A halftime show

“Wait what Lily? You serious right now? You don’t have to-” George’s eyebrows had shot so far up they almost leapt off his face, but Lily doubled down in her panic. “Look, if you all swear to secrecy, I’ll let you do whatever you want to me tonight and we’ll never speak of it again.” The agony of the choice was etched into George’s face, torn between what his conscience told him was right and the throbbing in his cock said was even more right. “Prove it.” All eyes landed on Jason who stood arms outstretched, leaving easy access to his belt and zipper.

An all too familiar heat coursed through Lily’s body as she surrendered to instinct, peeling off her shirt and dropping it. Moving to Jason she fell to her knees and undid his jeans, sliding them down to reveal a rapidly rising familiar dick. Mickey cursed softly as Lily wrapped her lips around the shaft, pumping the base with one hand. Her mouth gliding up and down the spit slicked length Lily dropped a hand down to her own jeans and dragged a finger against her rapidly dampening pussy. It was George’s turn to curse under his breath, and before Lily knew it Mickey was standing next to Jason and unbuckling his own pants. Continuing to pump her hand along Jason’s cock, Lily turned and took Mickey into her mouth. Swirling her tongue around his sensitive tip, she was rewarded with the taste of salty pre-cum on her tongue.

On the other side of Jason, George took his place and growled “we will NEVER fucking speak of this,” dropping his own trousers and revealing a thick uncut cock. As her mouth moved and tongue extended to suck George’s cock, Lily knew what she was doing was beyond stupid. Covering up an indiscretion with Jason by not only helping him cheat on his wife again, but also Cassie’s fiancé? She made a mental note to get a therapist, but the thought faded as she sank down the length of George’s cock to the base, her nose brushing against the wiry bush as she fought against her gag reflex. Her cousin’s fiancé, and close personal friend shuddered, how many times had she crashed on his couch, hung out with him and Cassie, been chosen as the future maid of honor at the wedding. Now she was throating his cock swapping between two other men in the middle of his living room.

Now that all three cocks in front of her were rock hard, Lily stood and shimmied out of her pants, presenting her fully nude form to the men. Despite George’s apprehension, Mickey and Jason wasted no time in exploring her body, groping her ass, and pawing at her tits. Jason slid a finger into her sopping wet cunt, snickering at how shamefully wet she was before holding up the digit to Lily’s face. Lily subserviently licked her own juices off his finger, even if this was insanely inappropriate and stupid, she was unbearably horny. She’d always had a schoolgirl crush on George, he wasn’t that much older than her and Cassie had raved about how perfect he was for years.

Pushing any thoughts of Cassie out of her head, Lily laid a hand on George’s shoulder and pushed him back first onto the couch. His face was inscrutable, but he offered no resistance then, nor when Lily mounted him and slid his cock inside her. His only reaction was a gasp of pleasure as he felt her tight walls snug around his manhood. Lily locked eyes with Jason, and motioned for him to get behind her, prompting a wide-eyed stare and muttered “damn you really are a fucking freak girl.” Lily figured the stretching from all Quinn’s butt plugs would be enough to facilitate her plan. She heard Jason spit on his cock and line up with her puckered little asshole, both him and George apparently having no qualms with the close proximity.

Lily let out a little “oh fuuuuuck” as Jason slowly eased his cock into her ass. The sensation of the two throbbing cocks inside her at once was divine, rolling her hips ever so slightly to work them both at once. Lily looked over at Mickey, seeming a little bitter to either be left out or settle for sloppy seconds. With a nod of her head, she beckoned him to stand beside her. It was a little tough to manage with how her body swayed from the double fucking, but Lily managed to fit Mickey’s cock in her mouth to pleasure all three men simultaneously.

The feeling of George in her pussy and Jason in her ass, separated only the slightest of distances, felt unlike anything she’d ever experienced. Lily had had Tom fuck her while she had a plug in but to have two thick dynamic cocks working into her at once was too intense for words. Her groans of pleasure were muffled by Mickey’s cock lodged deep in her throat. She felt like a sex goddess, drunk on the intoxicating musk of the men as they took her body completely. When she needed a break for air, she jacked off Mickey’s cock for all she was worth, bouncing between George and Jason who’d finally managed to settle into perfect synchronicity. While one plunged in, the other slid out, over and over, filling her perfectly. On one break for air from Mickey’s blowjob, George slid his shaft in a little deeper than before, setting off a powerful quaking orgasm deep in her core. “Ohhhhhh mmmmmmmfffuckkkk oh oh oh oh my-y-y-y-y god fuck fuck fuck FUCK” but the men didn’t stop.

