A Pleasant Surprise

Lily had a spare key to Jake’s house, his parents had given it to her two years ago so she could water their garden while they were away on a family trip. She wasn’t sure if they knew she still had it, but she was going to use it to her advantage today. Today, both of Jake’s parents had driven upstate to pick up his grandparents. Due to the length of the drive, they were going to stay the night up there before driving the four of them back to town for the holiday. Jake had the house to himself, and Lily intended to make full use of that. Unfortunately, Jake had other commitments, errands, car maintenance, gym, for most of the day and was due back in the early evening. She waited in the living room, a part of her nervous that his parents could come home early unannounced and catch her in her lingerie. It made the situation more thrilling.

Lily heard tires on asphalt and peaked out to see Jake’s car pulling up. She grinned wickedly and padded upstairs to the ‘game room’. Really it was just a second living room, complete with a couch and TV, but also including a pool table.

She sat on the couch, reaching her hands behind her back and unclasping her bra. She held it up seductively with her finger.

“Jaaaaake” she called tauntingly.

“Babe?!” Jake sounded pleasantly surprised.

“Come to the game room!”

The sound of eager footsteps marching up the stairs made Lily giggle. Jake walked through the doorway and his jaw dropped when he saw her. Lily’s jaw was the next to drop however as following behind Jake was his best friend David. Lily shrieked, dropping her bra and crossing her arms over her chest in attempt to cover up. Jake laughed walking up to her, a foreign twinkle in his eye, and sat beside Lily on the couch.

“What’s wrong babe?” Jake asked, something devious in his voice. “He’s already seen it all.”

Jake grabbed Lily’s wrists and pulled them to her sides, she gave no resistance. The only thing hotter than being exposed in front of these two men, was being forced to be exposed. David looked at her bare chest with a hungry gaze. Lily’s nose inhaled the scent of the two men. She had always loved the smell of Jake fresh from the gym, as weird as it may seem. David’s musk was no less gripping. The way the scents mingled in the air made her chest flutter.

“You look even better in person, Lily” David smiled. He was so casual about it, like he wasn’t staring at the naked breasts of his best friend’s girl. Like it was totally normal.

The compliment and his nonchalance made Lily ache.

The boys gave each other a look. Lily couldn’t quite make out what it meant but they were clearly communicating silently. David moved in and sat next to Lily on the couch. His weight shifting the cushions made the dreamlike scenario suddenly feel so real. Jake gently grabbed Lily’s ankles and pulled them over, causing her to spin on the couch and fall backwards into David’s lap.

The view from below was bewitching. She felt so submissive being manhandled so easily and looking up at David as he grinned down at her. She felt her heels loosen and Jake gently pulling them off. His finger tips ran along her foot and ankles, soft kisses trailing close behind. The attention drew silent moans from Lily.

“David’s gotten to see so much of you lately babe” Jake growled “why don’t you let him see what you feel like.”

Lily wondered if he had meant more than just touching. Not that it mattered anyway, she was melting already and primed to give herself over to the two friends. She lifted her arms back above her head, giving David silent permission. He didn’t hesitate. His hands found her breasts and squeezed and kneaded as if he was trying to memorize how they felt. His fingers traced lightly over her nipples and she exhaled through parted lips.

Jake watched from the end of the couch, loving how her body reacted under his friend’s hands. He watched her chest heave and pause as if David were dictating every breath she took. Her face turned a bright shade of pink, a sign Jake knew well. One that told him that Lily would soon be needing dick as much as she needed air to breathe, or water to drink.

Lily could feel David growing hard beneath his basketball shorts, his shaft pressing against her cheek through the fabric. The situation felt so erotic. Obviously she had done much more with others, but this is the first time another man was touching her with Jake in the same room. She knew that if this went on any longer she wouldn’t be able to resist yanking David’s shorts down and stuffing his cock down her throat.

Lily sat up straight, David’s hands falling away. She looked to Jake, her face asking a question that not even she knew. He only looked back at her with a devious smile and prideful heat in his eyes. Suddenly David’s hands were around her waist and she was pulled backwards with a slight yelp, being placed onto his lap. The power the two men were displaying over her made Lily quiver. Before she knew it, David’s hands were back on her breasts eliciting a breathy moan.

