Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 2

What's next?

A few dates later

After a few more dates, they had both had enough of taking it slow and decided to relax at James' place. They had talked about all sorts of things, including the more sexual topics, and Mary had told him that she had her penis since birth. James had not asked any specifics, but judging by the remarks of doctors that Mary had quoted while giving James the biological explanation of her situation, it was quite large. This also explained why she usually wore long dresses. Often with flowery prints and vibrant colors. Luckily for Mary, her genitals did not seem to bother James. In fact, Mary started to realize that if anything, James liked her even more for it.

"So do you want a drink?" James said.

"I won't say no to a glass of wine." Mary answered, as she made herself comfortable on the couch in his living room.

Mary was taking her shoes off as James made his way back to the couch. Her long, red hair fell playfully around her face. God she was beautiful. He set the glasses down, but neither had time to drink any. As soon as he sat himself next to her James took her Mary's face in his hand and kissed her. Mary leaned into James, placing one of her tiny hands on his chest and exploring his abs underneath his shirt. Their tongues intertwined as James let one of his hands wander down to her breasts. They were already big, but on Mary's frame they looked massive. She let out a cute, giggling moan as James squeezed on of them gently.

"You like them?"

She placed her hand on his crotch, feeling his hardness.

"I guess you do" She giggled.

James let out a sigh as Mary rubbed him over his pants. She pushed him over gently, sitting down sideways on his lap as he lied down with his back against the armrest. They continued kissing and groping, until Mary got off of him, trying to undo his pants. James hesitated while he lifted himself off the couch to aid Mary in her efforts, but he did not have time to object before she had already stripped his pants off, underwear and all. It was a meagre four inches, tapping James' belly as it sprung free. A rush of embarrassment flushed through James, who closed his eyes to hide away from her reaction. Mary however, noticed this instantly.

"It's beautiful!" She cheered Joyfully. And without hesitation she kissed its tip.

James let out a moan as Mary's lips made contact with his sensitive penis. He was almost ready to burst from the excitement already, but managed to restrain himself.

Mary now took his member into her mouth. She wanted to make him feel good. She understood his embarrassment, but she truly did find it beautiful. It was hard, exited and cute. She did not need it to be big, as she had never been really interested in being on the receiving end.

James let out a gasp as Mary started playing with his balls with one of her tiny hands. He looked down. In her hands, his member looked quite good. But the best part was the enthusiasm with which Mary went down on his cock. She made love to him with her mouth. Genuinely enjoying the act. She let one of her hands wander down to his bottom, feeling his round ass and letting out a positive hum on his cock when she felt the shape of it. She had already fantasized about James' booty, but the reality was even better. She removed her groping hand and let it down under her dress. James could only guess what she did there. But quickly her hand came back from under there and found its way to his sphincter. She had used her own precum, which there seemed to be plenty of, as lubricant and slid two of her fingers in his tight hole. They were both each other's first, but Mary had already researched what to do. Her studies paid off, as she immediately found his prostate.

"Oh what the-" James gasped, as his cock jumped in reaction to the newfound pleasure.

Mary's mouth was at the base of James' cock while her fingers worked magic on his prostate. James was almost going to burst before he stopped her.

"W- wait!"

Mary stopped and looked up and let her fingers slip out his bum. Gently drawing circles around it as James caught his breath.

"I want to see it." James said.

Mary hesitated, but nodded slowly as she scooted backwards on the couch. James quickly stripped his shirt off before looking in anticipation. Mary was about to lift up her dress but suddenly stopped.

"Close you eyes." She said.

James nodded and did as she said. James could only listen as she took off her clothes, hearing the ruffling of fabric and the noise of her moving on the couch. He could sense her scooting closer before he felt a small hand gently grab ahold of his cock again. Her thumb rubbing his frenulum ever so slightly.

"Open them"

What James saw next was the hottest thing he had ever seen. Her beautiful face beamed down with a shy, but exited look, surrounded by her playful, red hair. Her large breasts were moving along her exited breathing, taking up the space of the majority of her upper body. Yet below her breasts pointed a massive, throbbing, veiny cock! It absolutely dwarfed his own member. It must have been a bit over a foot long, making James wonder in amazement how she had ever been able to hide it from him. It twitched in excitement as it loomed above his own member. The head of her cock was huge, shining with precum. A large drop of it was threatening to fall onto James. Below her cock were two massive, tangerine sized balls, looking warm and slightly sweaty.

"Wow." Was all that James was able to say. "Wow." He repeated. Now speaking slightly louder as if he wanted Mary to hear his amazement.

"You like it?" Mary asked, still gently rubbing his cock.

James nodded. "It's so huge!" He said, as he hesitantly reached out to it. He didn't have to reach far before his hand was greeted by the heat emanated from her massive member.

