Another one

You're woken up when you feel someone trip over your foot.

"Ah! Dang it." the person says. You recognize it to be Abby's voice.

"Abby?" you say in the dark. You can't see anything or know what time it is. Your phone is in your jeans, which you have no idea of its location at the moment. "What time is it?"

"Just past midnight. I couldn't sleep and I was lonely. Thought you might want some company, but it feels like someone else is here?"

It sounds like Abby is sitting right next to your head and she had just touched Jenna on the back as she felt around for you. That woke the redhead who had been sleeping on top of you.

"Abby?" Jenna says groggily.

"Hey, Jenna. Sorry, I didn't know you would be down here."

"Oh, it's okay. I just came down to show John my assets." The girls giggle. You're surprised how they all seemed to get along pretty well, instead of constantly vying for attention. "Here, come on," Jenna says and you feel her sit up and shift her weight off you, quickly replaced by Abby straddling your hips. Your cock is still limp and recovering from Jenna's amazing titjob, though it stirs to life when you feel Abby's pussy lips touching it. She's wearing some sort of thin material, probably a nightgown, but has no panties on.

She starts to move her hips a little, rubbing your cock against her slit and you feel Jenna's hand wrap around your cock and helping her.

"Did you guys fuck?" Abby asks.

"Just my boobs. You were right, his cock is longer. I could actually lick the tip when he thrust all the way up," Jenna replies.

"Gosh. These are awesome, aren't they John?"

You agree as you picture Abby grabbing Jenna's breasts in the dark. You could just clap the lights on, but not being able to see actually makes it hotter.

After a while, Jenna announces, "He's ready to go, here, rise up a little." Abby lifts her hips off you so that Jenna can guide your cock into her pussy. She's already very wet from the stimulation and she proceeds to ride you at a moderate pace.

You lie there and close your eyes, enjoying the sensation of Abby's pussy, until you remember your first time with her and how she had described Nigel as old and frail, who just lay there and let the girls do their work. It was time for more than one thing to change, as you suddenly grab Abby's waist and push her over until she's lying beneath you.

"Woah, tiger," she says and you kiss her. Then, you fuck her for a little bit, then pull out and flip her around onto her stomach. She yelps when you smack her ass hard, then jam your cock back into her pussy. She moans loudly as you fuck her vigorously and you feel your sweat dribbling down your back.

"Fuck!" you exclaim as you cum and you feel Abby shudder too. Jenna's hand is on your back, as if to steady you and you pull her in for a kiss.

"Gosh dang it. That was some fucking," Abby manages to say as she recovers her breath.

You laugh. "I told you, you girls are going to get fucked from now on."

You collapse beside Abby, sneaking an arm under her to hold her, while Jenna lies down around your other arm, and you all go to sleep.