Back to the Future

Tim's cock pulsed as Sarah continued her story about the first time she had fucked him. Something about it was undeniably sexy even if it was against his will. After all Sarah and Haley had both featured in his fantasies, more and more ever since that Halloween now that he thought about it.

Sarah stopped speaking and just looked at Tim's throbbing cock, "Enjoying the story," She meant this to come out teasingly, instead it was this sort of distracted tone that managed to make Tim even more horny.

Tim gritted his teeth, "You raped me."

Sarah looked in Tim's eyes, "Spoilers, I haven't gotten to that part yet," Sarah pointed at Chloe, "And she helped so does it really count."

"Yes," Tim half-shouted.

"Hey," a knock was heard on the door, "You and Chloe can't keep him to yourselves all night."

Sarah grabbed Tim's cock causing him to throw his head back as she squeezed causing a jolt of pleasure to shoot through him.

"You need to go out there," Sarah said, "Clothing optional."

"No way," Tim panted.

"Yes way," Sarah squeezed hard and precum started rolling down Tim's cock, "If you want to hear the rest of the story you'll go out there and behave for the rest of the night." Sarah began stroking Tim's aching cock, "Otherwise I'm just going to let the girls in and we'll do as we please with you," more precum leaked out of Tim's cock, "Just like we have done at every party since Halloween."