"I'm glad you do-" Mary gasped as she felt his hand on her cock for the first time. She let him explore for a bit, reaching up to her breasts and rolling a nipple in between one of her fingers. She started leaking precum like crazy, and frequent drops started splashing on James' belly and his own member.

"It's so warm!" James whispered excitedly as he started to touch her member more confidently. He let one of his hands explore her massive, low-hanging balls, cupping them and feeling their weight. His other hand ran up and down her seemingly endless length. James did not have small hands, but Mary's cock was so thick his hand did not even get close to wrapping around her entire girth. Mary didn't leave all the fun to James however, and started to continue her work on James' ass. She used the precum that had dripped down on James' cock and spread it over her hand. Quickly she found his prostate again. This time however, she let go of his cock, giving all his attention to his ass instead.

James let out a moan of pleasure. He had a hard time keeping focus on exploring his girlfriend's beautiful cock. The pleasure that Mary's tiny fingers were giving him was something he had never experienced before. Mary got closer to kiss James as she was fingering his bum. As they did, their cocks started rubbing onto each other. Loads of Mary's precum lubed up both of their genitals. Mary, being much shorter, was now sitting on James' lap, not being in reach of his lips otherwise. One hand was resting on James' manly chest to support herself. The other was behind her back, with her fingers rubbing on James' prostate. Mary's balls engulfed James' much smaller penis almost completely, while Mary's monster pointed upwards, rubbing her precum between her tits.

This went on for only a few more minutes. James was on the verge of release, but then Mary removed her fingers from his tight hole and shifted her weight off of him. Before James could realize what was going on, Mary had placed the huge, shining head of her rod against James' tight opening. James curled up his torso, reaching to kiss Mary again. As they engaged in a passionate, sloppy kiss, Mary pushed forward, her huge, precum-lubed cock starting to penetrate him. James cringed in pain, but it wasn't so bad as he was anticipating. perhaps because he hadn't had time to think about it, perhaps because of the wine Either way, James didn't have time to care, for as soon as her head popped inside, it pressured his prostate like Mary's fingers never could have. If there was any pain, it was completely overpowered by the pleasure.

As it happened, they moaned in unison, interrupting their sloppy kiss. The pleasure was so good that Mary could not do anything other than pushing further in his warm, virgin hole.

"Ohhh" James moaned. "You're inside of me!" He said, shocked with Mary's bold move, but filled with ecstasy.

"Ahh yes baby!" Mary moaned. Having her massive member almost completely ingulfed by James' warmth was a feeling unlike any other.

"I love you, James!" Said Mary, looking into her boyfriend's eyes.

"I love you too, Mary! F*ck you're amazing!" James moaned back to her. The pressure on his prostate almost overwhelming him. "Mary, I-" James' face cringed as small torrents of cum erupted from his erect cock, hitting the bottom of Mary's round breasts. James arched his back, which only made Mary's monster press harder onto his prostate. Their faces were now separated by some distance, and Mary looked in love and awe as her sweetheart came on her thick cock.

"Oh sweetie!" Mary said, happy that her lover was feeling this good. She let him calm for a bit. And when James' orgasm subsided she pulled out her cock, leaving only the tip inside of him.

"Oh James you feel amazing!" Mary said, slowly inching her cock back inside him. She took his hands and placed them on her tits as she pulled out again.

"Mary... you're- ah!" James was having a hard time talking. The majority of the length of Mary's massive beast slowly sliding back and forth over his prostate was too much. "Mary... wa- wait!"

Mary stopped moving and let James collect his thoughts. "Can we move this to the bedroom?" He asked, panting. "It uh... It is getting pretty messy." James said, looking to the cum on his stomach and the precum all over the couch. Mary now looked around as well, as if she woke from a trance. "Yeah that's probably a good idea." She said laughing. James laughed as well and crunched his abs again, leaning in for a kiss. Then Mary slowly drew her cock back, pulling away from his warm hole and the kiss. They both let out a moan as Mary's massive glans was pulled from James' sphincter with a load 'pop'. Mary admired the sight, before leaning in for another kiss. Their cock were reunited once again as Mary rested her tiny body on James' torso. Her balls were sliding over his cock and her tits pressed against his chest as their tongues found each other once more. James let one of his hand wander down to the huge, hard dick pressing down on his stomach.

"Let's go then." James said. "I want to feel you inside of me again." He said, blushing but confidently giving her big rod a little squeeze.

"Okay tiger." Mary said with a smirk, giving James a quick kiss.

Without waiting, James picked Mary up, who let out a little yelp in response to his sudden action. As he carried her to his bedroom he took one of her nipples into his mouth. Mary let out an approving moan as she gave her member a few long strokes. James threw her on his bed and quickly joined her, laying down next to her. They started kissing again, this time James was vigorously stroking his girlfriends massive piece of meat. He enjoyed the heat and sheer size of it, especially since it was fit on her tiny body. It made it look even hotter somehow. He squeezed her boobs gently, alternating between them. Mary enjoyed the initiative, but she was too hungry for the feeling she had previously felt to be satisfied with a handjob. She slid away from him, grabbed his shoulder and pushed it down into the bed.