Lily turned her head to face her admirer, locking eyes with him. The heat in the room was building and becoming too much to bear, Lily’s lips seemed to be drawn into David’s— almost as if there were a magnetic force. She moaned as their lips met, David swallowed it whole as he began to map out her mouth with his tongue. His fingers were electric as they softly traced from her breasts, down her abdomen, and began to explore the waistband of her panties tentatively. Lily responded by leaning harder into the kiss and dragging her fingers into David’s soft hair. He understood what she was telling him with her body and his fingers slipped beneath the waistband lower and lower until…

“Holy shit, you’re so wet right now” David grinned.

Lily couldn’t speak, the sensation of his fingers dragging circles around her soaking clit was too much. Her chest swelled as she tried to breathe in the moment, looking at David through hooded eyes. Then she drew her eyes to Jake, who sat watching on the other side of the couch. Lily could tell by the look he was giving her that he was struggling to contain himself.

David’s lips found Lily’s neck, making her shudder.

“Oh fuck! Yes.” She moaned softly as David curled his fingers inside of her.

“Baby!” she whimpered to Jake “your friend— FUCK! Your friend is making me so fucking wet… he’s making me feel so good.”

“I want to taste how wet you are from being such a slut!” Jake growled.

David happily relinquished Lily, who obediently sat down in her previous seat. Jake dropped to his knees in front of her and pulled her panties off. There was no soft kisses up her leg, no teasing touches, only primal lust. He dove straight in, moaning as his tongue landed upon her wet slit. The vibration rattled Lily to the core and she began moaning uncontrollably as Jake went to work on her clit. He knew exactly how to pull her along with his tongue, he had learned her well over the years. He could easily make her cum within minutes if he wanted, but instead he teased her relentlessly. He would bring her to the edge, making her hips rock into his face, and just before the fireworks he would change pace or technique.

Lily was a puddle at this point. Every nerve was screaming for release, someway somehow. She managed to open her eyes just a little bit and saw that David had undressed and was now sitting on his end of the couch stroking himself. The sight of him jerking off to her while only a few feet away was nearly enough to make her burst right then and there. She admired his cock, slightly longer than average and thick.

“Oh fuck” the words came from deep in her chest. Jake lifted his gaze briefly, following Lily’s own and seeing that she was staring straight at David’s throbbing member.

“Tell me what you want baby” David whispered loudly into her pussy.

“I want to suck your friend’s dick” her voice was trembling from the dangerous pressure coiled inside of her “I want him to fuck my face… I want him to do it while you fuck me! HOLY SHIT” she threw her head back at the image of her own creation.

“You want to be a good little slut for us?” Jake breathed.

“Yes baby! I want to be your slut! I want you two to use me! Use me however you want!”

She had more to say but she was quickly interrupted by David’s dick pressing between her lips. She opened her eyes in surprise, seeing that he had moved to behind the couch. Understanding her place, she began enthusiastically moving her lips and tongue up and down along her shaft. It wasn’t long before she also felt Jake stretching her as he pushed himself inside of her. There was no need for the pleasantries of a light and sensual warm up, Lily was already soaking and her entire body was aching— allowing Jake and every inch of his large cock to fill her completely. She moaned around David, who responded to the sensation by gripping Lily’s hair on either side of her head and pulling her forcefully down on himself. He began thrusting with a needful gusto, giving Lily the facefucking she so desired. Jake meanwhile pounding in and out of her like her sole purpose was to take him.

And that is exactly how she felt in that moment. All other thoughts washed away as the two men used her body for their pleasure. Lily relished in the sensation of being filled by two cocks, a brand new and intensely potent experience. She allowed herself to submit to them— to be their fucktoy.

Jake had worked Lily to the absolute limit though, the feeling of his cock dragging along her walls and forcing itself deep back inside was mixing wonderfully with the filthy reality of Jake’s best friend making her gag around his cock. Her body began to rock and spasm, David easing his grip and allowing himself to pop out of her mouth as she gasped for air. Her body could not take in any air though, it was as though every function had been put on hold, stepping back while pleasure went on a rampage through every bone and muscle. She felt the pressure inflate and explode, drawing an ear shattering moan of satisfaction. Jake was soon drenched in her fluids as she gushed out in release. The bright lights of the game room were dimming, the two men blurring. Lily was still quaking and shuddering— her world slowly went dark.