Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 133 by Samus1001 Samus1001

What's next?

Ass fucking we will go

Author's note: This chapter contains a significant departure from the original story. More than one person was unhappy with Heather's story arc. Some thought she was forgiven too soon, and another person commented that she's a pet fuck toy, yet she is rarely treated like one. Finally someone else made a point that had me reconsider her character arc in a major way, and this chapter reflects that change. I do try to accommodate my readers, so if you have any comments, please send me a message, or write a comment on the chapter. I read every single one, and will respond. I promise.


Tina decided she wasn’t going to wait anymore. She walked back into the den carrying a bottle of lube. Her butt was all cleaned out and lubed up. She was going to get Caleb’s dick up her ass even if it killed her.

She walked right over to Caleb as he sprawled out on the couch, his feet resting on Heather's lap while she massaged them. Tina tossed the tube of lube on his lap, dropped her pants and panties and said, “Get your damn cock out. Now, damn it. No more delays. No more teases.”

Caleb looked up with an amused grin. “Okay. Okay. I’ll stop teasing you.”

He took his feet off Heather and stood. Tina reached for his pant and the pair quickly undressed. She pulled him to the center of the room and even though they had already drawn everyone's attention announced, “Hey everybody, we’re gonna try anal now.”

Tina hadn’t noticed Amanda seated between Kathy and Chris, a layout of the mansion grounds in front of them. She wouldn’t have cared if she did.

She waited a second till she had everyone’s attention, then dropped to her knees. In a loud and clear voice she began, “Ok, the first thing we need to do is make sure he is nice and hard. You can do that however you like, but this is your last chance to put his dick in your mouth till he takes a shower. I’ll do ass to mouth but I don’t recommend it unless you’re a butt slut like me. Also, once it's been in your butt, you do not want it going in your kitty. You'll get a UTI and you don't want that. Once we are finished, Caleb is going to take a shower, and scrub every bit he's got down there.”

Tina licked along his thick shaft before fisting it with both hands and saying, "You don't need to worry about getting his dick slick just yet. Spit makes a terrible anal lube, so only use it if you've got nothing else."

She popped his cockhead in her mouth and jerked the lower half of his shaft while she enjoyed the taste of his precum.

June looked over at Mary and silently indicated their husband's crotch’s. Both men were getting hard. June knew that Harold enjoyed watching his son fuck other women. He loved June telling him about Caleb’s conquests as well. It seemed that Mark might enjoy it too.

Amanda made to get up, but both Chris and Kathy stopped her. The gardener had impressed both young women. Kathy wanted to play with her, even if she turned out not to be worthy of Caleb. Even if she wasn't, Kathy still wanted to watch him fuck her. She was a beautiful blonde busty woman, and would look great riding his cock.

“Amanda, don’t go. We’d like you to stay. You’ll be seeing things like this a lot, so you need to get used to it.” The pleading in Kathy’s eyes caused her to relent.

Chris said, “If you’re into girls, I’m pretty sure Kathy and me will want to play with you a lot.”

Amanda looked over at Kathy and eyed her huge bust. She couldn't wait to have them in her hands. “I’d love that,” she sultrily whispered.

Tina transitioned from a blowjob to a titty fuck. Her big fake tits shiny from the combination of lube and spit on his shaft. “More lube Caleb. Girls, there is no such thing as too much lube when you do anal. We bought flavored and plain ones. Hey Cindy, do you do ass to mouth, or eat anal pies, or rimming?”

Cindy was slowly stroking Harold’s cock. Beside her Mary was doing the same to Mark. “I’ll rim a girl if I really like her, but ass to mouth isn’t my thing. I’ve never had an anal pie, but I'll try it once. Seems a waste of a load of cum otherwise. I prefer it sprayed on my back or ass after anal.”

“Good to know. And that’s another thing to keep in mind. Where do you want him to unload? More lube Caleb. Make sure he knows before you get too involved. Mark or Harold, if you want to cum in my ass later, Cindy can try eating anal pie, otherwise let me suck your cock and you can finish in my mouth.”

Neither man answered, they were focused on Caleb's shaft rubbing between her big fake boobs. Cindy and Mary's handjobs weren't helping them focus on her words.

“Caleb, I want you to shoot on my face and tits. Fill my mouth up too. Okay?”

He grunted acknowledgment and she released his cock from her tits. “Ok, now this isn’t a porn movie. Anal is difficult if you’re new to it, and there is really only one position for beginners, and that is not riding him like they do in porn. Not only will the angle of your insides be off, you can break a guys dick if you do it wrong.”

