Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 436 by XarHD XarHD

What's next?

A Reunion

The elevator doors parted onto the Hollow Garden, and Myra stepped out first, fox tails fanning in wide arcs to test the space. She moved with the alertness of a wild animal entering new territory: not tense, but wary, every muscle tuned to pick up on what the rest of her body missed. Both tails moved independently, one tracing the tiled floor, the other mapping the air behind her. Her ears pricked at every sound: the humid murmur of leaves, the far-off hum of insects, the subtle click of a Mildred’s sandal on stone. Her eyes, unfocused and always a little too wide, swept the entrance not for light but for the auroras of emotion that defined her new way of seeing.

The Garden hit her with a wall of sensation. The ambient emotion here was heavy—comfort, peace, deep sadness, and the anesthetized patience of a place where most of its residents never left. The emotional weather landed on Myra’s face in the same way a change in barometric pressure prickled the skin: subtle, but impossible to ignore.

She stopped after two steps. The colors swirled, then stabilized. Myra’s breath caught—just a little hitch, the kind that would be missed by anyone who didn’t live their whole life tracking the edges of sensation.

Andy watched her without speaking. He wanted to reach for her, but he knew by now that you didn’t crowd Myra unless she signaled it was safe.

Laura stepped out of the elevator a moment later. Both bodies, moving in step, hair catching the sunlight from the glass ceiling above. Each wore the same careful, measured expression, and he noticed that both her sets of eyes were watching Myra, not him.

He waited for a beat, then moved closer. “Good morning,” he said, softly, as if the whole Garden had ears.

Both of Laura’s bodies turned toward him. The one on the left stepped forward first, and the right followed in perfect synchrony. She hugged him together, both sets of arms circling his waist at once, chins tucked against each of his shoulders. It was not awkward, nor did it feel staged. If anything, it felt natural—two bodies, one soul, holding him as if to anchor herself in the moment.

Andy held both of her, letting the warmth and the double pulse of Laura’s heart steady his own. He kissed each Laura on the forehead, then on the cheek. She smiled in tandem, and he felt the bond thrum between them, her anxiety and worry melting away in the comfort of his physical contact, much like his worries about Arabella’s words vanished in Laura’s embrace.

When Laura let go, Andy looked past her to Myra. She was standing just beyond the reach of the embrace, arms hanging loose, tails twitching slower now, but her head tilted as if listening for news from another room.

Andy stepped toward her. “You okay?” he asked. The words were insufficient, but he knew better than to crowd them with more.

Myra took her time. She closed her eyes, as if that would help her gather the answer, then said, “I don’t think I’ve ever felt anything like this.” Her voice was very quiet, but the silence of the Garden made it seem louder. “There’s so much… peace here. But also so much waiting. Like everyone’s in limbo, but they’re not unhappy about it.”

Andy nodded. “It’s a good place. Arabella did her best for them.”

Myra opened her eyes. “I believe it.” She turned her face toward him, but he could tell she was looking through him, seeing the aura that only she could see.

Laura, both bodies, stepped up beside Myra, and one of them reached for her hand. Myra’s fingers tightened around Laura’s without hesitation.

Andy took Myra’s other hand, careful not to surprise her. “How are you feeling?” he asked. “About… all of it.”

Myra’s lips pressed tight, and both her tails stilled. She looked down at their joined hands, then at Laura. “I’m still trying to figure out what I’m supposed to feel,” she said. “Laura told me the truth last afternoon. About Greg. About my… my mother. About the shack and the other women. I think I always knew there was more to it, but it’s different when you hear the names. When you know exactly where you came from.” She took a deep, steadying breath. “The part that keeps sticking in my head isn’t the Hotel, or Greg, or even my mother. It’s Warrenville.”

Andy frowned, confused. “Warrenville?”

Myra nodded, the motion so slight it was almost a tremor. “We grew up in the same town. We went to the same school. Laura was right there, and I never knew. She was beside me for years, and I never knew she was my sister.” She let out a shaky laugh, more disbelief than humor. “And all those things I said about her… the things that started it all… I was just a bitter, lonely kid taking it out on the only person who made me feel small. And she was my sister.”

Laura’s bodies didn’t move, but Andy felt it through the bond: raw empathy, a kind of silent apology, and a tight, brittle love that threatened to snap at the wrong word. He didn’t stop to wonder how.

Andy squeezed Myra’s hand. “She forgave you,” he said. “You know that.”

“I do,” Myra replied, and this time her voice was stronger. “I don’t doubt it. It’s just… I can’t get past it yet.”

They stood like that for a while, just the three of them, until the breeze from a distant vent made the bamboo leaves click together like applause.

Andy said, “Are you ready to meet her?”

Myra nodded, more certain this time. “Yes,” she said. “If I’ve learned anything from what happened to Laura, it’s that I don’t get to let my own discomfort postpone things that matter to other people.”

Andy smiled. “She’s been waiting a long time. Arabella said Marie’s afraid you hate her.”

At this, Myra’s tails went absolutely still. Not frozen, but so devoid of motion that it drew the eye.

Myra said, “That’s… not right. I… I was angry at her for a long time, yes, when I was a kid. I was scared, and I didn’t know why she didn’t want me. But… I understood long ago that she did what she did because she wanted me to have a better life. I just… never realized what she was really saving me from. But I want to tell her myself.” She straightened, squared her shoulders, and then her face broke in a small, crooked smile. “Will you take me to her?”

“Yeah,” Andy said. He let go of Myra’s hand only to slide his arm around her shoulders, the way he would have done with a friend who needed a little extra courage. Laura’s left body did the same, and the three of them set off together down the winding stone path.