"Hey-" James protested amusedly, before feeling Mary get on top of his back. Now he understood. "New position?"

"You like it?" Mary whispered in his ear, before giving his neck a little kiss.

James hummed in approval, though he got a bit nervous because of the sudden change of pace. "Just- go slow again?" He asked, feeling Mary's long shaft slide between his asscheeks.

"Of course!" Mary kissed his lower back, making a trail of kisses that went more and more towards his butt. Her cock went down with her, covering his crack with precum. "I'll be gentle, baby." She said softly, now pulling her face away from James' back. "I don't want to hurt my sweet, strong man." She said, now massaging his buttcheeks with her tiny hands. Then she pulled them apart and pointed her huge piece of girlmeat at his entrance. Slowly she started pushing again. Her huge glans drove the walls of his sphincter apart. Despite his tightness, his ass gave little resistance to her cock. It was as if they were made for each other.

"Ahw yeah..." James moaned into his pillow, answering the moans of his girlfriend. To his left, he could see the mirrors of his closet, and in their reflection he could see his tiny angel working his butt with her massive cock. Mary immediately picked up where they left behind and continued slowly sliding in and out, using the full length of her miraculous penis.

"I think-" James stopped his sentence when Mary slid her cock inside him to the hilt. "-I like this-" Mary pulled out again, squeezing his ass with her tiny hands. "-position!" said James, before feeling Mary's cock slide back in. All the way. "OH my-" James exclaimed.

"I've read about this one." Said Mary, who was breathing heavily as she fucked James' ass slowly. "It allows my cock to point right at your prostate."

"I don't think-" James moaned as Mary's cock slid past his prostate again. He was on the verge of cumming. Again. Boy was he lucky with this girl. "-your cock-" He continued before his sentence was broken up again by one of Mary's thrusts again. "-needed any help-" Mary pulled back again. "-with that!"

James was right. The thickness of Mary's member was so great that the position really didn't matter. It put such wonderful pressure on his prostate that it really didn't matter from which angle she did it.

"I love you Mary!" James exclaimed, before he felt that strange yet wonderful feeling overtake his body once more. He could feel himself cum on the sheets as his Girlfriend picked up the pace. She was still making slow, long strokes, but she was now using a bit more ****. Her balls were now slapping against James' ass and with every thrust her hips smashed his cheeks as well.

"OH I love you too James! Your ass is amazing!"

They both lost track of time. James came so many times he lost count. he was in a near constant state of orgasming by the feeling of Mary's amazing cock. With every thrust he could feel his hips being pushed into a wet spot made by his own cum. After a good long while however, Mary could feel herself getting close. Her balls had been swelling, getting ready for her release.

"Oh James!" She moaned loudly. "James turn around!" And James quickly did, sensing the situation at hand.

"I'm going to cum soon, baby!" Mary moaned. "I want to look at you when I do" She said smiling, sliding her cock back into his gaping asshole.

They moaned in unison as Mary entered James for the last time this evening. James reached out and took hold of one of Mary's round breasts.

"Cum for me, Mary. Cum inside me!" He encouraged her. He could feel her huge testicles slap against his asscheeks.

"Yes baby!" Mary panted. She was so very close. She could have never dreamed this moment, and yet here it was. "I'm gonna- OH!"

Huge torrents of cum shot inside James' ass as Mary's massive monster erupted. James felt his ass being filled with warm fluid, causing him to cum once more. Mary could feel her balls tighten and was lost in ecstasy as she was buried inside James to the hilt. "OH YES BABY!" James moaned loudly and he wrapped his legs around Mary's curvy hips. Her orgasm must have went on for an entire minute, before she collapsed onto James. Her head barely reaching his chest and her tits surrounding James' tired cock. Every now and then James could feel her twitch inside of him as they lay there panting. He stroked Mary's back and caressed their face as she lied there on top of him. A moment ago she was a sex machine. Now she was his little angel again. The moment turned from sexual and beastly to gentle and romantic. Eventually Mary pulled out her member, which was getting flaccid. Good thing too, James didn't think he could take another round.

Mary climbed a bit higher and was now laying half on top of James, with the other half on the bed. They shared a kiss and looked into each others' eyes. James then looked down. Both their cocks were next to each other on display. The contrast was almost poetic. Her much superior, albeit flaccid, cock was still more than twice as big as he ever could be when hard. Probably closer to three times. Yet beside him was the sweetest little woman imaginable. Mary's eyes were closed. Her breathing was slowing down. James took the blankets and pulled them over the both of them. Then they fell asleep.

What's next?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)