Ai, after a little convincing.

Rob looks uncomfortable.

“What’s the matter?” you ask.

“I do not want to displease you, Mistress” he says “but …”

“Yes?”

“I don’t want to hurt anyone.”

“Even though they’ve hurt you in the past?”

He looks even less comfortable and you mentally kick yourself. Rob is a really good guy, kind and considerate, not the sort to want **** or payback, no matter how deserved, and you’ve just asked him to help you give some. You think about telling him to return to Tina and Ashley and have them teach him some more but instead you decide to try something else.

“O.k.” you say “I won’t make you choose who to punish… Instead I will give you a chance to do the opposite, to show mercy to one of them … to act as a moderating factor … they will still be punished but, by helping me do so you can insure their punishment is light. So who will it be?”

Rob nods and smiles a little. It is obvious that he doesn’t like the idea of you punishing anyone with pain or humiliation but that he has accepted that it is your duty as Mistress, and he seems glad that you have taken his feelings into consideration and allowed him to modify the punishment somewhat. “Ai.” he says, without hesitation “She’s the least cruel of the three, and only goes along with the others out of fear of rejection.”

That hasn’t been your experience, but maybe she is different around Rob than around you and the other girls.

“O.k.” you say “From now until I tell you otherwise you will not speak. If you speak I will send you out. Do you understand?”

Rob seems about to speak but then he just nods.

“Good” you say “Now wait here.”

You go to the other bedroom (where Tina and Ashley are so involved in each other they don’t even notice you) fetch the book, and then back to the living room. The three girls remain face down, ass up on the carpet. “Ai” you say “stand up”. “Yes Mistress” she says as she does so, eyes still downcast. “Pick up your punishment equipment and come here and do not speak unless I give you permission”. She looks afraid as she silently picks up her blindfold and bondage gear and walks over to you. You take the blindfold and place it over her eyes and then take her lead and put it on her collar.

“Now Bea” you say … you are about to have Bea spank Sissy with the paddle when you realize that it might disturb Rob (if not Tina and Ashley) if they hear it … “I want you to spank Sissy with you hand, 10 times on each butt cheek, and Sissy if I hear anything from you while I am punishing Ai I will come out and have Bea change to the paddle. Do you understand?”

“Yes Mistress” they say in unison.

As you lead Ai from the room you hear the first slap of Bea’s hand on Sissy’s ass and a squeak of shock and pain from Sissy. Ai looks worried and afraid

You take to the bedroom where Rob is waiting patiently and over to the bed. “Lie down.” You tell her, pushing her onto the bed.

She does as ordered and then you take the beautiful bondage gear out of its bag and affix her hands to the bedhead, one to each corner. You can see she is frightened and you know that, could you see her eyes, they would be pleading for you not to continue. However you do not relent taking her ankles and affixing them to the foot of the bed so she is spreadeagled across it in the most **** position possible.

“Now” you say “I am going to leave you here like this until I decide what to do with you.”

“NO!” she says finally finding her voice “Please mistress! Please don’t leave me here! Please don’t leave me alone!”

You look at her. You thought that being **** was her greatest fear (as, you guess, did she) but it seems being alone is a far worse fate, one that she is willing to risk even more punishment to avoid. Rob looks over at you and you nod toward Ai.

Rob goes over and touches her hand. “Who is that?” she asks, but Rob does not answer. “Is that you Mistress?” and then she seems to realize that it is not a woman’s hand. “Oh No … please … please don’t hurt me … please… ” She struggles against her bonds but they are well made.

Rob pulls away, not wanting to frighten her anymore and she calms down a little but then she seems to become afraid that she is alone again, and her fear of that returns “Please” she says “Are you still there? If you are could you say something? I’m sorry if I … If I … You’re not going to hurt me are you? If you wanted to do that you could have … please say something … let me know you are still here …”

Rob places his hand on hers again, and this time she grips it.

“Oh I see” she say “You aren’t allowed to talk. I’m not supposed to either but the Mistress has gone so it’s o.k.”

Rob looks over at you watching with amusement. He says nothing.

“O.k. you’re right.” says Ai “Just because I’ve been bad doesn’t mean you should be, even if the Mistress isn’t around.”

As they stand there, his hand in hers, you wonder what they are feeling. He seems to be trying not to look at her almost entirely naked body, while taking furtive glances at it the way most guys do at you breasts when they talk to you. She is smiling but it seems ****, like she doesn’t actually trust ‘whoever-he-is’ but wants him think she does so he won’t leave her.

You flip through the pages of the book until you find a spell that might help. Intima sciential (intimate knowledge) promises to give you knowledge of what others are feeling without making you feel the same (since you have no desire to feel what it is like to be in Ai’s position). You’ve sort of worked out how to direct spells to all listeners, all males within earshot or all females. You still don’t know how to target specific people but in this case you don’t need to.

