Approach Phoebe!

Phoebe looks like she's about to run away from the whole thing. But you manage to catch her off guard and cut her escape route.

"Oh h-hello, Mr. Doe. Right?"

"Yeah, yeah." you run a hand to her cheek and caress it. "You remember?"

"We uh - we have three classes together. So I---please take your hand off of me."

"Uh-uh, you're too damn cute, you know that?"

"I---please Mr.Doe, I know what Dean Judie said but I-I'm not ready for that kind of act! It's sinful! We aren't even married!" You smile and cup her face, realizing now that the good ol' Christian girl is a true virgin. And you could be the first person to take her virginity. But do you want to do that here? Or somewhere later?

You can only imagine the more intimate setting she'd prefer. And there's plenty of other holes to use on this one.

"P-please Mr.Doe."