Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 423 by Samus1001 Samus1001

What's next?

Anger, Jealousy, and a Boner

Author's note: Thanks to my hard drive crashing, this chapter took a long time to finish. I'm using my phone to write it, and that is both slower and harder. I should have my computer fixed later this week and can start writing faster. Now on with the show...


Chloe glared at Mother Monose and demanded, "I want to know everything you do about that woman. And don't pretend you don't know anything. All of the substitute teachers have been Lotus Sisters, and that means they were hand picked by you."

Monose's nostrils flared, the only visible indication of how upset she was. Thankfully, she and Chloe were currently alone. Mary and Brandy were out of the mansion, and June was occupied with the new herd candidate. Those three were the ones most likely to explode if they knew the truth.

But as she looked back at Chloe, Monose wished she were anywhere but Caleb's mansion. I should have refused to send Mark Daniel's playthings to be bred by Caleb. This is an unmitigated disaster, and the bomb hasn't even gone off yet. It's only a matter of time before Tabitha wakes up, and the Holy Mother has the Marshals guarding her, so I can't even silence her. Damn that woman! She was supposed to get bred and leave! She certainly wasn't to be claimed by the Stretcher King.

Monose pursed her lips and wracked her brain for some plausible story as Chloe glared at her. Chloe's been in the sisterhood since the day she was born. She's not stupid either. She'd see through any bullshit. And no matter what I came up with, Tabitha is unlikely to corroborate the story since I can't even speak to her. Damn it!

Finally she decided to talk around the subject, hoping the Mother Superior's former lover would understand and not take it too badly. With a sigh, Monose began speaking. "You are aware of the jobs that are typical for my sisters. They often find themselves accommodating the needs and desires of the Stretcher Kings, and their Queens, sometimes without their knowledge. Even if it's something they would hate them for."

The way Monose emphasized the last few words tripped a thought in Chloe's mind. "So Tabitha did something that Kathy would hate? Is that what you're saying?"

Monose bluntly stated, "Yes."

Chloe searched her memory for anything about her new girlfriend that would cause her to truly hate someone. But as much as Chloe knew about Kathy, even the sisterhood reports on her didn't know everything.

Kathy is a sweet girl. She doesn't hate anyone. Hell, she forgave Heather, and is even reforming the other cheerleaders. Unfortunately, aide from her being a Lotus Sister, I don't know anything about Tabitha.

Chloe wracked her brain, trying to think if she had ever met Tabitha before. She had interacted with hundreds of Lotus Sisters in her lifetime. But Tabitha was relatively young, and there were thousands of them. Most of the ones Chloe knew were older than the one resting in April's bed.

I know they are killers. Hell, one of them saved Helena's life when she left Stretcher King Ming's harem by killing the mercenary the new harem queen sent to kill her. Even though Helena wasn't a member of the holy trinity, that lotus sister still earned a new tattoo.... Wait a minute. Tabitha has a new tattoo as well....

Chloe's eyes widened as she put two and two together. That tattoo is so new it hasn't healed yet... And Mark Daniels disappeared without a trace after fucking one of the maids from the maid pool. He hasn't even tried contacting his ex-wife or his children since the day he fucked her. And all of the maids have been Lotus Sisters, which means they wouldn't have seduced him without orders... and that means...

"You... You stupid idiots." Chloe hissed through sudden anguish. Her heart ached for her queen, the woman she loved more than any other. "She killed him, didn't she? Tabitha killed Kathy's father."


As Caleb walked into the Pit at lunchtime, Zack peeled off and hurried over to his girlfriends. Caleb watched him go and smiled as the three girlfriends greeted Zack with the enthusiasm of little puppies happy to see their owner. Megan waved at Caleb as Alice and Amy folded their arms around their man.

Caleb waved back and turned away to head further into the Pit. Then he grinned at the sight before his eyes. Half the cheerleaders were inside the Pit today. Ordinarily the Denizens would be furious at their presence, but not anymore.