You cast the spell and find out that Rob, while he is attracted to Ai’s almost naked body feels guilty about it and about his part in her predicament. She, surprisingly, does trust the mystery male but is still frightened and uncomfortable. Her **** smile, it seems, is to hide this so as not to make her only companion feel bad.

Given this revelation you decide to change Ai’s punishment to something more pleasant for both she and Rob. Something that will, perhaps, help him gain some confidence.

You begin by casting with the spell ‘Adauge Voluptatem’ on Ai increasing the pleasure she experiences from all sensation. You sense her becoming less uncomfortable as the touch of Rob’s hand feels nicer, the blindfold on her face feels softer and more sensual, the G-string between her legs seems to be touching her most intimate parts in a most intimate way, the sheets beneath her body seem softer, like silk or velvet, and even the shackles began feel pleasant around her wrists and ankles, like the hands of a lover. She begins to relax and, as you planned, begin to become sexually aroused.

Ai looks to where she thinks Rob is standing “You know” she says “You can touch other parts of me if you like. It’s o.k. I trust you.” Rob, while happy to oblige is too afraid of doing something wrong to know where to start. Thankfully Ai seems to have realised that her mystery man is not the sort to act without tacit instruction. “Start with my face.” she says.

“Mmm” she says as he places the back of his hand on her face “That’s nice, you have very nice hands. Touch my lips.” As he does so she puts out her tongue and licks the tips of his fingers seductively. “Mmm… you taste nice.” She leans forward sucking his fingers and you decide to reward her with another spell (Coniunctum Labia) causing her to groan around Rob’s fingers as she finds herself ‘vividly imagining’ (actually feeling) how they would feel between her other lips. Rob’s cock is quickly hardening.

“Where else would you like to touch me?” she asks breathily “Would you like to touch my breasts? Because I think I’d like that.”

Rob takes his hand, fingers wet with her saliva, and moves it to her breast, cupping it. “Oh” she gasps “Oh that feels nice. You are very good at this, but then I’m sure all the girls say that.” Rob looks at you, wondering what he is doing right. You gesture that he should try both hands.

Rob does so and, thanks to you spell, Ai groans as her breasts react to his touch with more pleasure than she has ever experienced from such ministrations. “Oh God!” Ai moans “That feels so good. Oh… Oh yes.”

Suddenly, without permission or warning Rob leans forward and kisses Ai’s lips which, thanks to your spell linking the feelings of her mouth to her nether lips cause her body to buck. Rob stops, wondering what he has done but Ai cries out. “Yes! Kiss me! Kiss me all over! Kiss every part of me!”

Rather than kissing her lips again Rob moves his face down to her breasts and begins kissing them causing her to moan and squirm with increased pleasure.

You look between Ai’s legs and realise that her pussy is now weeping with moisture. You are about to direct Rob toward it what Ai sobs. “Please … Please I’m so horny … I … I need you to … to fuck me … with your fingers… your mouth… your cock … I don’t care!”

Rob looks to you for instruction. You cast a spell (anima sermonis (soul speech) allowing you to speak to his mind. “Put your cock in her.” you instruct “Move inside her as you did with me.”

Rob quickly puts his hand down and moves her G-string over to allow him access to her oozing cunt. He then positions his cock at her entrance before slowly burying himself insider her.

“Oh my! … Oh my! … fuck! … you … you’re so big and … oh God! … I’ve … I’ve … my …” Ai looses the power of speech as Rob’s cock fills her with more joy than any cock before it. He moves inside her driving her closer and closer to the greatest orgasm of her life. you quickly speak the spell that will align their orgasms and then another that will transfer her devotion from yourself to him the moment she sees him. As they are about to peak you instruct him to take off her blind-fold so they can look into each other’s eyes at the moment of climax and then leave. Before you close the door you hear Ai cry out “ROB! OH ROB! OH GOD! I LOVE YOU! I … I … I … I’m sorry … I’m so sorry … I hurt you … I … I want you … I want to …”

“It’s O.k.” say Rob.

“It’s not.” says Ai “I need to make it up to you. Please…”

“O.k.” says Rob “How about this. You can make it up to me by telling me when you are horny so I can be the one to help you out.”

“Only if you do the same for me”

“The Mistress said I had to talk to Tina or Ashley first and only come to you if they said no.”

“New Rule” you say walking back in causing Ai to lower her eyes and look a little scared. “Ai now you belong to Rob as well as me. He may use you before Tina and Ashley if he desires.”

“Thank you Mistress” they both say and you smile and leave them to themselves, taking they book and leaving the key to Ai’s shackles.