Kathy exclaimed, “I don’t want you guys doing this if it might hurt Caleb!”

Cindy had shifted position and popped her mouth off Harold’s cock to speak. “Don’t worry too much Kathy. Tina obviously knows what she’s doing. He’ll be fine.” She went back to sucking Harold’s cock and reached over to Mark. Her hand joined Mary’s in stroking him.

June smiled at Mary as Mary removed her hand from Mark's average looking dick. Cindy was now playing with both of their husbands. June reached over and together with Mary’s help they began undressing Cindy.

Chris was kissing along Amanda’s neck and had her hands inside Amanda’s overalls playing with her breasts. She worked Amanda’s shirt up but Kathy pulled it back down and gave Chris a look of warning. Amanda was for Caleb’s enjoyment, not Harold and Mark. Chris would have to play with her through her clothes.

Tina moved into the fetal position on her knees and said, “This is the best position for your first time doing anal. It’s a lot like doggie but it lines your insides up so he will slide in easier. I’ll teach you girls how to lube your butts another time. Caleb make sure you put a lot of lube on the tip of your cock. Once you take my butt plug out, press your cockhead into the hole before it closes all the way.”

He did as she asked. He was making a mess on the carpet with the lube. He’d have to remember to apologize to the maids. As soon as the butt plug popped out, he shoved his cock inside.

He rammed in several inches when Tina screamed, “STOP! Fuck! I said put the head in, not the whole damn thing.”

Caleb started to pull out and she yelled, “Damn it! Stop! Just keep it right there for a minute. Fuck, let me adjust for fuck's sake. You just shoved a telephone pole up my butt.”

Hazel hurried over and knelt beside Tina, worriedly asking, “You ok babe? We can stop if you want.”

“I’m fine. Just make sure Caleb follows instructions. Caleb, you have to go slow, especially with the other girls. You can hurt them if you put too much in too fast. Your cock is fucking huge. I've had anal hundreds of times and even I think you need to go slow. OK? Now, very slowly start working your way in and out. Very slow. Each time you go in give me a little tiny bit more. And keep putting lube on when you pull out.”

June glanced over at her husband and smirked at the sight of his throbbing cock. She'd done anal with him before, though she wasn't a butt slut like Cindy. June knew very well how much her husband was enjoying the sight of little Tina struggling to take their son's huge dick in her ass.

Shifting her eyes, June cocked an eyebrow at Mark. Mary's husband's gaze wasn't focused on the action in the center of the room. June traced his line of sight, and felt herself get a bit uncomfortable. Mark was looking at the couch his youngest daughter sat on, as Kathy was being groped by Amanda.

June refocused her attention on her son and Tina. It wasn't her place to say anything about what Mark was doing. Harold had certainly seen Hazel masturbating whenever their daughter watched them have sex. It was a simple guilty pleasure. June certainly enjoyed watching her son when Harold fucked her.

Some mother's even allowed their daughter's to wear skimpy clothes around their fathers to help motivate them to provide more delicious cum for their family. And Mark wasn't a young man anymore, he may need a little help to get going at his age. But the way Mark looked at Kathy left a unpleasant impression in June's mind.

Back in the center of the room Tina whimpered every time Caleb pushed in. When he had half his cock up her ass she moaned, “Fucking fuck you’re huge. Ok hold it right there for a bit and let me get used to your big dick.”

Chris had her hand down Amanda’s overalls and the two were kissing as Chris strummed her clit. Kathy tapped Chris and said, “Hey, I wanna taste too. Share.”

Chris went back to kissing Amanda’s neck and Kathy turned her head so the two could also make out. Amanda’s hands roamed Kathy’s breasts. She took one and guided it up under Kathy’s dress. Kathy held her dress down so that no one could see up it, then spread her legs in welcome to Amanda.

Cindy, naked and horny, soon found herself being spit roasted by Harold and Mark. Each time Harold thrust into her pussy he caused her to bounce forward, pressing Mark’s cock deeper into her mouth.

June and Mary also disrobed. The two women moved to the floor. June donned a strap-on harness as Mary got on her knees in the doggie position, milk dripping from her breasts onto the carpet. June slid her rubber dick into Mary as the two mothers watched Caleb trying not to hurt Tina. They were close enough to see she was enjoying it, despite the pain from having his huge cock in her butt.

