Abbie pretends to ignore Stefan while he fucks her

Content that Tyler knew who was boss (at least in this moment), Michelle turned her attention forward again, where Dominic was still enjoying the contrasting options of whose mouth he wanted to slide his dick in and out of. Michelle was tight, aggressive, and each pump into her mouth left Dominic half-wondering if he'd come out of it alive. Abbie, on the other hand, was gentler, softer, and was more generous with her tongue and lips in pleasuring Dominic.

"Aw, did I overwhelm you?" Michelle asked in faux concern as Dominic stepped to his right to take advantage of Abbie for a bit.

Dominic let out a small grunt as he eased his dick into Abbie's mouth. "Nah, just didn't want my girl here to feel left out."

"Your girl?" Michelle laughed. "She's about to be his girl." She gestured to Stefan, who, after one final slurp through Abbie's pussy, got up on his knees, and tugged on his thick cock to bring it back to life. Michelle leaned over the back of the couch to swat at Dominic with her left hand, but then quickly lost interest as Tyler hit a tender spot while thrusting deep into her.

Abbie had her mouth full of Dominic and wasn't even paying attention to the rest of the room around her. She didn't hear Michelle, she didn't even really notice that Stefan had taken a break from eating her out. But she couldn't ignore the stretch and the squeeze she felt as Stefan pushed the tip of his dick into Abbie's sopping wet cunt.

"Ohhhh ..." Abbie grunted, despite Dominic's cock still in her mouth. Her body tensed up at first, and she arched her back. But as she recognized what was happening, she attempted to relax into it, trying to loosen her body enough to let Stefan push himself inside her.

She pulled Dominic out of her mouth and idly stroked him as she lifted her head up to see what was happening down below. Stefan was on one knee, holding the base of his cock, and pushing the rest of it forward into Abbie's pussy. She was plenty aroused, plus Stefan's sloppy fellatio had left her very moist and lubricated. But the thickness of Stefan's dick was a lot to take in. Still, Abbie wasn't one to back down from a challenge. She breathed deeply, her mouth open, and stared intently at Stefan. He was looking down at her pussy, but she was staring straight at his eyes.

Her breathing was loud -- and apparently loud enough to get Stefan's attention. He looked up at her, and then slowly drove his hips forward, sliding his dick into her pussy. If he's not going to speak, then neither am I, she thought. With an involuntary smirk, she rested her body back into the sofa again, and reached for Dominic. He was plenty willing himself, and leaned over Abbie, allowing her to take his cock into her mouth again. He reached down and played with her tits a little, touched her stomach and marveled at how smooth she was.

"She's barely acknowledging you, dude," muttered Tyler. He didn't necessarily want to be watching Stefan fucking someone, but he was surprised that Abbie wasn't reacting more verbally.

Michelle turned back toward Tyler. "Dude barely talks. Maybe Abbie's doing the same."

"Yo, Abbie," said Tyler. "You know you've got a cock inside you, right?"

Abbie slipped her lips off Dominic just far enough to verbalize a short answer. "Yes."

"Dude's huge, you know that?"

"Mm-hm."

"You're cool over there? He's not breaking you in half?"

Abbie giggled. "I'm cool over here." She sucked harder on the tip of Dominic's dick, teasing the end with her tongue.

Stefan had pushed nearly all the way into Abbie's pussy by now. She was already very tight anyway, but around Stefan's thick girth, it felt incredible.

Michelle was still staring at Tyler over her shoulder. He had slowed his rhythm on her, obviously distracted by watching Abbie. "Hey, your dick is inside my pussy. How 'bout you focus?"

Tyler laughed. "I'm just ... I can't believe she's not reacting more."

"I'm way too busy seeing if I can make this other boy come on my face from an upside-down blowjob." Abbie stroked Dominic's dick again, and teased the tip some more.

"Wait, really?" Dominic said, suddenly concerned that he didn't understand the rules of the game.

Abbie cackled. "Sure, you want to come on me? Come on me." She sucked him harder after that, and could feel that Dominic was tightening up, trying to hold back. "Of course," she continued, taking his dick out of her mouth again. "You don't want to blow it all now and miss the grand finale."

"Grand finale?" said Tyler.

"The night is young," said Abbie mischievously.

She turned her head to the left, only enough to barely catch eyes with Michelle, sharing a sly smile. She flexed and relaxed her muscles, writhing slightly on the sofa, holding the moment of Stefan inside her (despite pretending to not notice him), holding the moment of Dominic over her head (knowing full well that he wasn't going to miss the grand finale), holding the moment of watching Michelle's body jolt into her side of the couch as Tyler pummeled away at her pussy. Her eyes closed as she allowed all the feelings of the moment to fill her body and then release as she relaxed.

With a satisfied sigh, she opened her eyes again, and found herself staring directly at Stefan. "Who knows what's in store?"