Asks Andrew to borrow it

Katie couldn't remove her eyes from the dick as Andrew picked it up. "Wait," she stopped him. "Umm... How did you get a magic dildo like that?"

Andrew stammered a bit before saying, "C-can we really just drop the topic altogether?" He took the dildo and brought it over to his desk.

As Andrew reached for the knob on the bottom shelf, something overcame Katie. "C-can I borrow it?" she asked.

This stopped Andrew in his tracks. He stood back up and opened his mouth to speak, but no words came out. He closed his mouth and frowned, and looked like he was thinking hard about his decision. He was thinking very hard about it. Through gritted teeth, Andrew groaned and said, "I don't know if that's such-" but he was cut off.

"Just for one day!" Katie said.

"That's not really the prob-"

"I'll wash it really well when I'm done!"

"It just isn-"

"Please! I'm just really curious! I can't go out and get one myself; I'd die if my roommate ever found it! Just one day!"

"Katie, can't you just use a hairbrush or som-" this time Andrew stopped himself when he saw how dejected Katie looked.