjusted to stroke his cock over the nut milk jar. Chris came over to aid in jacking him off, and Kathy removed her apron, setting the jar between her melons. His toes curled as he began blasting his load. Kathy encouraged him, “Cum from me babe. Give us lots of your yummy cummy.”

He shot blast after blast, most of it going in the jar, but he left a good amount splattered across her tits. Chris dove in to lick up the mess as Kathy held up the jar and proudly stated, “Damn love, that’s the most you’ve ever given us. It’s almost full from one round. You must like the idea of fucking Tina's ass.”

As he panted against the chair he muttered, “Can you blame me? If she's got the experience to do it, I'd rather try it with her than possibly hurt Sonia. But what's this about lesbian sex clubs? I didn’t know that was a real thing.”

Gabbie and Angie knelt beside Caleb, licking and sucking the remaining cum off his cock, as Megumi said, “Well, they’re not all strictly lesbians. Lots of married women join too if they’re not getting what they need from their husbands. It’s better than cheating on them, and also they can’t get pregnant. Well, unless you come along and breed them, but then their husbands would love that anyway. I was a member of one for a while after Angie's dad died. They're a lot of fun. I never realized how much I missed being in a woman's arms until our threesome with Angie. They really helped me get over my husband's ****.”

Caleb had nearly forgotten that he had created a normality last night that made sexual experimentation between women normal as well as making it so that lesbian sex wasn’t considered cheating. These lesbian sex clubs must have been created when reality shifted again. Previously, Megumi had never been with a woman before the threesome with her daughter, but with the reality shift she had.

It seemed that might also explain the relaxed clothing environment this morning. Usually the girls are mostly dressed when they come to breakfast, but today over half of them were topless. He thought about the implications and a thought occurred to him. He said, “I’m not sure we should all attend at once. If this club as exclusive as you say, it might make us look like we think we are better than others.”

Sonia said, “He’s right. As a Stretcher King, his public image should be our top priority. I think if any of us do go, it shouldn’t be more than two or three and Caleb shouldn’t be there the first time. If we do decide to go, we need to go to other clubs as well, so that we aren’t seen as sticking with any one group.”

Kathy put her arms around Sonia, resting them over her womb. She kissed her neck and said, "Does the Sisterhood have a lot of influence with lesbian clubs? I would think that they run a lot of them, just like they do convents."

Sonia pulled Kathy around and onto her lap. They kissed briefly then Sonia caressed and squeezed Kathy's cummy boobs while saying, "In other parts of the world sure, but not here. Most of the clubs in this country are either run by true lesbians or rich women who are bored with their husbands but too loyal to cheat. True lesbians don't want us around because they don't like our devotion to Stretcher Kings. Of course, if Caleb were to attend they would be fighting over his cock, they just don't like our religious devotion. It was true lesbians that created the term 'cock worshipers' in the feminist movement of the 60's. They did an impressive job of closing us out of the movement in the US. It didn't work in Europe, but we had a lot more influence there to begin with. For the rich women, being in a lesbian club is more a status symbol than anything else. Those kinds of clubs are all about strict hierarchy. The only thing they really care about is power, and lording it over the members from more modest backgrounds. New members tend to be treated like servants, which doesn't meld very well with the sisterhoods beliefs on equality."

Kathy leaned forward and kissed Sonia, their tits mashing together. When she pulled back she said, "I'm sorry I got so jealous earlier. I really am happy that Caleb claimed and bred you. Could we maybe spend some time alone, like on a date or something?"

Sonia giggled and kissed the top of Kathy's breast licking up a glob of cum Chris missed, "As your servant, you can do anything you like with me, my Queen."

Tina stopped making out with Hazel to make gagging noises as Sonia and Kathy kissed, “There is too much lovey dovey crap around here. That’s great and all but, back on topic, I’ve got the most experience getting fucked in the ass, so I should go first so I can teach you all how to do it right.”

A relieved Sonia said, "I second that idea. Sorry Caleb, I'll still do it if you like. I'm curious myself now, but I'm a little scared too."

Hazel smacked Tina's ass and said, “You only want to do it just so you can get double teamed.”

Tina smacked her huge ass back and said, “No, I wanna get triple teamed. Hey! If we wait till your mom gets home, I can get fucked by the whole family! Brother, sister, and mom! It would be like a dream come true!”

As everyone laughed Tina added, "Ok, how about a show of hands, who all wants to try taking Caleb up the butt?"

Sonia raised her hand, followed by Melissa and Amelia. Amelia said, "It's not really my thing, but I'll do it. I've never had one your size though Caleb, so be gentle."

Melissa said, "I know I like it rough, but be gentle with me back there too. I just want you to **** me when you do it. Tell me things like my pussy isn't good enough for your cock, or the only way you can cum is using my ass. Things like that."

Gabbie looked over at her and whistled, "Man, that's really weird. Do you really get off on that kind of thing?"

Melissa smiled at Gabbie, "Oh god yes. It wouldn't work with just any guy. In fact, with most guys it would be a total turn off. But Caleb is so perfect and manly he just hits ALL my buttons. I can't wait till he is comfortable enough to slap me while he uses me. Not hard enough to bruise or anything, but enough of a sting that it lights a fire in me."

She didn't mention that she wanted Caleb to mark her permanently. She pictured a womb tattoo or one that said something like 'Caleb's cumdump'. She knew Caleb wasn't ready for anything like that yet.

At last, slowly, Angie also raised her hand. Her mother asked, "Baby, are you sure? No one is pressuring you to do it."

Angie meekly said, "I'm sure mom. I'm just a little scared that's all. I want to try everything with Caleb at least once. He's my best friend, and I've loved him for a long time. If there is something he likes, I wanna try it."

Tina saw that no one else was going to try, so she said, "Okay, I've got plenty of plugs here to start you all out. We'll use the smallest ones and work our way to bigger as you get used to them. I'll get lots of lube and some anal toys at the store today and we can practice more later."

Amelia, Gabbie, and April started laying out breakfast. As they did so Kathy suggested, “Melissa, why don’t you sit on Caleb’s lap and go for a ride, since you didn’t get any of him last night.”

Melissa didn’t need convincing. She rushed over to him but he held up his hand. “Would you mind if someone else got a turn instead? I already planned to play with you sometime around lunch.”

Kathy asked, “I thought we weren’t planning out a sex schedule? And what exactly did you have planned today that you can’t stay and help pack?”

He smiled at her as he indicated for Katie to come ride him. “It’s a secret. I’ll need Melissa, April, and Tina to go out with me. I have something planned for this evening that I need their help with. I don’t know how long it will take though.”


If you like the story so far consider buying me a cup of coffee at https://ko-fi.com/samus1001

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)