A circle jerk? Really?

“So what are we going to do until he gets here?” Carly asked.

“Hey, I have an idea,” I piped up. “How about a little game?” I suggested. “It’s a little twist on a game guys sometimes play. It actually goes pretty quick, at least when guys play it.”

“Sure,” Susie agreed. “We just need something quick, he’ll probably get here pretty quick. What’s your game?”

“Well, what you do is everybody forms a circle and starts masturbating. Whoever comes first wins. It’s called a circle jerk.” I looked at the girls and smiled.

“But we don’t have anything to jerk,” Amy pointed out. “How’s that going to work?”

“Well then, call it a circle jill if you want,” I replied. “We’re all already kinda sitting in a circle so everybody starts playing with themselves. I’ll beat off and you girls can finger yourselves. Same rules apply. Whoever cums first is the winner. Ok?”

“Ok,” the girls all agreed, giggling again.

“Ok. Ready? Go!”

I reached down and grabbed my thick cock. I was already hard again after fucking Carly outside not very long ago. All four girls started rubbing their pussies and watching them was making me even harder.

I started slowly at first, just long firm strokes as I eyed each of the girls in turn. I really didn’t care if I won or not. In fact, if I let one of them win and didn’t actually cum myself, that would just mean I would be ready to fuck one or more of them again soon.

As I continued to stroke slowly but firmly, I looked around the room. Susie hadn’t wasted any time, plunging two fingers deep into her kitty, rapidly pumping back and forth. She had her eyes closed and was squeezing her left boob with her other hand and I could tell her whole body was tensed up. She seemed to be intent on winning and the way she was working her tight pussy I imagined it wouldn’t take her very long to cum. I could never have imagined seeing my sister naked and masturbating right in front of me. It was definitely hot and I had to slow down a little to keep myself from getting too excited and cumming too soon.

Next to her, Amy was using a different technique. I couldn’t believe I was watching her getting herself off too; she was the one of my sister’s girlfriends I had lusted after the most and had had more than one jerk off session looking at some of her Facebook pictures and thinking about fucking her. I never would have believed that something like tonight would happen. She was holding her thick lips open with two fingers on one hand while pinching and rubbing her clit hard with the other. She was biting her lip and moaning and looking right at me, watching me stroke my hard dick. Our eyes met and we just smiled at each other as she kept right on working her honeypot.

Meanwhile Beth also had two fingers in her snatch but was also working her clit with her thumb. Instead of pumping in and out she was working her slick inner walls obviously massaging her g spot. Her feet were up on the sofa with her knees in the air and her legs spread wide, giving me a great view of her pussy as she worked it. I could see her juices already dribbling out between her fingers onto her cute little ass cheeks and it looked like she was about to be the winner.

Last there was Carly who I also had the hots for and had already enjoyed playing with her tonight. Unlike the other three, she had her legs stretched out straight in front of her and clinched tightly together at the knees. The palm of one hand was pressing hard against her mound while her other hand was pushed up inside her snatch underneath it. She was biting her lips and her eyelids were fluttering as she too was obviously close to the edge.

All four of them were working (playing?) hard, trying to cum while I just kept my slow and steady rhythm stroking my engorged rod. It was wildly exciting watching four young hotties trying to get themselves off while I watched, but I was careful to just stay on the edge and not go over it.

I was looking and trying to see who would actually cum first when Beth let out a banshee-like scream and her whole body shook like a bowl of jelly. She bent over from the intensity of her orgasm and was just clutching her cunt and holding on tight with both hands.

And then one by one, like dominoes falling, the other three girls came too. Next Susie, then Carly and finally Amy. What a sight it truly was, sitting there watching four hot teen girls thrashing in the throes of ecstasy right in front of me. I had to stop stroking and hold my steel hard shaft as tight as I could to keep myself from cumming too.

Slowly the girls recovered from their hard orgasms and just looked around the room like they were slightly bewildered.

“So I think I was first,” Beth finally managed to say. “What do I win?”

Before I could answer, the doorbell rang.

“Uh oh, pizza guy’s here,” I stated the obvious. “I guess you get to open the door, Beth,” I grinned. “Go on, girls. All four of you have to greet him.”