In the near distance, Dinah stood outside the clinic entrance, her own arms crossed over her chest, watching with the kind of careful attention usually reserved for people about to jump off a cliff. As the group approached, Dinah pointed down a garden path, then stepped back, out of sight.

Andy led them toward the far corner, where a stone bench overlooked the pond and the slow, perpetual motion of the water. Myra’s gait was slow but never hesitant; she tracked the emotional currents as surely as if she could see the terrain. Laura kept pace, both bodies silent now, both sets of eyes forward.

They turned the last bend. Marie was already there, seated at the end of the bench, a book in her lap. She looked up as they approached—first at Andy, then at Laura, then at Myra.

The book slid from Marie’s lap and hit the stone with a soft, apologetic sound.

Marie and Myra faced each other, maybe ten feet apart, neither moving.

Myra’s tails had vanished behind her, compressed so tight they seemed to disappear into the small of her back. Marie’s hands hung limp at her sides. Her face crumpled, not all at once but in layers—the lips first, then the eyes, then the thin lines along her jaw. She brought her hands up, as if to cover her face, but stopped halfway. They shook.

Marie took a single step forward. Stopped. A sound escaped her, not a word but something softer, the beginning of a word that never formed.

She said, “Myra?” Her voice broke on it.

Myra’s breath hitched, loud enough for Andy to hear from where he stood. Her eyes brimmed, and her tails pressed so flat against her back that the tips curled upward, shivering. Then, without ceremony, Myra crossed the space and stopped just short of Marie, uncertain.

Marie reached for her, and the gesture was so instinctive, so unrehearsed, that it closed the last gap by itself. She folded Myra into her arms, and her hands gripped the fabric of Myra’s dress, knuckles whitening as if to keep her from ever leaving again. Myra’s own arms went around Marie’s waist, and she shook, once, a whole-body spasm that left her hanging on for dear life.

Please log in to view the image

Andy stood with Laura and watched. He had not expected to cry, but the sight of the two women—both so strong and so fragile, and both of them holding each other as if it was the only thing in the world—undid him. He looked at both of Laura, and saw that both faces were wet.

He did not look away.

The Garden let them have their moment. The water made its patient circuit; the air moved but did not hurry; the world outside shrank down to just this, a reunion measured not in time but in the density of the air around them.

After a while, Marie and Myra sat together on the bench. Marie’s hand rested on one of Myra’s fox tails, stroking it like she would a child’s hair. Myra’s head lay on Marie’s shoulder, and neither of them spoke.

Andy, arms around both Lauras, kept his distance. It was enough to be there, to know this was what the Garden was built for.

He felt Laura’s hands squeeze his, and looked down. Her eyes were fixed on the pair at the bench.


The emotional aftershock of that first embrace carried them through the walk to the bench, where Marie and Myra sat together, shoulder to shoulder, neither in a hurry to speak. Marie’s hand rested lightly on Myra’s nearest tail, stroking the plush fur as if reacquainting herself with a lost piece of her own life. They both breathed quietly, every inhalation and exhalation a negotiation with the new rules of existence. Andy and Laura kept a respectful distance, but not so far that they could not see everything.

For a while, they let the quiet do the work. Myra leaned into Marie with the boneless trust of a child, tails draping over the edge of the bench, eyes wet. Marie’s hands shook for a long time, but she held Myra as if, by touch alone, she could convince herself this was real and not just another in a long series of hallucinations.

Marie was the first to move. She reached up, careful, and brushed back a lock of Myra’s hair. Then she laughed—very soft, almost nervous—and said, “Your ears.” Her voice was tight, like she wasn’t sure it was okay to joke.

Myra smiled, a real one. “I know. They’re… a lot.”

Marie shook her head. “No. They suit you. You look better than I did at your age.” She tried to say it lightly, but the compliment landed heavy, a long-missing currency returned to circulation. “They must make everything sound different.”

“They do,” Myra said. She took her time with every word, like she was translating from another language. “I hear every little thing. But I don’t see anything. Well, not like you.” She gestured at her eyes, which never quite landed on Marie’s face, and then at the rest of the world. “I lost my vision, before I came here.”

Marie’s hand stilled on Myra’s tail. She looked at Myra’s eyes, and then looked away. “How?” she asked, quietly, a tremor in her voice.

Myra flexed her hands in her lap. “Long story. Stress, overwork, vascular thing that hit both eyes at the same time. It’s permanent. Or it would be, but here, I have this.” She swept a hand in a small arc, as if inviting the world in. “I see emotions. Not just moods, but everything people feel. I can see you right now, like your face is lit by your emotions, mine, Andy’s, Laura’s.” She smiled again. “It’s better, in some ways. Harder in others.”

Marie nodded, her own voice steadying. “You always felt things harder than anyone else I knew. I thought you’d outgrow it, but I’m happy you didn’t.” She laughed again, and then caught herself. “What do you see, now?”

Myra’s smile faded, but she answered honestly. “You’re afraid I’ll vanish if you look away. You’re also angry—at yourself, not me. And you love me, more than anything.” She hesitated. “And you are angry at my father, because we should never have been apart.”

Marie went very quiet, eyes searching Myra’s face for something that wasn’t there. She let her hand fall to her lap, fingers lacing together. “You always were smart,” she said.

“Not always,” Myra replied. “I got good at hiding it when I was small. It made things easier.”

They sat a while longer, then Marie said, “Do you remember anything from before?”

