Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 74 by zankoo zankoo

What's next?

Abbie and Stefan

Abbie had no idea how big Stefan's cock was. It was just ... big. She was absolutely no size queen, and if she was being honest, there was a point at which being big didn't increase her pleasure any more. If anything, she found pleasure in how she connected to the people -- though sometimes that connection was the way a cock fit into her pussy.

Stefan's fit tightly.

He started the evening kind of surly and grumpy. He warmed up a tiny bit when things began to heat up, but he never really turned on any kind of charm. Abbie found him interesting, but distant. Sometimes when men were aloof, she'd be curious and would long to learn more. Not really the case here with Stefan. She enjoyed fucking him, for sure, but there was little need for more.

So when he arrived at her feet, she looked at him and smiled, she fingered her pussy a bit (partly to maintain her own stimulation, and partly to let him know that this was what she wanted from him), and then she closed her eyes.

While Abbie's eyes were closed, she breathed more deeply. She was a little concerned that she might fall asleep, but as soon as she felt Stefan's cock pressing against her labia, she knew that wasn't going to happen. She breathed in, and out. In, and out.

On a deep breath in, she felt Stefan penetrate her. She held her breath for a moment, waiting for Stefan to fully enter her. He did, and Abbie convinced her body to relax, to receive Stefan inside her. As he drew back, she breathed out.


Once they had a slow routine going, Abbie's breathing evened out. Stefan didn't seem to need to talk about anything. In a way, Abbie wondered why he was even fucking her. She wanted to ask him, do you even enjoy this? but decided she'd rather live in her own dream than risk pushing questions she wouldn't like the answers to.

Stefan fucked her mechanically. In and out, very steady, very even. Abbie wondered what his climax would be like. Would his intensity fade or increase? Would the color of his face change? Would he come inside her the way Tyler and Dominic had previously? _Her _curiosity was piqued, for sure. His, probably not.

She opened her eyes and looked over at Jake and Michelle. Watching Jake opened more to the world than fucking Stefan, she decided. She had no regrets about doing exactly what she was doing with exactly she was doing it with. But she watched Jake, the way he ran his fingers through Michelle's hair, the way he gripped her hips as he fucked her from behind, the way his irregular rhythm led to infinitely new possibilities in their intercourse.


Abbie glanced back up at Stefan. His face hadn't changed much. He was staring at her, but she couldn't quite figure out what he was looking at. Her hair? Her ear? Maybe his mind was elsewhere. Stefan's dick was impressive, and that was pretty much the end of it.

She watched his face tense up a bit, and she wondered whether that was an orgasm face. Was he about to come? she asked herself. Then she saw him jerk his body a bit and shake his head. He stopped fucking her for a minute, and pinched his dick with his hand.

"I think I might have ..." he began quietly.

"Did you come in me?" Abbie asked plainly.

"I think I started to. But I'm holding it back." He didn't look comfortable.

"Don't **** yourself! Go on, finish the job!"

"Huh?"

Abbie sighed. "In me or on me, but don't waste it!"

Stefan took a breath and jammed his cock back into Abbie's pussy. This time, it felt bigger to her. He had successfully staved off the full orgasm, even if he had had a mini climax a moment earlier. But three or four more pumps into her, and he was back. He slowed down, pushed hard inside her, and released.

Abbie could feel the waves of semen filling her. Stefan still had a hand at the base of his cock, and as he climaxed, he squeezed himself a bit as if to coax more jizz into her vagina.

Stefan backed up again, still holding his dick in his hand. He pulled all the way out, then thrust back into Abbie's cunt. Out again, and back in. He pinched his dick with his fingers, pushing out the last bits of come. He slid out one more time and slapped his now softening dick on her labia. Finally, he stepped back, looking at her.

Abbie looked back at him and winked. She was confident that she probably wouldn't find herself in another circumstance with Stefan, and that was just fine with her. She turned her head back toward Jake. Somehow, he sensed that she was looking his way, and he looked toward her as well.

"Don't forget me," said Abbie.

"I could never," said Jake. He turned back to Michelle and swatted her on the ass a bit. "Let's go over here," he said to Michelle, "and see what we've missed."

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)