Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 16 by Hi101 Hi101

What's next?

Athena explores Erin’s cunt

I watch Erin tremble on the edge, her body quivering as Athena's tongue flicks relentlessly over her swollen clit and those puffy lips. Erin's drool slips from her open mouth, pooling on the bedsheets below, her high ponytail swaying with each shudder. The control plug in her ass hums softly, denying her release until I say otherwise—my little game of power that keeps them both so deliciously ****.

'Not yet, Erin,' I murmur, my voice low and commanding as I stroke my slick cock, still throbbing from her tight heat. 'You know the rules. Beg properly, and maybe I'll let you shatter.'

Erin whimpers, her knees buckling slightly against the bed's edge. 'Please, Master... I need it. Let me cum for you. I'll do anything.' Her words come out in broken gasps, her bald pussy clenching visibly under Athena's eager laps.

Athena pauses for a split second, her blue plug glowing faintly as I activate it with a quick tap on my remote, sending a jolt of pleasure through her. She dives back in without hesitation, sucking gently on Erin's clit while her hands grip Erin's thighs to steady her. The teen ****'s own thong dangles around her knees, her exposed ass wiggling as she works, the crystal plug catching the light.

I step closer, grabbing a fistful of Athena's ponytail to guide her deeper. 'That's it, ****. Make her scream without mercy. Show me how well you're learning.' Her tongue probes Erin's folds, lapping up the juices that drip steadily now, mixing with the saliva from her efforts. I can feel the warmth of her breath against my balls as she nuzzles in closer.

Erin's moans grow louder, her body arching as she pushes back against Athena's face. 'Master... oh god, it's too much... please!' I smirk, reaching down to pinch one of her erect nipples through the flimsy apron, twisting it just enough to make her yelp.

'Almost, my perfect cock sleeve,' I say, releasing her nipple and sliding my hand down to her ass. I give the red plug a firm twist, ramping up the vibrations inside her. She bucks wildly, her pussy grinding against Athena's mouth.

'Cum now, Erin. Soak your sister's face.' The command unleashes her—Erin cries out, her whole frame convulsing as waves of orgasm rip through her. Juices squirt onto Athena's chin and cheeks, the teen **** gulping and licking greedily, not missing a drop. Erin's legs give out, and she collapses forward onto the bed, panting and spent, her skirt flipped up to expose everything.

I pull Athena back by her hair, her face glistening with Erin's release. 'Good girl,' I praise, wiping a thumb across her lips before shoving it into her mouth. She sucks it clean obediently, her eyes wide and submissive. The control plug punishes any flicker of resistance in her mind, but she's catching on fast.

'Your turn to earn some pleasure, Athena. On your back—legs wide.' She scrambles to comply, lying on the bed beside Erin, who rolls over weakly to watch. Athena spreads her thighs, her bald pussy on full display, those less pronounced lips already puffy and slick from the earlier inspections and her own arousal.

I climb onto the bed, positioning myself between her legs. Erin crawls closer without being told, her training kicking in—she knows her role. 'Help me, Erin. Get her ready for my cock.'

Erin nods eagerly, leaning in to kiss Athena's inner thighs, working her way up with soft bites and licks. Athena gasps as Erin's tongue traces her slit, parting the lips to expose her clit. I watch for a moment, stroking myself, before leaning down to capture Athena's mouth in a rough kiss. My tongue invades her, tasting the faint saltiness of Erin's cum on her lips.

Breaking the kiss, I trail bites down her neck to her collar, then yank the apron aside to free her large breasts. They're heaving with each breath, nipples hard peaks begging for attention. I latch onto one, sucking hard while pinching the other, drawing a sharp moan from her.

Below, Erin has Athena's pussy spread wide with her fingers, her tongue plunging in and out, fucking her with it. Athena's hips buck up, seeking more, her hands fisting the sheets.

'Enough,' I growl, pulling Erin away gently but firmly. She retreats to kneel at the bed's edge, eyes hungry as she watches. I line up my cock with Athena's entrance, the swollen head nudging her wet folds. She's tighter than Erin, her body still adjusting to this life, and I savor the resistance as I push in slowly.

Athena winces, then moans, her walls clenching around me. 'Master... it's so big...' I thrust deeper, filling her inch by inch until I'm buried to the hilt. Her blue plug presses against my pelvis with each movement, a reminder of my control.

I start pounding her steadily, my hands gripping her hips to pull her onto me. Her tits bounce with the rhythm, and I lean down to suck on them again, leaving red marks from my teeth. Athena's cries fill the room, a mix of pain and building ecstasy as she adjusts.

'Erin, don't just watch. Finger her ass around that plug—make her feel full everywhere.' Erin obeys instantly, slicking her fingers with spit before circling Athena's plugged hole. She eases one finger in beside the crystal, stretching her further while I fuck her pussy raw.

Athena thrashes, overwhelmed, her body a live wire under our ****. 'Please... Master, it's too much... I can't...'

'You can, and you will,' I snap, activating her plug to reward her submission with pulses of pleasure. She arches off the bed, her pussy spasming around my cock. I pick up the pace, slamming into her harder, the bed creaking under us.

Erin's finger pumps in sync, and soon Athena's right there, begging like Erin did. 'Cum for me, ****. Milk my cock dry.'

With a strangled scream, she does—her orgasm crashes over her, walls fluttering and squeezing me tight. I groan, holding back just long enough to feel every pulse before pulling out and flipping her over onto her stomach.

'Not done yet. Ass up, both of you.' They scramble into position side by side, cheeks presented, plugs winking. I alternate spanks between their asses, watching the flesh jiggle and redden.

First, I yank Erin's red plug out with a pop, her hole gaping slightly before clenching. I replace it with my cock, thrusting into her ass without warning. She pushes back greedily, moaning as I stretch her.

A few deep pumps, then I switch to Athena, pulling her blue plug free and burying myself in her virgin-tight rear. She yelps, but the pleasure from the earlier activation keeps her from pulling away. I fuck her ass roughly, building my own release.

Back and forth I go, using their holes like the toys they are, until the pressure builds too high. With a final thrust into Erin's ass, I cum hard, flooding her with hot spurts. She shudders, grinding back to take it all.

I pull out, spent but satisfied, and watch my seed leak from her. 'Clean each other up, girls. And remember—tomorrow's training starts early.'

They turn to each other, tongues and fingers working to lap up the mess, their bodies entwined in obedient bliss. What a perfect evening.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)