Myra nodded. “I remember the shack, mostly. The way it always smelled like laundry and something sweet. There were other women, but I don’t remember their names. There was a river behind the house, and sometimes you’d let me play outside as long as I could see the back door.”

Marie’s lips twisted. “I was always terrified you’d get lost, or that the wrong person would see you. He made us stay inside, but I wanted you to be a real kid, not just…” She trailed off, then started again. “The other women—Sandra, Colleen, Nancy, Renee—they all looked after you, too. You called them aunties, sometimes, but you didn’t like it.”

“I didn’t like sharing you,” Myra admitted. “It felt like you were everyone’s mother, not just mine.”

Marie blinked, startled by the honesty, then put an arm around Myra’s shoulders and squeezed. “You were always mine,” she said. “I just couldn’t say it then.”

Myra inhaled, deep, and let it out slow. “Why did you give me up?” she asked, as if she already knew but needed the words anyway.

Marie’s hand stayed tight on her shoulder. “I thought I was protecting you. Greg would never let us leave, but if I made it look like you’d wandered off, or been taken, he’d blame the others. Not me. I thought maybe someone good would find you, someone who could love you the way I couldn’t.” She shook her head. “It’s stupid now, but it made sense when I was there. The Garden, and the Hotel, and everything that happened after… it showed me how wrong I was.”

Myra said nothing for a long moment. Then: “It wasn’t wrong. It saved me. You did what you had to do.”

Marie swallowed, then looked away. “It hurt. Every day. I tried to follow you, once, but Greg caught me. After that, I stopped trying.”

Myra reached over and found Marie’s hand, squeezing it hard. “You don’t have to apologize. I always believed you did it because you loved me, even when I was too angry to admit it.”

Marie’s eyes were wet, but she blinked the tears away before they could fall. “You’re so much like me,” she said. “I always hoped I’d get to see you again, but I stopped believing it a long time ago.” She sniffed, then turned to face Myra head-on. “Are you happy now?”

The question landed with surprising ****. Myra considered it, then said, “I think I am. For the first time. I have friends. I have…” She gestured to the bench, to the Garden, to Andy and Laura in the distance. “I have people who know me, and they love me, and they still want me around. I never expected that.”

Marie let the silence go on, then said, “I want you to know: I’m sorry I wasn’t stronger. You were a child. I was too.”

Myra smiled, but it was smaller this time. “That’s not the part that needs forgiving.”

Marie’s head cocked. “What do you mean?”

Myra sat up straighter, and her tails stiffened behind her. “There’s something you’ll hear, eventually. About what I did—what happened with Laura, and Andy, and Chloe. I want you to hear it from me first.”

Marie’s hands closed tighter, knuckles whitening. “You can tell me anything. I’m listening.”

Myra inhaled, braced herself, and met her mother’s gaze squarely for the first time.

In the shade of the bench, with the sound of the river somewhere behind the Garden wall and the weight of a thousand afternoons pressing down, she prepared to say the hardest thing she had ever said.


Myra did not start right away. She sat with her hands folded in her lap, thumbs worrying a groove into the skin, tails wrapped close to her thighs. Marie, hands locked tight around Myra’s, waited with the patience of someone who understood that sometimes, the act of speaking was an injury in itself.

“My earliest memories are from the shack,” Myra said. Her voice was measured, as if reading a diagnosis off a chart. “It was cold in winter, hot in summer. I was sick a lot. I don’t remember much of you from that time. Just your hands, mostly.” She flexed her own fingers, as if conjuring the memory. “You used to braid my hair. Even when it was dirty or tangled.”

Marie’s face went soft, mouth twitching at the edge of a smile. “You hated sitting still. You’d fidget until I let you run off again.”

Myra nodded. “I was always running. I was so afraid of getting left behind.” She paused. “And then one day, I was.”

Marie inhaled, slow, then let it out in a thin stream. “Tell me what happened after,” Marie said, her voice careful, not wanting to shatter what they’d just rebuilt. “After I… after the day I let go of you.”

Myra nodded, as if she had been waiting for this question since forever. She started slow. “They put me in a foster home, first,” she said. “It was only for a few weeks—nobody told me what was going on, but I figured it out. The next house was worse, so I ran away. They found me and sent me to another. Then another. It was like nobody wanted to keep me for long, but nobody wanted to admit it either. I learned not to get attached, after a while.”

Marie flinched, but didn’t look away.

Myra continued: “The Calders were the last. They were older, and they already had a real daughter, but they treated me better than anyone else. They made me go to school, even though I’d missed a lot. They tried to make me part of their family.” She paused, remembering. “It was hard, at first. I didn’t know how to be in a family. But they were patient. Even when I made it hard.”

Marie’s voice shook. “Were you happy, with them?”

Myra looked at her hands, then up at the distant glass ceiling. “Sometimes. It got easier, but there was always this feeling—like I didn’t belong, or like I was borrowing someone else’s life. I tried not to show it, but it leaked out. The anger, the sadness.” She gestured at her chest, as if it still lived there. “I think that’s why I started lying.”

Marie frowned, confused. “Lying about what?”

Myra’s jaw tightened. “About everything that mattered to anyone.” She drew a breath, and the words seemed to physically hurt her. “I figured it was a way to hurt others, and maybe if I did that, I’d hurt less myself. I… I became a bully, because it was easier than to admit I was hurting so much.” She took a deep breath. “In middle school, when I was thirteen, I knew Laura and Andy. I didn’t care for him, but I hated her. And then one day, I learned that a girl called Chloe had kissed Andy. It hadn’t been intentional, and we all knew he belonged to Laura, but… eventually, I told people that Andy and Chloe had kissed, that Andy made fun of Laura behind her back. I wanted to make her—make Laura—feel as lost as I did. I thought it would be harmless, but it wasn’t. It was poison. It ate away at her, and I didn’t know.”