The rest of the women were shifting uncomfortably. April had a noticeable wet spot in her slacks. Angie and Gabbie were groping each other but were keeping their hands outside their clothes. Amelia was paying more attention to June and Mary than she was Caleb and Tina, she had a hand in her skirt and a look of passion on her face.

Melissa had Heather laying across her lap while Heather's butt was directly over Megumi's lap. Both older women were stroking their hands across her hair and body, Megumi mostly petting Heather's supple ass, her panties pulled down to just under her butt. Katie sat across Sonia's lap, the two women cuddled and whispering to each other.

Brandy sat alone, her mouth slightly open, her breathing heavy, as she watched Caleb's huge cock entering and exiting Tina's tiny rear. Her own butthole clenched each time he drove his dick into the skinny purple haired woman.

Caleb's hips were nearly touching Tina's ass as he plunged in and out of her. He picked up speed at her direction and was trying to get the last little bit up her butt. Tina was up on her hands and knees now throwing her ass back at him. She wanted all of his cock in her, but it seemed she had reached maximum capacity.

"Fuck Caleb! Grab my hips and ram it in me! I want it all! Fucking shit! I'm gonna CUUUUMMMmmm!"

Caleb slammed into her as hard as he could. He felt her juices splashing against his legs. Her entire body shook and convulsed as he finally managed to make his hips meet her ass.

When she was finally able to raise her head she growled at Hazel, "Why aren't you wearing a strap-on yet? And where is your mom? I want my triple team!"

June slowed the thrusting of her strap-on into Mary as Mary came down from her own orgasm, milk squirting from her nipples and almost reaching Hazel. "Hold on a minute Tina. Harold could you stop fucking Cindy long enough to take her and Mark into our bedroom. Mary, Tina, and I will join you later. Wait until we get there before Mark tries out Cindy's ass. Mary said she wanted to see."

The three agreed and hurried out of the room.

June turned to Kathy and said, "Kathy dear, the dads are gone. You can stop hiding your body from them now."

Kathy's response was to scream, "Oh Amanda. Yes. Yeeessss!" as Amanda flicked her thumb across Kathy's clit. Kathy held on to her and pulled her face down into the generous cleavage of Kathy's dress. Amanda began to make motorboating sounds, which caused Chris to laugh.

Looking down on her daughter, June snickered, "You going to get naked, or what?"

Before long clothes began to fall off all over the room. Hazel donned a strap-on and lay on the floor so Tina could ride her, Caleb reslotted his cock in her ass. Finally June popped her fake dick in Tina's face, still coated in Mary's juices, fucking her mouth while trying to stay in rhythm with the others.

Amanda got onto the floor in front of Kathy to put her head between Kathy's legs. Chris shifted behind her and ate Amanda's pussy from the back. Amanda put her hands above her head, groping Kathy's boobs as Kathy moaned out in pleasure.

Angie and Gabbie quickly locked themselves in a 69 position, while April masturbated beside them. Amelia noticed April all alone and joined her. The two women also flipped into a 69 after asking the younger women if, when they hit their peaks, they could switch partners.

Melissa was soon getting her clit licked by Heather, while Megumi finger fucked Heather with one hand, and ran a dildo into her own pussy with the other. Katie and Sonia both produced vibrators and took turns using them on each other.

All of this Brandy watched, her clit throbbing in her pants. Her nipples were hard as rocks, her panties soaked through with her cream. She made no move to join in or even masturbate. She couldn't, she didn't want to miss a single thing. She'd never been so turned on in her life. None of her sororities orgies ever made her feel this hot and bothered.

Mary sat down beside Brandy and ran her hand down her daughters back. "Baby, you ok? You look uncomfortable."

Brandy turned to her nude mother, the sight of the sexy woman, milk still slowly dripping off her nipples, caused Brandy to lose control and leap at her. She locked her mother in a kiss and she ripped her own clothes in her haste to remove them.

In the center of the room, almost forgotten as the women around them focused on their own partners, Caleb yanked his cock out of Tina's ass. Tina pushed June away, removing the rubber dick from her mouth, as Caleb replaced it with his own. Tina eagerly swallowed as he filled her mouth with his thick sticky goo.

Not even a woman as whorish as Tina could take the full load though. Her mouth overflowed, dripping down onto her tits, where his cum met her hands, getting rubbed all over, and making her implant scars disappear.


