Abbie offers her pussy to Jake and her mouth to Michelle

Knowing that she wanted to get some attention herself, Abbie wasted no more time. She carefully positioned her legs on other side of Michelle's hips, and stuck her ass out toward Jake. She put her hands on Michelle's arms, and slowly lowered herself down atop Michelle.

"Maybe I should have asked first," said Abbie with a laugh. "But I'm optimistic that you'll go along with it."

Abbie leaned forward and engaged Michelle in a deep kiss, her tongue quickly finding its way into Michelle's mouth. After a beat, they separated.

"Sorry, what's that?" Michelle asked. "I can't hear you with your tongue in my mouth."

Abbie laughed again. She was always inclined toward a positive energy, and having sex only enhanced her sense of fun. Plus, sex with Jake -- and now sex with Michelle -- Abbie was pretty much in the best place she could possibly be. Everything about this scenario was an absolute joy to her.

She wiggled her ass, hoping to get Jake's attention. She was too busy making out with Michelle to look back, but had to imagine that he was well aware of her presence. If I were Jake, and my pussy was back there available to me, I'd fuck me. Abbie stopped kissing Michelle for a moment to laugh at her own inner monologue. "That's right," she said, out loud this time. "I'd fuck me."

"I'd fuck you too."

Jake's voice floated across the room, and Abbie felt a tingle go through her as she heard him. Moments later, she felt him too, as he pulled his dick out of Michelle and without breaking stride, plunged it straight into Abbie's pussy.

"You know I can't resist you, don't you?" said Jake.

Abbie kissed Michelle a little harder before breaking away and turning back to look at Jake. "Of course you can't. Who could?"

Jake fucked Abbie's pussy a while, then switched back to Michelle's. While drilling Michelle again, he leaned down and licked Abbie from behind for a bit, and then pushed his cock back inside her again. This time, while fucking Abbie, he reached his hands down and fingered Michelle. The whole while, Abbie and Michelle continued making out, groping one another's face, neck, and breasts as they did.

They repeated this ritual several times, Jake fucking each of them a bit and switching to the other, the two women kissing, licking, sucking, and groping.

Jake reached his hand underneath Abbie and touched her pussy as he fucked her. He slowly drew his cock out, stroking her gently as he did. Abbie stopped kissing Michelle for a moment and turned to look at Jake.

"Mm?" she said, partially a question, partially a soft exclamation of pleasure.

"Abbie," Jake said, holding her attention. He gently touched the tip of his dick to her ass. "Do you think I ..." he started, trailing off. He had hoped she might finish the thought for him, but instead she smirked.

"Do I think what, Jake?" Abbie wiggled her ass at him.

Jake chuckled. He realized she wanted to hear the question so she could answer it. "Would you like me to ..." He paused to take a breath, and press his cock a little more firmly against her. "... to fuck you in the ass?"

Abbie closed her eyes slowly and sighed. "Mm, Jake ... I'd love it if you fucked me in the ass." She reached her hand back and spread herself open for him.

Jake pushed the head of his dick against her asshole, but didn't penetrate her. He rubbed against her, sliding the tip up and down. Abbie shuddered as she felt him against her, pushing herself back toward him in an attempt to get him inside her. Jake wasn't quite as urgent, enjoying the feeling of just rubbing against her. Abbie's pussy was still very wet, and Jake also dragged his cock against her labia before touching her asshole again.

"Ooh, Jake ... don't tease me," Abbie cooed. She turned back to Michelle, kissing her again, and touching the sides of her face.

"What do you want, Abbie?" Jake said, leading her on.

Abbie lifted up from Michelle. "Mm, you know ..."

"Tell me," Jake whispered. He slid his dick back into her pussy for two or three quick thrusts.

"No, Jake, that's my pussy ..." she said, a slight edge of confusion in her voice.

Jake pulled back again and re-inserted himself in Michelle's vagina. Michelle immediately gasped, surprised (but equally delighted).

"And that's mine!" Michelle said, her body bouncing a little as Jake pumped into her.

"But Jake," Abbie said, "you said you would fuck my ass ..."

"And?"

"And ... I want you to fuck my ass ..." Abbie whimpered through a smile. "I need you to --"

But Abbie was interrupted. Jake pulled his cock out of Michelle again, and without hesitation, drive it straight into Abbie's ass.

"Jake!" she said sharply.

Jake snickered. He fucked her hard, drilling her ass with ****, each pump eliciting a moan or a yelp from Abbie. After twenty or so thrusts, he pulled his dick out, and much more carefully, slid it into Abbie's still wet and warm pussy. Half dozen pumps there, then to Michelle, then back to Abbie's cunt, then back to Abbie's ass.

Abbie's ass was tight, but Jake felt lubed up from fucking both Michelle and Abbie's pussies, both of which were very wet. Jake put his hands on Abbie's ass, spreading it, kneading it. He spit onto her asshole to add to the lubrication.

He switched back to Michelle for a bit, but acknowledged to himself that he preferred Abbie. The threesome was exciting, for sure, but even so, he wouldn't have been mad if it had just been the two of them together for the night.

Abbie and Michelle kept part of their focus on each other, still pawing and making out, but every time Jake switched partners, the women would get momentarily distracted by him. Jake even tried to time it out to catch them at particularly opportune moments -- like if Abbie was clearly getting in deep with tongue-kissing Michelle, Jake would slow down, pull out, and then surprise Abbie with a quick thrust. Okay, he admitted to himself, I guess the three-way play isn't so bad. He slowly drew back once more and slowly began fucking Abbie's pussy again.