Marie absorbed this, her own face awash with regret. “You were just a child.”

“I was a child who knew how to break things,” Myra replied, voice steady. “I did it on purpose. I wanted to be the one who got to decide who belonged. I wanted someone else to hurt, so perhaps I would hurt less. But I never thought it would get so bad. And then, the day after I lied… that’s the day she died.”

The confession was not theatrical. It landed in the air between them, as matter-of-fact as a diagnosis.

Marie reached out, hesitated, then rested her palm against Myra’s cheek. “You didn’t make her die.”

Myra shook her head. “No. But I made sure she was alone when it happened. I made sure she had nobody left. Not even Andy. I made it so she couldn’t trust him.” She let the admission settle, then looked at her mother, her eyes wet. Her voice broke. “And she was my sister. Even though I didn’t know, not until yesterday.”

The word “sister” seemed to shock Marie as much as the confession itself. She blinked, and then something in her posture changed—she reached out, took Myra’s hand, her own eyes glimmering. “It… it’s my fault, isn’t it? If I had known you would hurt so much—” she started, but Myra cut her off.

“It’s not your fault,” Myra said. “You did what you had to. If you hadn’t let go of me, I would have been trapped there forever, just like you.” She pressed her mother’s hand, hard. “You saved me. You gave me a chance.”

Marie’s breath stuttered, but she didn’t cry. She just closed her eyes for a moment, then opened them again, as if daring the world to do its worst. “I never stopped looking for you,” she said. “Even when it was hopeless. Even when I knew Greg would never let me find you.”

Myra’s ears flicked. “I believe you,” she said. Then, softly, in a voice so small Andy and Laura had difficulties hearing it, she said, “There’s nothing to forgive, Mom.”

Marie went very still. It was the first time Myra had used the word, and both of them seemed to know it. Andy, watching from the path, saw Marie close her eyes for just a second, as if she needed to put it somewhere safe before she could continue. She let out a sound that was not quite a laugh and not quite a sob. She took Myra’s hands in hers and squeezed them until the bones pressed together. “You grew up to be so strong,” she said.

Myra smiled, then shook her head. “Not strong,” she corrected, “just stubborn. When I decided I wanted to help people, I went all in. I studied until I was the best. I thought if I could fix enough bodies, I could fix the thing inside me. But it doesn’t work like that.”

Marie ran her thumb over Myra’s knuckles, as if memorizing every ridge and groove. “I wish you could have been happy,” she said.

Myra shrugged. “I am. Now. For the first time.” She glanced over at Laura, who was still watching, silent and solemn. “Because I finally understand what happened. Because I finally got to meet you.”

Marie looked down, hands pressed flat on her knees. “You went through so much,” she said, her voice tight. “And all I ever wanted was to keep you safe.”

Myra leaned in. “You did, Mom. You did the best you could.” She let the word “Mom” sit for a second, as if tasting it for the first time. “Even when you couldn’t be there.”

Marie nodded, but didn’t trust herself to speak.

Myra softened, her whole posture relaxing. “I didn’t tell you the hard parts because I wanted to hurt you. I told you because you asked, and because I don’t want to lie to people I love.” The word “love” arrived quietly, but it carried more **** than anything Myra had said all day.

Marie froze, both hands closing over Myra’s, her face a study in awe and grief and something like hope. She stared at her daughter, really stared, as if searching for the baby she remembered in the face of the woman in front of her.

Then, at last, she let the tears fall, and she said: “I love you, Myra. I have loved you every day since the day you were born, and I am sorry it took this long for you to hear it.”

Myra didn’t answer right away. She just held Marie’s hands and let the truth of it sink in. When she did speak, her voice was small but unbreakable. “I love you too, Mom.”

This time, the hug was mutual, neither **** nor fragile. Marie wrapped her arms around Myra’s shoulders, holding her with the warmth of a mother who had spent half her life dreaming of this moment. Myra, for her part, did not shake or shrink away. She simply held on, as if this was the one thing she’d been missing all her life.

Andy watched the reunion in silence, one arm looped around both of Laura’s waists. He saw the tears on Laura’s face, the mirrored pain and relief that only someone who’d been doubled could possibly understand. Both Lauras stood a little closer together, and Andy felt the thrum of their bond—a cord that hummed with joy and sadness and the certainty that, in another world, they could have had this too.

After a while, Andy spoke, voice soft but insistent. “There’s somewhere else we need to be today. But we can come back after, if you want.”

Marie looked at her daughter, eyes filled with tears, and whispered, “We should go with them. You should meet your aunt.”

Myra nodded, her head against Marie’s shoulder. “I’d like that,” she said.

Marie wiped her eyes, kissed Myra on the forehead, and then stood, taking her daughter’s hand in hers as they walked back toward Andy and Laura. They walked together, Myra and Marie side by side, Andy and Laura a step behind, the four of them moving as a unit through the sun-warmed maze of the Garden.

No one rushed. No one needed to.

For the first time, Myra did not walk as if she was searching for something just out of reach. She held her mother’s hand, tails swaying gently behind her, the weight of years lifting with every step.

Andy looked at Laura, who looked at him, two sets of blue eyes meeting his own. She smiled, both bodies, the kind of smile that was made of everything they’d lost and everything they’d found. Andy squeezed her hand.