Caleb walked back toward the den after his shower. When he left, June was leading an unsteady Tina toward June's bedroom, Brandy was licking her mother's pussy, Kathy and Chris switched places with Kathy eating Amanda while Amanda ate Chris. Amelia had been locked in a 69 with Angie while April was in one with Gabbie. Melissa and Heather were kissing and playing with each other. Megumi had left them to go play with Katie and Sonia.

When he returned Mary was no longer in the room and it seemed everyone had switched partners. Angie was now with Melissa, both of them having found dildos to use on each other. Amelia was getting fucked doggie style by Sonia. Amanda, Chris, Katie, Hazel, Gabbie, and Megumi were locked in a long daisy chain of pussy licking, finger fucking, and dildo dipping. April seemed to be taking a break. She was sipping on some sort of cocktail as she gently stroked her clit and watched the girls in the daisy chain.

He stood in the entryway and watched for a bit, feeling his sleeping member awaken while he decided which hole to stick it in. Finally he walked over to the couch Kathy was on. Heather's head was between Kathy's legs licking her clit while Brandy and Kathy were kissing and whispering to each other.

He dropped to his knees behind Heather and pulled the wet crotch of her cat suit to the side, exposing her slit. When his cock rubbed her opening she tried to lift her head but he pushed her back down commanding, "Don't stop licking. Make your queen cum."

Kathy began stroking Heather's hair, whispering, "Nice kitty. Lick my clitty kitty." She looked up at Caleb and smiled at him. "She's being a good little pet fuck toy tonight, giving out lots of orgasms. Reward her with your cock, my love."

As his cock slid inside her, he was amazed to discover Heather had never been stretched before. He quickly fixed that problem and Heather moaned loudly while gripping Kathy's thighs. Brandy licked her lips as Caleb embedded himself fully inside Heather. Heather's legs shook and tears fell from her eyes.

Kathy grew concerned and said, "Caleb wait."

But Heather hollered, "NO! It's perfect. It's so big and perfect. Please Caleb! Please fuck me!"

He pushed Heather's head back down into Kathy's pussy and growled, "Then get to licking. If you cum before Kathy does I'll stop fucking you."

He looked directly into Kathy's eyes as he rammed his cock hard into Heather. He tried to convey his love for her with just his facial expression even while gripping Heather's hips and hammering his dick into her.

Heather's cunt was already rippling along his shaft. He was sure she would cum before Kathy, but then Kathy's eyes began to roll back and her butt started to thrust up off the couch.

Kathy bit her lip and snapped her legs tight around Heather's head as she let out a muffled scream just as Heather lost control and convulsed around his cock. Her pussy was so tight and the feel of her velvet cunt so pleasant, that he before he knew what was happening, Caleb was firing his load deep inside her. He quickly filled her cunt to overflowing and fell back against the floor.

Kathy pushed Heather down beside him and with a wild look in her eyes she dove head first into Heather's muffin. Caleb laughed as Heather's orgasm was renewed. Glancing over at Brandy he saw the same wild look in her eyes as her sister. She lunged toward Caleb and grabbed his cock. With a scream of need she mounted him and dropped her cunt around his shaft before he'd softened even a little bit.

Brandy began forcing his cock inside her, stretching herself as she rammed her ass toward his thighs while babbling, "I need this so bad. I need your cock Caleb. I need you to fuck me. I need your cum."

Even as his cock reached deep inside her, her mind screamed. Brandy was a lesbian, yet she'd never felt such a strong attraction to a man, or such a powerful need to have his cock inside her.

She fell upon him and jackhammered her cunt up and down his shaft as she **** her tongue into his mouth. She grabbed his hands and **** them onto her breasts, squeezing them as hard as she could. Her thrusting quickly became uncoordinated, and her pussy grew even wetter as it flexed around him. She moaned into his mouth as she tried to tame his tongue with her own.

Out of the corner of his eye he saw Kathy's face rise up from Heather's crotch. She knelt beside them and yanked Brandy's head off of his. Pulling harder she brought Brandy up into a seated position, every inch of Caleb's pussy stretching cock engulfed by her twitching cunt.

Kathy used her hand to open Brandy's mouth. Then she dribbled the load she sucked out of Heathers pussy into it. Kathy kissed her sister, their tongues battling for a share of his cum. Brandy began to convulse again as she struggled to kiss her sister while maintaining her jackhammering of his cock, her thighs rising and falling, her hands reaching for her baby sister's enormous tits.

