Abstain

You have enough on your plate without adding a captive woman to the mess. You're supposed to be a respectable man of industry after all, not a warlord. It's beneath a man of your station and upbringing to act like a barbarian. You turn your back on the Carib's and head back to the boats, trying to figure out how you will fit your crew, those you've rescued, and those you've captured into the fleet.

After a few hours of pillaging the enemy village, your crews are ready to head out, heavily laden with stolen goods and people. The work rowing back is extra difficult, but your people are in high spirits, and the trip even feels faster than when you came out. The news of your success spreads fast upon making landfall back on Hispaniola. Along the way home you are greeted by small groups of well-wishers, eager to hear stories and sometimes share gifts with the conquerors of their mutual foes. The festivities do not end there however. The settlement, having already heard the rumors, has organized a small party on short notice, welcoming the return of their fellows and the arrival of their spoils.