They walked together through the interior of the Garden, the path curving around a shallow pond and under a stand of cypress. At this hour the Garden was quieter, the staff mostly indoors, the only movement a pair of women drifting, hand in hand, under the poplars near the far edge. The four of them walked in a line—Marie and Myra side by side, Andy and Laura a few paces ahead, Laura’s two bodies walking in the usual perfect sync.

They were halfway to the cottage when Andy caught up to Myra, falling into step beside her.

“Do you want to know what to expect?” he asked, quietly. “With Sarah.”

Myra nodded, but kept her face forward.

Andy spoke low, as if the wind might carry the words away. “She’ll be in her chair by the window. She rocks, always the same motion. She doesn’t talk, except for a phrase she repeats. She doesn’t look up when you come in. Laura visited twice, I was here once, and she didn’t seem to know we were there, but… I thought I saw something, last time. Like maybe she was trying to come back.”

Myra chewed on this, then said, “Do you think she’s still in there?”

Andy considered. “I think so. Or part of her, at least. Marie thinks so too.” He hesitated. “So does Laura.”

Myra gave a small, grateful smile, then asked, “If you were me, would you want to see her like that?”

Andy looked at Laura for help, but it was Marie who answered. “If you don’t go, you’ll regret it,” she said, softly. “But it will hurt, and you can’t fix her by being strong. You just have to be there. That’s all.”

Myra let the words settle, then squared her shoulders. “Okay,” she said. “I want to use my own sight. If I see something, I’ll tell you.”

Laura—both bodies—looked at her and nodded again. Then, with a deliberate motion, she merged the two into one: a single woman, arms at her sides, hair falling around her like a shield. She looked very small, and very young, for a moment.

Marie led the way, up the brick steps and to the door. She hesitated, looking at Andy and Myra as if to check they were ready, then opened the door and stood aside for the others.

The interior of the cottage was sunlight and stillness. Sarah sat in a rocker by the far window, her body bracketed by the gold of late morning. Her hands, folded in her lap, gripped the arms of the chair with the bone-white insistence of a person determined not to let go of anything ever again.

She rocked, slow and steady, the motion so constant it might have been powered by the planet’s own rotation. Her lips moved, but the voice was almost inaudible: “My baby girl, my baby girl, I’m sorry, sweet girl.”

Laura crossed the room, knees buckling under her as she dropped to the floor in front of the chair. She took both of Sarah’s hands in hers and held them, her head bowed.

“I’m here, Mom,” Laura said. “I came back, just like I promised. And I brought someone. Two someones, really.”

Sarah rocked, the phrase running on its own tape loop.

Myra paused on the threshold, then oriented herself toward Sarah, her ears pointed, tails tucked, eyes wide and unblinking. Andy saw the way her body went absolutely still, the way she seemed to vanish from the room without leaving.

He leaned in, careful, and said, “What do you see?”

Myra whispered, “Nothing. Almost nothing. It’s like an absence, or a silence. I’ve never seen anything like it.” Her fingers drummed on Marie’s arm, anxious. “But when Laura talks, there’s something. Like a flicker at the edge of the field. It doesn’t have a color or a shape, but it’s real. I don’t know if it’s just her emotions, or… or if there’s something more.”

Andy nodded, and logged it against what he remembered from last time: the tiny twich on Sarah’s cheek, the briefest change in the loop, the sense that something in the machinery of her mind was struggling to engage.

Laura, still kneeling, lifted one of Sarah’s hands to her face and kissed it. Then she spoke, voice low and shaking: “I found Myra, Mom. I found my sister. Marie’s daughter. And I brought Andy again. You remember Andy, Mom, don’t you? He never let me go, not even after the river.”

Andy felt the air in the room tighten, as if the cottage itself was waiting to see what would happen.

Laura went on, “We did it, Mom. We found each other. He’s the one who brought me back. I wish you could see us now, all the women here. I wish you could know how much I love you.”

Sarah’s hands twitched in Laura’s grip, but the phrase didn’t stop.

Marie, standing by the door, covered her mouth with her hand. Andy saw the tears start, and turned away so she could have her privacy.

Myra, after a moment, said, “May I try?”

Laura nodded, and released Sarah’s hands.

Myra crossed the room, moving with a deliberate, careful grace. She stopped at the edge of the rocker, knelt, and reached out for Sarah’s wrist, her own hands very gentle, and then looked up at Sarah’s face. “Hi, Aunt Sarah,” Myra said, the words small and trembling.

Sarah’s eyes tracked nothing, but her left hand curled tighter around the armrest.

Laura spoke again, this time with Andy’s help: “We’re here, Mom. All together.” Laura turned to Andy, and for a split second, he could see all thirteen years of Laura’s life—the real one—written on her face. In that moment she was just a daughter, helplessly pleading with her mother to come back.

He stepped forward, and took Sarah’s other hand. “It’s Andy,” he said, softly. “I’m here, too. I never stopped trying, not once. I’m sorry it took so long to bring her back, but I did. I found her. We’re together again.”

Sarah rocked, lips moving. The phrase was quieter now, as if it had lost some of its ****.

Marie crossed the room and put her arms around the back of the rocker, holding Sarah’s shoulders in a careful embrace. “We’re here, Sarah,” she said, over and over, voice breaking.

Myra leaned in, forehead nearly touching Sarah’s. “You have a family, Aunt Sarah. The other women, and my Mom, and me, and Laura, and Andy. You’re not alone. You’re safe. We’re not going anywhere.”

For a moment, nothing happened. The room held its breath.

The moment stretched, then broke with a tremor: Sarah’s hands, which had been limp in Laura’s grip, tightened for half a second. It was small, almost deniable, but Andy saw it; so did Laura, whose face flooded with wet, helpless hope.

