Attempted Two Versus Two

Matt snored soundly and happily as he laid in one of the massive beds in the abandoned Madwell mansion. It really helped that his face was also sandwiched between the breasts of Ashley and Mia Autumn, and had a hand cupping one asscheek each.

"Mia, you have to stand up to these bullies better!" Ashley whispered.

"I can't help it Ashley, they're stronger and smarter than me!" Mia complained, "Plus they're the mayor's kids, who is going to be on my side if I complain?"

"That's true..." Ashley stopped to think, "But there's gotta be some way to get them to lay off you..."

Suddenly, the door to the room opened.

Ashley and Mia turned, expecting Wade to have come back with Wendy. But to their horror, instead there were two large Cryptid men standing in the doorway. Mia screamed, waking Matt up.

"Wh-what the hell is this!?" he yelled in terror.

"So these are the rascals having fun in this place," the bird-looking man said.

"Can't complain, they brought some fine women with them. I was fucking two of them while waiting for you," the reptile-looking man with big horns replied.

"Aw that's no fair, I call dibs on these two then!" the bird Cryptid argued.

"Whatever, suit yourself," the reptile Cryptid said, "I smell another one anyways."

Smell another one? Fucking two of them? He must be talking about my friends! Ashley realized.

"Mia, I need your help!" Ashley whispered.

"With what?" Mia asked.

"Those two Cryptids over by the door, I need you to help me distract them," Ashley pleaded.

"H-how!?" she asked.

Matt leapt off of the women, buck naked.

"T-take those women, please spare me!" he cried as he ran for the door.

"What a wimp," the bird Cryptid chuckled, "Alright go find your other one while I get my threesome that I'm owed."

"Wait!" Ashley exclaimed, getting off the bed, "Y-you're no match for us!"

"Huh?" the reptile Cryptid said, "This little lady thinks she can fight us?"

"Not fight! Fuck!" Ashley shouted, "I-I challenge you two to fuck the two of us! Whoever gets tired first loses!"

"Ashley what!?" Mia asked, "Are you out of your mind!?"

Hodag's aphrodisiac pheromone was still in effect, but Ashley also had a secret kink of fucking supernatural people like werewolves and whatnot from all the smut she read, so it was definitely the combination of the two that was driving her. She ran up to Hodag and immediately put his flaccid dick in her mouth.

"Whoa whoa! She's supposed to be mine!" Teratorn complained.

"Not my fault, this bitch pounced on me!" Hodag retorted.

He used one hand and pulled Ashley off of him with ease, before turning to leave.

"There, you get your two sluts, now I'm going to go find that last one," Hodag said, before walking out. His heavy footsteps made loud sounds on the tiled floors.

"Wait!" Ashley cried, trying to get back up, but Teratorn stood in front of her.

"Raring to suck a cock are you? Well I've got one right here for you!" he shouted as he shoved his erect cock into her mouth and hitting her throat in one clean motion.

"You over there!" Teratorn barked at Mia, who was cowering behind the bed, "Get the fuck over here and join her!"

Timidly, Mia reluctantly got up and walked over. She was terrified, but she was also just too much of a pushover, so she'd rather obey his commands than run for her life.

Teratorn guided Ashley's head back and forth on his dick as he motioned Mia over. Mia got down on her knees and the birdman Cryptid let go of Ashley's head, giving her some time to gasp for breath before he pressed the two of their heads together, with his erection in the middle of course. For the second time that day, the Autumn sisters found themselves kneeling side by side pleasing the same cock.