Kathy shifted around without breaking the kiss. She placed her legs on either side of Caleb, her pussy dropping down to his face. He began licking everywhere he could reach as he fought not to cum. Soon enough he had to hold Kathy's thighs in place as Kathy's girl cream flowed out of her snatch. She and her sister exploded in orgasm. The tightness of the newly stretched pussy was too much for him and he found himself coating another woman's insides with his seed.

Kathy pushed Brandy off of his cock and once again dove face first into a cum filled muffin.

Heather appeared at his side. She leaned over him and licked the combined juices off his cock. He stroked her hair as he panted, "Good girl."

Heather wasn't trying to keep him hard or make him cum. She was just cleaning him. He propped himself on his elbows and looked around at all the women in various states of sexual contact. He had forgotten to give out the rings he bought the girls earlier and he hadn't officially claimed Amelia or Melissa yet.

He looked back down at Heather, wondering what to do with her. She seemed to have taken to being his pet quite well, but he was worried that she was doing it to manipulate him and the others into going easy on her. He couldn't have that, but she hadn't done anything since he made her his pet that deserved punishment. Then he had an idea.

He patted Heather to get her attention and said, "Take your costume off. I have something that you are going to do for me."

He stood as Heather took off the cat ears on her head and removed the cat costume. The section where her tail met her hips had gotten ripped. He resolved to buy her a new one. When she was fully nude she stood before him in all her glory and asked, "What would you like me to do, Master?"

He took a good look at her nude body and hesitated. Part of him wanted to keep Heather for himself. She had a fantastic body, honed by her years as a cheerleader. She had a great set of tits, perky and round, though a little smaller than Chris's. Her ass wasn't as nice and plump as Kathy's, but then again, not many people had a body like his girlfriend. It was still a fantastic ass nonetheless.

He looked down at Kathy as she made out with Brandy. The sight of the two ultra sexy sisters kissing would have turned his dick into a steel bar if he wasn't already hard. He cleared his throat and got her attention, "Hey Kat."

She looked up at him with love clear in her eyes. The look Brandy gave him made him want to stick his dick back inside her. Kathy's voice was musically beautiful as she spoke, "Yes my love? Is there something you'd like to do to us?"

Caleb chuckled at her choice of words, "Yes, but I've got a question first. Do you mind if I send Heather to go fuck our dads? "

Beside him Heather stiffened. The look on Kathy's face turned unrecognizable for a moment. It was Brandy that answered him though, "I don't want that bitch anywhere near-"

Kathy put her hand over Brandy's mouth and firmly demanded, "Hush Brandy."

Looking back and forth between Heather and Caleb, Kathy spoke in a flat tone, "You're doing this to help our moms, aren't you?"

"Yeah, but it's not just that. Heather needs to be punished, Kat. I'm thinking of making her free use for our dads. She's already free use for all our friends."

Kathy's lips thinned and she remained silent for a few moments before speaking. "And so far only the women among the Denizens have used her. I do NOT want the men using her too. That's too much Caleb. Having sex with women is one thing, but some of the guys would really try to hurt her, and you promised she wouldn't get hurt."

Caleb nodded, "Okay, fine. She's free use for the girls, but also our dads."

At Kathy's nod, Caleb guided Heather out of the room.

Brandy finally spoke, "I can't believe you'd let our dad fuck that bitch. Why the hell would you allow that? And why not have all your guy friends make her into their cum dumpster?"

"I have my reasons." Kathy responded, though she wasn't about to tell her sister her thoughts.

I can't let Heather have sex with the other male Denizens. I want her fucking Dad as often as possible. If Dad is fucking Heather, Cindy, and Tina, that means he won't have the energy to have sex with Mom. And now that Mom is stretched, she'll want sex more often than ever, which means she'll turn to Caleb and the other girls. It's a long shot, but I might even convince Mom to leave Dad and join the harem. If I can make her one of us, I'll get to have sex with her all I want. And with Mom in the harem, she'll help convince my sisters to join too. Then my ultimate sexual fantasy will come true. All four of us will join Caleb in bed. The five of us will then fuck, suck, lick, and do just about everything else. And then Caleb will breed us all, and the rest of the harem, and all these other women too. We'll be the perfect family for my perfect man, and have dozens of children.

When Caleb returned he began to move towards Kathy, his hard dick leading the way. Amelia and Melissa got to him first though. As they pushed him down onto a couch, Amelia got over top of him while Melissa whispered in his ear. "It's time you added us to the harem, my king."


If you like the story so far consider buying me a cup of coffee at https://ko-fi.com/samus1001

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)