Amy

Susie was still catching her breath and looked around the room a little distractedly. “Geez, trying to think of something different here.” Actually she was just stalling for time.

Finally she said, “Amy! I dare you to take off Beth’s panties and finger fuck her for thirty seconds. Then let Beth take off your thong and finger fuck you for thirty seconds. Then you put your thong on Beth and she puts her panties on you.”

“Huh?” Amy came back at her. “That’s kind of complicated. You want to get me and Beth naked like everybody else? But then you want us to put our panties back on again? Ok, I’m confused.”

“No, you don’t put your panties back on. You put your thong on Beth and she puts her panties on you. I just figured that would be a cute twist.”

Amy sighed. “Ok,” she said.

I just grinned because I liked the way this game was going. Almost everybody was naked. Of course, I was still wearing Carly’s bra and panties, but I had been naked and I might as well have been anyway what with my hard cock sticking out from the side of the panties. And now the two girls who were still wearing panties had to take them off so they would be at least momentarily naked until they put each other’s panties back on.

Amy and Beth were still sitting next to each other on the sofa. Amy leaned over toward Beth and helped her slide forward so her butt was near the front edge of the sofa. Then she grabbed the waist of her boy shorts panties and started pulling them off. Beth raised her ass off the sofa a little to maker it easier for them to slip down. She pulled them down off of Beth’s ankles and dropped them on the sofa. Beth’s pussy was totally bare, not even any stubble. Her pink inner lips poked out between her outer lips with a cute little wrinkle.

“Mmmm,” Amy said rubbing her bare mound. “What a pretty pussy.”

“Don’t just rub her, you have to finger fuck her now,” my sister reminded her of the details of the dare. “You get thirty seconds, starting now.”

Amy stuck two fingers in her mouth to get them wet. Then she reached down and rubbed Beth’s pink pussy lips to spread them open. She pushed the first finger into her honey hole first, then added the second finger. She pumped them in and out, rubbing her inner walls. Beth moaned but then my sister called “time” on them.

Next it was Beth’s turn to take off Amy’s panties. Well, it was really a thong. She turned to face her and Amy lifted her hips making it easy for Beth to pull her thong off. Amy had a small trimmed bush above her pussy and Beth played with her short hairs for a moment. Then she plunged two fingers straight into Amy’s cunt without any warning. Fortunately, Amy was apparently already wet from the excitement of playing with Beth’s snatch. She worked her fingers in and out of Amy’s warm wet hole until Susie once again called “time!” Beth pulled her fingers out and they both slumped back on the sofa.

“Well, it looks like you two had fun,” Susie grinned at them. “I guess you didn’t mind that dare so much after all, huh? But you’re not finished yet. You have to put your panties on each other.”

They looked at her slightly confused, then seemed to remember. Amy picked up her thong from the sofa and slid it up Beth’s legs.

“Ooh, that feels weird,” Beth remarked. Then she picked up her boy shorts and slid them up Amy’s legs. “So I guess my name’s Amy now and you must be Beth, she laughed.

“Yeah, whatever you say,” Amy replied. “But it’s still my turn to choose.”