Mickey slapped his cock across her face as if annoyed by the interruption, prompting Lily to take him back into her mouth. Every muscle in her body spasming, Lily barely had the fine motor control to move her tongue. Two powerful hands gripping her ass wrenched her back to reality as Jason grunted, warm cum filling her ass as he gave her a rough slap for good measure. The slap jolted Lily’s head and she pushed past her gag reflex to hilt Mickey’s cock down her throat. This proved to be just the edge Mickey had needed, and he grabbed her head firmly as jets of warm cum surged into Lily from the other end.

Mickey and Jason moved over to the other couch panting, quietly murmuring to each other “holy fuck dude” and “yeah man I fucking TOLD you.” The absence of his friends inside Lily seemed to jolt something awake in George- “Both of you, get dressed and get the fuck out. If you ever breath a word of this, I’ll feed you your fucking teeth.” Despite the harsh tone and brutal threat, George didn’t alter his pace or loosen his grip on Lily’s hips. Grumbling, Mickey and Jason quickly obeyed, and in moments had disappeared off into the night.

Once the door had slammed shut, George sat up on the couch, pulling Lily up with him so that she straddled his lap. Still inside her, his strong arms helping her hips grind into his, George finally made eye contact with Lily. “She told me you know, what happened at the show.”

Lily’s jaw dropped; George knew she’d had sex with Cassie?! “She told me right away Lily; we don’t keep secrets from each other. I’m gonna tell her we fucked as soon as she gets home.” Conceptually she heard and understood the words coming out, but they were so unexpected they sounded like gibberish. George lifted a calloused hand to the back of her neck, “And you know what Lily? I’d bet anything it’s going to make her so fucking horny.” As if she didn’t weigh anything at all, George stood up, sinking even deeper inside her and pressed her back against the wall thrusting up into Lily’s cunt. “I’d bet she’s going to want to know every slutty detail and demand I fuck her then and there.” He increased his pace, picture frames on the wall knocked askew by the ****. “I’d even bet she’s going to ask me if we could fuck you together, do you want that, Lily?”

Before she could respond, seeming to not care that Mickey had cum in her mouth minutes before, George pressed a fierce kiss to her lips. The intimacy of the act, from a man she’d trusted since she was an awkward nervous teenager, the life partner of her cousin and best friend, felt more impactful and momentous than being triple penetrated. Lily lost herself in the kiss, her limbs clinging desperately to George’s muscular body. When the kiss finally broke Lily panted “yes yes fuck oh my god George always anything- you feel so fucking good yes you Cassie both- y-e-e-eh-ssssssssssuh.” Another orgasm coursed through her, and George kissed her again, pulling her down as hard as he could onto his cock.

George finally came, a torrent of cum pulsing into Lily’s pussy, refusing to let the kiss end as he leaned his full weight against her into the wall. The aftershocks of Lily’s orgasm tingled, little sparks of pleasure hitting her nerve endings as the kiss finally ended and she rested her head on George’s shoulder. He gently lifted her off his dick, chuckling at Lily’s gasp at the sudden void within her, and placed her tenderly on the couch. Sitting beside her, George stroked Lily’s thigh and gazed off into the distance pensively.

Lily had no idea what to make of the events of the evening, of everything that had happened since her sexual awakening nothing held a candle to fucking Cassie and George. “George…” she started hesitantly, reminding herself that being awkward was sort of pointless after they’d just had sex, “Cassie isn’t mad at me? She’s not going to be mad at me?” Lily felt like a scared child again, terrified of being alone in the world that didn’t seem to care. George wrapped her in a tight hug, comforting and loving, intimate in a far different way than what they’d just done. “Lily, Cassie loves you with her whole heart. There’s nothing you could ever do that would change that. And I’m pretty fond of you too. Did I expect you two to accidentally end up having a wild gay hookup at your girlfriends show? Nope. Did I expect anything about tonight? Also no.” George smiled his charming easy grin, the kind of smile that radiates confidence and reassurance, “Cassie is the love of my life, gonna marry her someday soon. But we’ve been talking a lot about spicing stuff up, we’ve been together for most of our lives and fear we missed out. This week just accelerated it a bit.”

Lily sniffled and wiped away a tear, “jesus you really are the perfect fucking guy George. I’m glad you and Cassie have each other.” George laughed again, gently cupping Lily’s chin, “it’s all gonna be just fine Lily, better than fine. I’ll text Cassie and tell her to get home, and my guys know better than to ever speak about tonight. It’s all gonna be ok.” As if to seal his promise, he leaned in a planted a loving kiss on Lily’s lips. Lily melted into it once more, and as they pulled away George’s cock had begun to stir with new life. Noticing her eyes on his erection, George laughed “Let’s save it for when Cass gets home, c’mon let’s get you cleaned up.”

The pair tidied the living room and took turns with quick showers to rinse off. By the time Cassie walked through the door, George and Lily were cuddled up on the couch in sweats drinking beer and watching a movie.