“My baby girl, my baby girl, I’m sorry, sweet girl—” Sarah’s voice wobbled, the pattern catching, and then, for a single iteration, the script changed.

“My baby girl, my baby girl… I love you, my sweet girl.”

The old phrase snapped back in after, like a skip in a record. But it was enough.

Laura let out a sound that was not a word, not a cry, but the pain and joy of sixteen years’ waiting compressed into a single sob. She dropped her forehead to her mother’s lap and clung to Sarah’s knees, doubled over, shoulders shaking.

Marie’s hands, clamped on the back of the rocking chair, began to tremble, and she made no move to hide her tears.

Myra whispered, “She’s still in there. I see it, Andy. It’s so faint, but it’s her—she felt it, she heard Laura, and she wanted to say it back.”

Andy, suddenly blinking hard, squeezed Myra’s shoulder. “I know,” he said. “I saw it, too.”

Laura didn’t let go of her mother’s hands. She pressed them to her cheeks, and through the tears, she started to laugh—a wild, unsteady sound, but one that made Andy’s chest tighten with hope.

Marie crossed to them, and knelt by Laura’s side. Myra followed, and for the first time, the whole Williams family—mothers, daughters, aunts and nieces—were together in a knot of hands and tears and the sound of a woman who was still, somehow, trying to come back.

Sarah continued to rock. The phrase returned to its old pattern, but every few cycles, the “I’m sorry” softened, lost ****, sometimes replaced by a longer pause, as if the machinery that ran her brain had to work harder to keep the tape loop running.

Myra reached out for Sarah’s hand, took it in hers. Her tails, which had been rigid with tension, finally relaxed, draping to the floor in loose, slow sweeps. “Aunt Sarah,” Myra said again, this time stronger. “I’m here. I promise I’ll come back, too.”

Sarah’s rocking slowed for three beats, then resumed.

Marie hugged Myra from behind, and for a long while, the only sounds in the cottage were the breathing, the chair’s slow creak, and Laura’s soft, hiccupped laughter dissolving into tears.

Andy watched, hands folded, and did not speak. There was nothing he could say that would not break the spell, so he just stood sentinel for them, witness to the first movement of a soul returning.

Laura eventually straightened. She wiped her face, then knelt before Sarah so she could meet her mother’s eyes. “I’ll come back, Mom,” she said. “Every day. I love you, and I’m not giving up. I’m not.”

Sarah did not look at her, but the next phrase was slower, as if her brain had to rewrite it on the fly: “My baby girl, my baby girl, I—” A pause, the gears grinding, then the old pattern snapped in. But the hesitation had been real, and everyone present heard it.

Marie, eyes wide, gasped and said, “She’s fighting, Laura. She’s fighting to reach you.”

Laura nodded, tears streaming. Andy let himself breathe, just once, before moving to the window. He looked out at the Garden, its impossible calm, its weightless air. It was only then that he realized his hands were shaking, too.

After a while, Myra turned to Andy, her eyes wet and clear. “You saw it, right?”

He smiled. “I did. You were right about her.”

They lingered, none of them wanting to be the first to leave, but eventually, Sarah’s looped phrase began to soften and slow, and Laura—exhausted—let go of her mother’s hands and stood.

“We’ll come back,” Laura promised, one hand on Myra’s shoulder, the other holding Marie’s. “I’ll come every day, Mom.”

Marie wiped her face, and looked at Andy and Laura with a gratitude so pure it made him want to look away. “She’ll come back to us,” Marie said, voice sure. “I know it now.”

Andy nodded. “Me too.”

Marie smiled, and for once, she looked younger.

When they left, Sarah’s phrase was so soft it was almost a whisper, but Andy was sure he heard the word “love” in there, every time.

They walked out into the Garden as a unit, arms linked, the spell of vacancy broken, if only for a little while.

In the slow light of the garden paths, Laura let go of Myra’s hand just long enough to wipe her own tears, then took it again, fiercely. Andy put his arms around both of them, holding tight, until Laura let herself split in two again. Then he held both of her, but she held Myra’s hand and Myra responded fiercely, both of them weeping openly, unashamedly.

The Garden, for all its waiting and all its stillness, was a place for healing, after all.


They were halfway through the Garden, the cypress shade cool after the warmth of the cottage, when Andy fell into step beside Myra and said her name, low enough that only she would hear. Myra turned her face toward him. “There's something else,” he said. “Before we get to Sandra.” He felt Laura's eyes on him from a few paces back and knew she had already decided this was his to say. “Sandra had a daughter. She was placed for adoption, like you were. Unlike you, this happened when she was a baby, so she never knew her mother.” He let that settle, then said, “It’s Riley.” Myra's tails went completely still. Andy said, “She's your half-sister, too. Yours and Laura's both. She doesn't know yet. Sandra… she doesn’t want Riley to see her as she is.” For a moment, the only sound was their footsteps on the path and the distant murmur of the Garden's water. Then Myra exhaled, slow and long, and said nothing. She reached back for Laura's hand without looking, and Laura gave it to her, and the three of them walked the rest of the way to Sandra in silence.

Sandra was exactly where Marie said she’d be: sprawled on the sun-warmed grass near the south sycamore, her back half-arched to expose her belly to the light, face angled toward the sky. From a distance she looked peaceful, a wild animal who’d found a moment of safety, but as they approached the careful stillness in her limbs read as vigilance, not rest. Her tail—heavy, lush, and entirely canine—rested limp on the ground, the tip twitching once every few seconds in time with her breath.

