A shared fantasy and punishment for Josslyn and Kennedy

About fifteen minutes later the two sisters entered the dungeon in matching pink dresses with white sashes around their waists that looked to be suited better for little girls than full grown women along with white knee high socks and black Mary-Janes. Their long blonde hair had been tied into long pigtails with pink and white ribbons.

"Are you ready for your punishments girls?" Carson asked.

"Yes Daddy," the girls said together.

"Good, now Kennedy since you were the one with my cock in your mouth this morning, I'm guessing the double blowjob was your idea?"

"It was Daddy, I'm sorry, I thought you'd like it."

"I did like it baby, but, you did as you wanted with out being told to do it. What do good girls do?"

"They do as their Daddies say," Kennedy answered nervously.

"That's right Kennedy. Now since it was your idea, your punishment will last until tomorrow morning and will begin upstairs. Josslyn, I'm going to put you on that spanking bench and spank you, but, I will give you a choice. You can choose Daddy's hand and be spanked until I think you've had enough, choose the strap and take twelve lashes, choose the cane and take eight strokes, or choose the paddle and take four hard swats."

"Paddle please Daddy," Josslyn said with a nervous sigh.

"Go wait by the spanking bench young lady," Carson ordered as he took Kennedy by the arm and led her to a tall narrow cage that she would be **** to stand in.

"Yes Daddy," Josslyn said making her way to the bench.

He opened the cage, and guided Kennedy in backwards so she would be **** to watch Josslyn's paddling. He then walked over to Josslyn and had her kneel on the end of the spanking bench. Without being told she slowly bent over the elevated section that was angled away from her and placed her hands on the small pads on either side of the mulk of the structure. With Josslyn in place he used the long straps placed at the thighs and lower back to keep her on the bench and the two smaller ones on the small pads to keep her hands in place. Finally he flipped Josslyns dress up and pulled down the Disney themed panties she was wearing down.

"Josslyn, I want you to ask for each swat, Kennedy I want you to count each of your sister's swats."

"Yes Daddy," the girls answered together. He went over to a rack of paddles and selected a small circular one and went back to Josslyn putting it against her ass.

"I'm waiting Josslyn," he said sternly after a few seconds.

"May I please have my swat Daddy?" Josslyn asked. WHACK! "Ow! I'm sorry Daddy!"

"One Daddy," Kennedy quickly counted.

"May I please have my swat Daddy? WHACK! "AAHH!" Josslyn screamed as tears began to stream down her face.

"Two Daddy."

"May I please have my swat Daddy?" Josslyn asked through her tears. WHACK!

"Three Daddy."

"May I please have my swat Daddy?" WHACK!

"Four Daddy." With her paddling over he pulled Josslyn's panties back up and let her off the bench. She slowly stood and he hugged her tightly, and kissed her lips softly.

"You took your paddling like a good girl, I'm very proud of you," he said with a smile.

"Thank you Daddy," Josslyn said wiping the last of her tears away.

He then let Kennedy out of the cage and took the twins up to the second story and to a room he had not shown them on the tour the night before. When he opened the door and turned on the light they were greeted by the sight of an adult nursery. The walls were painted pink with white trim. Several large stuffed animals sat on the hardwood floor. Adult cribs sat against the left wall both were white with pink bedding, Two small twin beds were placed with their headboards against the far wall. each was pink with a Disney Princess comforter. Next to the twin beds there was an open door walk in closet full of childish clothes. Finally against the right wall there was an adult sized changing table, with a supply of pink frilly reusable diapers.

"Kennedy, your punishment will be to spend until tomorrow as a baby. Take your big girl clothes and go lay on the changing table."

"Ye," Kennedy began before being cut off by Carson placing his index finger to her lips.

"Babies don't speak," he said sternly before heading into the walk in closet. Kennedy silently took off her clothes and laid on the changing table. Carson soon returned with a yellow adult romper with teddy bears on it, matching yellow booties, and an over sized pacifier on a long yellow ribbon, one end of which having two D-rings on it. "Open up," he said, holding the pacifier by her mouth. She opened her mouth and the pacifier went in. Carson then buckled it around her head effectively gagging Kennedy. "Until tomorrow morning Kennedy you will wear and use diapers, wear adult baby clothes, and you will have nothing inf your belly but baby formula," Carson explained as he lifted Kennedy's legs and ass off the table, placed a diaper under her and began to heavily powder her ass and pussy. The beautiful blonde flushed with embarrassment and grunted into her pacifier. "Now now, don't be a fussy baby," Carson said with a slight laugh as he ran his fingers through her hair and gently kissed her forehead. Before long Kennedy was dressed and sitting on the floor hugging a large teddy bear.

"Oh my God, Kennedy, you look so cute like that!" Josslyn said excitedly.

"Come on girl's it's lunch time," Carson said leading the girls down stairs. He fixed Josslyn a peanut butter and jelly sandwich as he warmed a large bottle of formula for Kennedy. Once, the sandwich was made and the formula wormed he took the girls into the living room and set Josslyn's plate on the coffee table, and took a seat on the couch. "Kennedy, come here," he said as patting the cushion next to him. Kennedy sat next to him and he re-positioned her so that she laid across him, her head and neck being supported by his left arm. He removed the pacifier and replaced it with the nipple of the large bottle of formula.

"I am getting so wet Daddy," Josslyn said as she took a bite of her sandwich and watched her sister being fed like a baby.

"Josslyn, don't talk with your mouth full," Carson said looking at the other blonde sister.

"Sorry Daddy."

"There's a vibrator in that box on the coffee table by your plate. I want you to turn it on low and hold it against the outside of Kennedy's diaper."

"Yes Daddy," she answered as she began to vibe her sister.

"Once your sister's bottle is gone, Daddy's going to put you both down for a nap.

"But I'm not tired Daddy," Josslyn protested.

"Don't talk back, do you want another spanking young lady?"

"No Daddy."

Two hours later Josslyn woke from her nap to the sound of Kennedy's exaggerated crying." she walked over to the crib her sister was in and pulled the blanket back. Having heard Kennedy on a baby monitor Carson walked in.

"I think she wet her diaper Daddy."

"I'll change her," he said dropping the side of the crib. "Come on Kennedy, on the changing table." It didn't take long before Kennedy was cleaned and re-diapered.

The rest of the day passed quickly and uneventfully. After dinner, a steak and potatoes for him, mac and cheese for Josslyn, and another bottle for Kennedy he tucked Kennedy back into her crib, now in a pink onesie.

"You've handled this punishment very well Kennedy, I'll reward you in the near future. Good night," he whispered to her before kissing her forehead.

"Are you going to tuck me into bed too Daddy?" Josslyn asked having changed into an Elsa night shirt.

"No, Josslyn, for being such a good girl for me today you'll sleep in the big bed with me." Not long after, Josslyn was naked on Carson's bed on all fours as he took position behind her. She moaned softly feeling the head of his cock rub up against her pussy.

"Please fuck me Daddy, I'll be such a good girl for you," She pleaded before Carson buried himself balls deep in her tight pussy.

Carson has lived out one of the twins fantasies, and of course his own. How will he reward Kennedy for taking her all day punishment? Let her cum as much as she wants for a day? Let her choose the next fantasy the three live out? Let her dom her sister while he watches? Or will she choose to have her sister be in charge? Answer in comments.

A) Kennedy cums whenever she wants for a day.

B) Kennedy chooses what the next fantasy they live out will be, but, Carson decides when.

C) Kennedy takes her Josslyn to the dungeon and Carson watches.

D) Kennedy has Josslyn take her to the dungeon while Carson watches.

E) Something else. What?