Betrayal

You laid there, basking in the soft afterglow of what had just happened before you saw Piper's hand reach down, touching the seed leaking from her hole before with a strength that you didn't expect, she shoved Phoebe off of her.

"What the hell Phoebe! Why'd you let him cum in me?!" Piper's face held a righteous, yet slightly fearful rage as she exerted her position as the older sister, demanding answers from Phoebe.

"Come on Piper, you looked like you were having the time of your life, and it feels so amazing when Leo gives you a big creampie like that." Phoebe, on the other hand, didn't seem to be notice Piper's indignation, apparently still basking in the afterglow of her own orgasm.

"1: That's beside the point, and 2: I'm not on birth control!" Piper yelled.

"Huh, well if it's such a big deal, why not?" Phoebe replied. You were beginning to wonder if they'd simply forgotten you were still in the room or if Piper had attempted to use her powers to give them a moment of privacy.

"Because I told you, I've never slept with a guy on the first date, part of prepping for that is getting on the pill or stocking up on condoms. God, Leo probably thinks I'm such a slut now, I don't know what came over me... I threw myself at him, let him do whatever he wanted, and may have gotten knocked up by my sister's boyfriend..." Piper was devolving into low mutters, and looked to be on the verge of a breakdown.

"Hey hey, it's okay." Phoebe hugged Piper from behind, her nude chest squishing into Piper's side, attempting to comfort her hurting sister.

But it wasn't to be, as Phoebe's touch or words, or something seemed to remind Piper of her anger bubbling below the surface as she shrugged Phoebe off of her, "Okay, NO it's NOT OKAY! Maybe you're okay stealing our boyfriends, but I'm not like that!" Piper yelled, turning and hurrying out the room, slamming the door behind her. Even before it fully closed you could hear Piper talking to herself, "Gotta get another shower, and I'm late for that job, I'll just have to grab something at the pharmacy on the way."

Phoebe, on the other hand, looked like someone had slapped her, and rightfully so considered Piper's words. You knew something about sisters so hopefully they would make up soon.

Deciding this was the moment to make yourself reknown, you softly rubbed Phoebe's back as you heard a soft sniffle.

"I thought she'd be happy, I-I I could see the way she was sad about the men in her life, and I saw how happy she was when you'd sit with her, talk with her, I thought she'd be happy that she got to have sex with you." Phoebe muttered as you pulled her into you.

"Look Phoebe, I'm not going to sit here and say it's going to be okay, and be the rock you need right now. In fact, I'm pretty ticked off myself at the stunt you pulled." You said and Phoebe pulled away enough so she could turn to see your irritated face.

"Huh?" Was her intelligent answer.

"I specifically told you not to use that spell again, and what did you do?" You said rhetorically as you continued on. "Not to mention, consider how Piper feels, she's caught in a whirlpool of emotions now, if she has anything resembling genuine feelings for me, which she probably knew she had to squash, now she's going to be not only worried about how I think of her, but still trapped by the knowledge that I'm your boyfriend, and just a friends-with-benefits with me, she probably feels like your were rubbing her face in how great the sex with me was. Not to mention she's going to be worried about how Prue will take this, and don't even try to say Prue wouldn't care, otherwise you wouldn't have waited until she had left before pulling this stunt!" The Leo train was picking up steam and in lieu of Phoebe's silence kept going.

"I know this is hard to hear, especially considering everything leading up to it, but how do you see us, our relationship, because as it stands, we're pretty good on the intimacy part of things, but outside of the bedroom..." You trailed off, leaving Phoebe to draw her own conclusions. "I'm not trying to add to the karma brigade, but that comment about how you thought Piper would be happy to have sex with me, do you think that's Pipers problem, that she doesn't have someone to have sex with, and if she did then she'd be alright? Because that's not what Piper was looking for, is why I'm asking, Piper is a romanticist, and you are her sister, so you should know better." You whispered as Phoebe sighed unhappily.

Finally deciding that Phoebe had endured enough scolding for one day, you squeezed her against you, ignoring her soft flesh, "Don't cry, this too shall pass." You said as you softly kissed her forehead.

"Hm, when did you get so wise?" She mumbled back as you smiled.

"About the same time you got so beautiful." You replied as Phoebe said silent, content to enjoy the moment for now.

"I also broke the downstairs shower as part of my plan, so I'mma need you to fix that." She dropped the bomb on you, shattering the small window of tranquility.

You said nothing, but let out a long sigh.