She heard them coming before they were in view, and by the time Andy, Marie, Laura, and Myra stepped out of the cypress shade, she was sitting up, front legs braced straight, ears pricked forward. She scanned the group with a long, dispassionate look, gaze landing on Andy first (a slow blink of calculation), then on Laura (a tightening around her eyes, but no surprise), then on Marie (a dip of the chin, the closest thing to respect Sandra ever offered), and finally on Myra.

The dog-girl’s nose twitched twice, registering the unfamiliar, but it was the sight of the fox tails and the oversize, mobile ears that made her tilt her head. She took in Myra’s posture, the nervous set of her hands, the way her tails bunched at her back, and logged her instantly as a contestant, without being told. Marie stopped a safe distance away. Andy kept pace at her right, with Laura and Myra just behind. For a moment, neither group moved closer.

Andy waited until the silence stretched, then nodded at Sandra. “Good morning,” he said, tone as neutral as possible.

Sandra’s eyes stayed on Myra, but she replied to Andy: “She’s new.” The voice was gravelly and flat, but not unfriendly.

“She isn’t,” Andy said. “This is Myra. She’s Marie’s daughter. Also part of my harem, and now knows about Riley.” He kept it brief, not wanting to make an introduction sound like a threat.

Sandra's gaze moved from Andy back to Myra, slower this time. Her ears shifted, not forward but sideways — the uncertain position. She looked at Marie, then at Myra, then at Marie again. Something shifted in her eyes, not the flat calculation of before but something older, recognition arriving through a different door. Her tail moved once, low and involuntary, and stopped. She said nothing for a moment, then said, "Myra." Not a question. Just the name, placed carefully, as if testing whether it still fit.

Myra said, “I’m sorry, Aunt Sandra, I don't remember you. But I think I should.”

Sandra was quiet for a long moment. Her tail moved once, dragging across the grass, and stopped. “You were small,” she said. “You used to scream when anyone except your Mom tried to braid your hair.” Her voice was very flat, the way voices go flat when the only alternative is breaking. “You called me Auntie Sandy.”

Myra's hands closed at her sides. Her tails pressed flat. “Auntie Sandy. I'm sorry I don't remember more,” she said.

Sandra shook her head, one sharp motion. “Don't apologize. You were very little.” She looked at Andy, then at Marie, then back at Myra. “Does she know about Riley?”

“She does,” Andy said. “That's part of why we're here.”

Sandra nodded, accepting this. “You came to tell me something.”

Laura, both voices, spoke first. “We’re not here to push you, or to override what you want. We just want to be clear. Myra knows the truth now—about her mother, about the show, about you. The only one who doesn’t know yet is Riley.” The words landed one by one, deliberate as chess moves. “We want to tell her. She has the right. It’s not fair to her, to keep this from her. She has lost so much. And we want to tell her about you, if she asks, but not **** her on you. Unless you want it, it will not happen.”

Sandra listened, ears flat, and said nothing for a long moment. She looked at Marie, then at Myra. “Would she want to meet me?”

Myra shook her head, once. “I don't know. But it's better to know the truth than to spend your whole life filling in the silence with something worse.”

Sandra’s jaw flexed, as if working out how to answer without giving too much away. “Riley’s strong. She’ll want to see for herself. Even if you tell her not to.”

Andy said, “She’ll want to come to the Garden. Maybe not immediately. But she will.”

Sandra looked down at her forelegs, at the place where her hands would have been, if she still had them. “I’m not ready for her to see me like this,” she said, voice lower, nearly human. “I don’t want her to think this is all I am.”

None of them rushed to fill the silence. It was Myra who finally said, “She doesn’t need to see you right away. I never saw my own mother until today, and it was still better knowing she was out there, even if I couldn’t have her. Sometimes that’s enough.”

Sandra nodded, not looking up. “Is that all you wanted?”

Marie, for the first time, spoke. “We want you to be part of it, if you want to be. But if you don’t, that’s fine too.”

Sandra’s tail made a slow arc, then settled. She looked at Andy. “Is there a way to be there, without… being there?”

Andy thought, then said, “A privacy screen. You could be behind it, talk to her, but not be seen.”

Sandra considered this, eyes narrowed. “She’ll know it’s me.”

“She will,” Andy agreed. “But you’ll have the choice.”

Laura, both bodies, stepped forward just a little. “You don’t have to decide now. We’ll come back tomorrow. Or the next day. Whenever you want.” Sandra lay down again, folding her forelegs and resting her head on them. Her ears swiveled toward Marie, as if waiting for one last word. When none came, she closed her eyes and let the sun take her.

Andy, Marie, Laura, and Myra lingered for a second, then turned and made their way back toward the elevator, each moving at their own pace. They didn’t speak, not right away. The conversation had done what it was supposed to do. When they reached the shade, Myra stopped and looked back. Sandra had lain back down in the grass, facing away from them, ears no longer rigid. Her tail lay still. Marie touched Myra’s shoulder. “You did well,” she said.

Myra smiled, ears flicking at the compliment. “She’ll come around. Just needs time.”

They walked on, the four of them in a loose cluster, the air in the Garden a little lighter than before. They left Sandra in the sun, as she wanted, and didn’t look back.


The walk back from the dog-girl’s patch of sun was slow, not because of injury or exhaustion, but because none of them wanted to break the spell of the day just yet. For the first few steps, they moved in a loose group: Andy at the front, scanning for staff or wandering guests; Laura just behind him, sometimes split, sometimes merged, her movements as quietly fluid as always; and Myra, walking shoulder to shoulder with Marie, neither saying much, but every few paces catching each other’s gaze as if reacquainting themselves with the idea of family.