The evidence before him was proof Kathy's plan to ostracize Kesha from the other cheerleaders was coming along excellently. I didn't think this part of Kathy's plan would ever actually happen, but boy was I wrong. Thanks to the gender ratio and cum eating normalities, sex acts between adult students is taken as a simple fact of life. But at school it is usually kept behind closed doors. The bathrooms seemed to be the choice place for a quick fuck. At least for everyone else. I fuck pretty much wherever I want. I would have bet that getting students to fuck out in the open like this was crazily impossible. But Kat and Melanie grew up in this mind-blowing reality, and they were so right it's ridiculous.

Carl, the head of the chess club, smiled and nodded a greeting to Caleb. Carl's pants were around his ankles, one cheerleader sucking his dick, while another cheerleader was sitting beside him getting her tits manhandled.

Caleb passed them by, high-fiving a skinny guy named Nathan, who was also getting a blowjob from another cheerleader, as he moved towards his usual table.

It wasn't just the male Denizens getting pleasured by cheerleaders though. If they had been, an outside observer might think that the cheerleaders were only here for a load of cum.

Among the female Denizens, Michelle and Kimberly were getting their pussies licked, Alison and Janice were getting fucked by strap-on wielding cheerleaders, while Misty lay on one of the concrete tables with a cheerleader eating her carrot flavored cunt and another nibbled one of her nipples.

Caleb had almost reached his usual table when he heard a loud familiar voice.

"Damn it! Don't just lick my clit! Finger me too!" Chris barked at Wanda. Chris sat on a concrete bench, leaning back against the table as Wanda knelt before her, munching the muscular woman's muffin.

Caleb couldn't hear Wanda's response but Chris tilted her head back and moaned, so Wanda must have obeyed.

Caleb began to sit beside her as he asked, "Hey Chris, where's Kat?"

Kathy's third period class was close to the Pit, so she was usually one of the first ones there. Caleb had a long walk from the Math hall, so he and Zack were normally the last to arrive.

Chris dug her fingernails into Wanda's head while grunting, "Oh, uh, she'll be, ah, here soon. Mmmm, suck my clit. Yeah. She's with Nikki right now. Yeah! Right there Wanda! Rub right there!"

Caleb smiled as Chris's legs began shaking, a sure sign of an orgasm exploding inside her. He watched as Chris shivered through her orgasm, his smile turning into a grin when she finished because Chris stood and retrieved her strap-on from her backpack.

Wanda eyed the big thick dick Chris donned. Caleb knew it was modeled after his own member. That was the only type Chris used.

When Wanda was spun around and bent over the concrete table her voice quavered, "Wait Chris. I'm not wet yet, and I've never had a dick that thick before."

Chris just laughed and pressed the tip against her opening. "You're gonna take my cock, or you'll never get Caleb's."

Chris grabbed Wanda's hips and pulled her ass back while she thrust hard. Wanda squealed as the rubber dick rammed deep up her love tunnel. Fully impaled, Wanda's head was jerked up as Chris yanked her hair.

Chris gave Wanda hard deep strokes as she purred in her ear. "You've got years of bullying to make up for, so I'm making you my bitch. You'll never go a day without my cunt cream on your lips, and my rubber dick in your guts. If you're a good girl, I might even ask Caleb to put his dick in you. If you're a bad girl, you'll get to find out what it feels like to have this other hole filled with my big cock."

As Wanda's eyes went wide and she whimpered in fear, Caleb chuckled. He reached out and turned Wanda's head so that she looked at him. "I suggest you be a good girl."

He ran his thumb across Wanda's lips. She took the hint and sucked it inside, her entire body jerking forward as Chris gave her several extra hard thrusts.

When she began licking his thumb, he smiled at her and said to Chris, "Looks like she wants to be a good girl, so don't break her. You can spank her, but no major bruising. And check with me before you fuck her ass."

After Chris acknowledged his order, he looked back at Wanda and imparted, "Chris won't treat you like shit, but you are basically her fuck toy till the end of the school year, or she tells me you've become a good girl. If you can do that, I'll give you a stretch. I might even breed you if you have been a particularly good fuck toy."

