Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 3 by ManRayMansker ManRayMansker

Which would you choose?

A “Little” too Eager

I stared at the sleek metal chastity cage dangling from Mia’s fingers. My heart pounded so hard it felt like it might burst out of my chest. The whole room watched me in silence. Jake smirked. Sarah looked eager. The other girls leaned in, hungry for whatever came next.

The part of me that had secretly fantasized about this for years won out.“Okay,” I said, my voice shaky. “I accept. I will do it.”

Mia’s smile turned absolutely wicked. “Good choice, little one. Strip. Everything off from the waist down. Let us see what we are locking up.”I stood on trembling legs and pushed my jeans and boxers down. My cock flopped out, soft and small, barely three inches even when I was a little excited from all the attention. The room stayed quiet for a second, then a few giggles broke out.Mia stepped forward and knelt right in front of me. She cupped my small package in her palm, lifting my soft dick and balls like she was weighing them. “Oh my god. Look at this cute little thing. It is tiny.”

She tried the cage on me. The ring slid easily behind my balls. My soft cock slipped into the short tube with room to spare. Mia clicked the padlock shut with a loud, final click. The metal cage looked huge on me. My entire dick and balls were completely swallowed by it, the head barely visible at the end of the tube. It looked pathetic.Mia burst out laughing. “Holy shit. It actually looks big on you because your dick is so small. This is perfect.”

She stood up and called the other guys over. “Come on boys. Drop your pants. We are doing a proper comparison.”Jake went first. He pulled out his cock, already half-hard. It grew to a solid five and a half inches, thick and veiny. Next to my locked microdick, it looked enormous. Mia held Jake’s hard cock right beside my caged one. The difference was humiliating.

“Jake’s dick is literally twice the size of your whole package,” Mia announced loudly. “Even soft, his is bigger than your caged shrimp.”Sarah dropped to her knees and sucked Jake’s cock eagerly, moaning loudly while staring at my tiny locked dick. “Mmm, so much nicer than that little thing.”

Tyler went next. His cock was a little bigger, around six inches, average but looking massive compared to my shrunken caged nub. The girls took turns comparing, slapping their cocks against my cage, laughing every time my tiny locked dick twitched helplessly inside the metal.“Look at it trying to get hard,” Lena teased. “It is pressing against the bars like a desperate little worm. Pathetic.”Emma grabbed my cage and shook it. “This is the smallest dick in the room by far. The other guys are all average, but next to your microdick they look like porn stars.”

The humiliation burned hot in my face, but my caged cock strained painfully against the metal, leaking precum that dripped onto the floor. They all noticed.Mia stood up and addressed the group. “Since our little locked boy has the smallest dick here, he does not get to fuck anyone tonight. He gets to watch. Everyone else, enjoy yourselves. Show him what real cocks can do.”

The night turned into an all-out orgy centered around my denial.Sarah pushed Jake onto the couch and straddled him. She sank down on his five-and-a-half-inch cock with a loud moan. “Fuck, you feel so good. So much thicker than that tiny caged nub.” She rode him hard, her tits bouncing, making eye contact with me the whole time. “You wish this was you, don’t you? Too bad your little shrimp dick is locked away.”

I sat on the chair across from them, naked from the waist down, my tiny caged cock throbbing uselessly. Every time Sarah moaned, my dick tried to harden and failed, the metal biting into me.Tyler took Lena from behind on the coffee table. His six-inch cock slammed into her wet pussy with loud, wet slapping sounds. “Hear that?” he grunted.

“That is what a real cock sounds like.” Lena screamed in pleasure, cumming hard around him while glancing over at my pathetic locked dick and laughing.Mia saved herself for last. She crawled over to me first, dangling the key between her breasts. “You are never getting out of this tonight, tiny. Maybe not ever if you keep leaking like a desperate little bitch.”

She kissed me mockingly, then turned to Jake. “Fuck me while he watches.”Mia got on all fours right in front of me. Jake mounted her and drove his cock deep inside her in one thrust. Mia moaned loudly, pushing back against him. “Yes! Fill me up. Your cock reaches places that little caged dick never could.”Jake fucked her harder, his balls slapping her clit. Mia looked straight at me. “See how wet I am for a real dick? Your tiny shrimp could never satisfy me. Look at it leaking in its cage. So fucking pathetic.”

I could not look away. My caged microdick strained painfully, the bars digging in as I leaked a steady stream of precum. The more they humiliated me, the harder it tried to grow, and the more trapped it became.One by one the girls took turns riding and getting fucked by the other guys while teasing me relentlessly.

“Look at his little dick trying so hard,” Emma giggled while bouncing on Tyler. “It is literally the smallest I have ever seen. Adorable.”

Sarah came over after Jake filled her with cum. She spread her legs in front of me and showed me the creampie dripping from her pussy. “This is what a proper fucking looks like. Want to clean it up with your tongue, little locked boy?”I nodded desperately. She grabbed my hair and pulled my face into her cum-filled pussy while Mia turned up the verbal humiliation.

“Eat another man’s cum while your microdick stays locked. This is all you are good for now.”The night continued like that for hours. I stayed locked in the too-big cage, my tiny dick and balls on full display as the smallest in the room. The girls took load after load from the average cocks that looked huge next to mine. They made me watch every thrust, every moan, every creampie.

By the end I was a desperate, leaking, humiliated mess. My cage was covered in my own precum, my balls aching, and my pride completely destroyed in the best possible way.Mia finally knelt in front of me, tapping the cage with her fingernail. “Welcome to your new reality, tiny. How does it feel knowing you have the smallest dick in the entire group?”

I could only moan in humiliated arousal.

What's next?

Comments

      Want to support CHYOA?
      Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)