It was Myra who eventually reached over, brushed the back of Marie’s hand with her own, and said, “Can we hang back? I want to walk with you.” Her voice was soft, the edges of it fuzzy with recent crying, but she did not sound uncertain.

Marie said, “Of course,” and matched Myra’s pace without further comment. The two fell a few strides behind Andy and Laura, who had by then started their own conversation—a low, ongoing hum that never quite carried back to the trailing pair.

Andy did not listen in, but he watched the way Myra’s gait synced to Marie’s, the way their bodies angled in together even as they moved along the curved path. The two women looked so much alike, next to each other. Myra’s fox tails—always a dead giveaway for her mood—were unhurried now, drifting in lazy tandem, sometimes brushing Marie’s thigh, sometimes trailing behind like oversized shadows. The ease in Myra’s steps, the lack of flinch or hesitation, made Andy relax in turn. It was a truce, or maybe a treaty, and if it was built on the foundation of what they’d just lived through, it felt sturdy enough to last.

The four reached the elevator platform together. The doors were closed, the chamber waiting with the quiet patience of a good butler. Myra and Marie stopped a pace back, their conversation suspended but not yet ended.

Andy glanced over his shoulder, ready to ask if they were coming, but found them standing with hands linked, facing each other and not looking at anything else. Laura drifted to his side, her eyes tracking the moment but not intruding.

It was Myra who broke the silence. She turned to Marie, lifted her chin, and said, “I’ll be back. Every day if they let me. I want you to come upstairs, too. Meet the others. They… they’re important to me, Mom.”

Marie smiled, “I’ll come up tomorrow, after Laura visits Sarah,” and the words hit the air not as a promise, but as a statement of cosmic fact.

They stood like that for a long moment—two women who should have been strangers, bound now by something stronger than story or memory. Around them, the Garden rippled with ambient emotion, the patterns of peace and uncertainty and raw new hope shifting with every breath.

Laura moved first. She stepped toward Marie, both bodies in perfect sync, and wrapped her arms around her in a hug that could have looked ridiculous, but didn’t. It was not a performance, nor a competition for space, but a doubling of intent: one set of arms at Marie’s shoulders, the other at her waist, all of it meant to anchor Marie in this world as thoroughly as possible. Marie did not flinch, nor did she seem surprised. She accepted it, and for a second let her own hands rest on each Laura’s back, one after the other.

Myra did not join the embrace. Instead, she put out her hand, the gesture awkward but unmistakably sincere. Marie took it, their fingers closing tight for a single beat before both let go. The lack of a hug was not a slight—it was Myra’s way of making the moment last a little longer, and Marie seemed to understand.

Andy, uncharacteristically formal, shook Marie’s hand. He said, “Thank you.” The words did not feel like enough, but Marie met his eyes and nodded, as if acknowledging that sometimes, gratitude had to be handled in small, manageable doses.

The elevator doors opened before anyone pressed the button. It must have been waiting there, summoned by the weight of the moment as much as by any schedule. Andy stepped in first, but didn’t press for the others to follow; he stood aside, giving space for Myra and Marie to approach at their own pace.

Myra hesitated on the threshold, tails swishing in thoughtful arcs. She turned to Marie, squared her shoulders, and said, in a voice that was all declaration and no question, “I’m coming back. Every day, if I can.”

Marie looked at her, face drawn but steady. “I’m not going anywhere,” she replied, and there was no trace of doubt. The words did not ricochet between them; they landed and took root.

The elevator chimed softly. Andy, Myra, and both Lauras stepped inside. Myra positioned herself with her back to the far wall, tails wrapping the chrome rail in a spiral. Laura pressed the “Lobby” button.

As the doors began to close, Myra turned her head and fixed her mother with a long, searching look. Marie, framed in the shrinking aperture, returned the gaze. Neither spoke. The Garden, in that brief interval, seemed to hold its breath.

Just before the doors sealed, a voice called out: “Wait. I need Andy for a moment.”

It was Arabella, standing no more than six feet away, her presence somehow unnoticed until now. She wore a navy suit that made her look equal parts CEO and ghost, and her hair—perfect as ever—was pinned up with two silver needles that caught the sunlight and threw it into Andy’s eyes.

Andy turned. Laura did too. Myra’s ears went flat, then upright again; her tails stilled, bracing for news. Arabella gestured with a single, gentle flick of the hand: “Laura, Myra, go ahead. Andy, please stay.”

Laura caught Andy’s eyes, saw whatever he was about to ask, and nodded. “I’ll wait for you at the top,” she said. Her voice was calm, but both bodies watched Andy like sentinels. Myra didn’t argue or ask why—she only pressed her lips together and gave Andy a nod of solidarity, then turned to face the closing doors.

When the elevator vanished behind the steel panel, Arabella let the silence linger. Andy resisted the urge to check his watch, or to fill the gap with chatter. Marie, a few yards away, looked at Arabella and then at Andy, gave a single, brief look of concern—then turned and began the walk back to Sarah’s cottage, her stride even and unhurried.

Now there was no one left but Arabella and Andy, the two of them in the echoing greenhouse hush of the Hollow Garden.

Arabella waited a full ten seconds, as if timing the length of a chess clock, before she spoke. “I promised you a conversation,” she said, her voice quieter than he was used to from her, stripped of the Host register entirely. “I've been waiting for the right moment, and this is it. What happened on the bridge — the shot glass, the others before it. I think you already know it wasn't coincidence, and I think you deserve to understand what it means.”

Andy didn’t know what to say to that, so he waited.

What's next?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)