Wanda tried to push his thumb out of her mouth to speak, but Caleb held it there until she stopped trying and gave in. He put a bit of pressure on her tongue till she began licking it again.

He nodded, "Good. Keep licking. Suck my thumb like it's a dick. If you show me what your mouth can do, I might just let you suck my cock."

One handed, he dug into his lunch, deciding not to wait for their other friends. It was a bit awkward trying to eat while Wanda gave his thumb a blowjob, but he didn't stop her.

This will make an interesting experiment to see if the pleasure increasing normality kicks in. It usually only happens when I'm fucking someone. But if sucking my thumb is enough to turn the normality on, that might make our orgies a bit more fun.

As he had those thoughts, Gabbie and Angie joined him. Angie began to eat, but Gabbie reached under her dress to pull her panties off. She then draped them over Wanda's head and sneered, "After Chris is done pounding your little pussy, I get you next. You've eaten Angie twice now, and I want a turn on your tongue."

As Chris continued to fuck Wanda, Caleb realized he had no way of knowing if Wanda was feeling the effects of the pleasure increasing normalities. The bitch cheerleader was easily able to continue licking and sucking his thumb, but she was also throwing her ass back at Chris now. Unfortunately, he didn't know if that was his normality making her enjoy the rough pounding she was getting, or if she just liked to have her cunt fucked hard.

He pulled his thumb out of her mouth, thinking, I'll have to get Kat or Mom to help me figure this out. It'd make a good experiment to do with Lori too. We never did get around to experimenting more with the watch.

Kathy still hadn't arrived when three cheerleaders walked over to him. Caleb smiled up at Burnadette.

Burnadette returned his smile and motioned at the two women accompanying her. "Hey Caleb. Ashley and Traci wanted to offer themselves to you, if you'd like to do something to them."

Caleb eyed the girls as they gave him hopeful looks. He'd always known Ashley to be a stuck up snobbish bitch. Her parents were well off, though not nearly as wealthy as Teresa's family. To be fair, Ashley hadn't bullied others too badly, choosing to admonish the poorer students verbally as her main form of condescension. Ashley looked down on others for the crime of not having parents as well off as hers.

Traci's bullying was an entirely different type. A prankster like Angie, though there the similarity ended. Angie's pranks were funny and meant to make you question your sanity. Angie's victims often found themselves laughing along with everyone else. Traci's pranks were mean spirited, with the goal of humiliating her targets. Every member of the Denizens had been a target of hers at one point or another.

Caleb looked them up and down. They had good looking bodies, though that was typical for cheerleaders. Ashley was prettier than most of her fellow students, with tits a little big for her overall size too, which probably contributed to her superiority complex. Traci wasn't as good looking, and her tits would barely fill his hands. Even ignoring the differences in their bodies, Caleb would prefer to play with Ashley. She had the less tarnished of the two reputations.

Remembering that he told Kathy he'd fuck a cheerleader to tease Kesha, he decided what he wanted.

With a smile on his lips, Caleb said, "How about you girls put on a show for me? Stand there and make out. Make it look good, and I'll stretch the girl that impresses me the most."

Traci blurted, "Really!?"

Before Caleb could confirm, Ashley grabbed Traci, turned her, and locked lips with her in a kiss and grope greeting that saw their clothes rapidly coming off.

Caleb sat back and watched, jumping a bit when Gabbie moved beside him and began rubbing his cock through his pants. Caleb snorted, "Hey, weren't you waiting for a turn with Wanda?"

Gabbie rolled her eyes. "Yeah, but that doesn't mean I can't play with my master's fuck stick while I wait. Who do YOU think I'd rather play with?" She leaned in to whisper, "Besides, all the denizens will have more orgasms if you join in the fun, even if you're not fucking any of them."

Caleb thought about that for a moment. His pleasure increasing normalities specified that women would have more sexual enjoyment when he did, so long as they were in the same room. That made him wonder if the Pit qualified as a room.

When Burnadette pulled one of his hands to fondle her tits, he looked over at her, wondering when she took her top off. Not that he minded. She belonged to Kathy now, which meant her body was his to enjoy.

Traci was fully into the kiss and grope with Ashley, but the other cheerleader kept her attention mostly on Caleb, and Gabbie rubbing the hardening flesh tube in his pants.

Even though the way Traci fondled Ashley was doing more to turn him on, he'd already decided that Ashley would get his dick today. He was really only waiting for Kathy to show up. He wanted another threesome with her, and making Ashley lick the pussy of a girl she once looked down on would be priceless. He glanced at the time on his phone and wondered what was taking her so long.


Lilith clenched her teeth as the hubunny named Melissa drove her strap-on in and out of the succubi pussy at a very rapid pace. Lilith had been on the table for over an hour, though the hubunny had replaced Amber only a few minutes prior.

On the table next to her own, Amanda was getting a similar treatment from a young woman that had been introduced as Gemma, though the high school senior couldn't fuck at nearly the pace Melissa did.

Even so, Lilith couldn't understand why she kept cumming so much, or so hard. I've had much larger dildo's stuffing my cunt before. Nor is this my first time getting my pussy pounded by shifters either. Ah shit! She's going even faster?! Fuck! I thought that giant hucow was going to break my pussy when she fucked me, but this hubunny might succeed!

When Melissa reached forward and grabbed Lilith's hair, yanking her head up, Lilith let out a screech, a fresh orgasm causing her milk to squirt into the suction heads.

Melissa's hips were practically a blur as she thumper fucked into the huge titted hucow. To the room she happily commented, "You were right Amber, Lilith has a fantastic cunt. It doesn't grip my dildo nearly as hard as the other hucows around here. I can really pound this pussy."

June lifted her head from the unipump table and smirked, "Then Caleb will love fucking her. UH! Amber sweetie, not so hard. Make love to me."

Amber pulled back a bit, slowing down her thrusts, and apologized, "Sorry June. I was watching Melissa and for a second there I started to speed up to match her. Not that I can. No one can fuck as fast as a hubunny." Then she reached down and began massaging her lovers back as she slowly fucked her.

"Mmmm. That's much better. Your hands are magic." June sighed as she lay back down on the table and enjoyed the sensations of having her tits drained while getting her pussy pleasured.

Gemma glanced at the control board for the table Amanda lay on and pressed a few buttons.

Amanda sighed in pleasure as the suction on her nipples slowed down but increased in power. Then the clit stimulator began to vibrate, sending her into orgasmic ecstasy. "Oh Gemma, you always know just what I like. Mmmm. Little faster on the clit vibe."

Gemma cranked the speed of Amanda's clit vibrator up a notch and waited to see how her lover would react. She glanced at the milk canisters beside her and saw that Amanda had a good milk flow going. Looking over at Lilith's table she smirked.

Poor girl is obviously not pregnant. She's been on the table for over an hour and she's barely pumped half a gallon. Even Connie doesn't take that long to drain her tits. If Lilith joins the herd, we'll have to get Caleb to breed her first thing. She's got a fantastic set of knockers, and they should be making the maximum amount of milk. Hell, if he does, Lilith might get tits even bigger than Amber's gigantic boobs. Although, if it takes her this long just to produce half a gallon, Lilith might practically live on one of the milking tables.

Damn. Now I'm jealous. Laying on a milking table all day and getting fucked over and over by the harem would be the best life ever. God, what I wouldn't do to be a hucow. They always have huge tits. Connie's got the smallest set, and my boobs could get lost in her bra. I hope Kat can use her magic to make my tits bigger soon. I want huge milk cans just like hers before Caleb pumps a baby in me.


Thanks for making it this far. I hope you've enjoyed the story up to this point. Leave a comment, hit the like button, and tell me the things you would like to see. If you love the story, and want to show your appreciation, how about buying me a cup of coffee at https://ko-fi.com/samus1001

What's next?

Comments

      Want to support CHYOA?
      Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)