Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 12 by Mrjakobs Mrjakobs

What's next?

3.5 Secrets

David held the phone in his free hand as he plowed into Sage’s mouth. He captured the best moments of the whole ordeal, shoving his whole member into Sage’s throat, then he cut the video and threw the phone to the side. Sage saw him do it, and immediately pushed against his thighs. David disregarded it, and happily thrust into a few more times before finishing inside Sage’s throat without warning. He had already cum twice and felt perfectly comfortable taking this moment for himself. He pressed his ballsack against her puffy lips and pumped his load into her as he let out a satisfied sigh. Sage, feeling the sensation of hot cum pouring into her, relented, and began to swallow David’s load with deep gulps.

“Good girl…” David moaned, using both his hands to push himself into Sage’s mouth as deeply as possible, “That’s right, fucking swallow it, just like last time… Oh fuck…”

Sage could feel him going soft inside her mouth, but continued to suck obediently. In truth, it was turning her on more than she ever thought possible. To be used by this disgusting man was just as good as she remembered. She let David take his time, allowing him to finish before slowly pulling out his half-erect cock from her mouth. Sage sucked on him hard until every last inch of his shaft had been removed.

“Fuck Sage you are such a slut,” David said, placing his hand under Sage’s chin and forcing her to look up at him.

“I wanted you to film the whole thing, David,” Sage said shortly.

“Never said that when we started, “David shot back.

“Don’t start, one of the rules is my husband has to watch.”

“Well, we already broke that one, didn’t we?”

“Videos are as good as watching,” Sage shot back. She was still incredibly horny, and David seemed to know that. He wasn’t as apologetic this time. Instead, he seemed confident, almost cocky that he had pushed the boundaries.

“Right, of course they are. But… think about it, how practical is it going to be trying to film every last thing?” David said, picking up his phone and typing on it for a moment. “Just sent you the videos, by the way, I’m sure you’re husband is going to lose his fucking mind.”

“You need to play nicely, David,” Sage said shortly standing up and walking over to her phone. As she did, she noticed that David was still not fully soft. If anything, it seemed like he was slowly becoming hard again. It was an observation she wished she hadn’t noticed and wished she wasn’t so excited about. Sage could feel David staring at her body while she worked on her phone. With a newfound excitement, she happily attached all three videos to a message for Jeremy, then added a kissing emoji. As soon as she sent it, Sage felt a rush of adrenaline and lust swim over her. She wiggled in glee, making her ass shake as she did so. David noticed it and began to stroke his cock again.

“I’m just saying, video recording every little thing…” He walked over to Sage, who had now turned from her phone and looked at him. She glanced down, noting he was now fully erect again.

“That’s the deal,” Sage shot back shortly.

“Is it? Think about it, you don’t think Jeremy likes the idea that he’s not getting every bit of what's going on between us, you think he doesn’t love the idea that we’re doing things together alone right now?” David asked. He stepped closer to Sage as he spoke, his giant cock now between her thighs as his hands firmly grabbed her juicy ass.

“If you keep pushing boundaries, we won’t be doing this again David,” Sage shot back.

“You said that last time, but here we are” David replied with a smirk. His hands dug into Sage’s fleshy thighs as his cock rubbed against her underwear. She could feel his girth against her pussy, and she could tell he was testing the waters as his cock began to thrust back and forth slowly against her.

It was electrifying, her juices bled through her black underwear onto his dick, encouraging him to thrust a bit more aggressively.

“Oh my god… David we–” Sage was interrupted by David shoving his tongue into her mouth. As he aggressively made out with her, his cock began to rub more eagerly against pussy. A sawing motion that thrust upwards as David’s hands wandered from her ass to her breasts. The two kissed passionately, and Sage felt herself nearing completion as she began to push back against his shaft.

It wasn’t until David’s hand went to Sage’s underwear and moved them to the side, it wasn’t until Sage felt David’s warm, bare cock against her wet lips that she snapped back to reality.

“No,” She said firmly, pushing away from David aggressively. She let out a breath, happy to see David had frozen.

I am in control… I can… be in control Sage thought. Her mind was foggy, but clear enough to know this was going too far. David cleared his throat, half anticipating Sage to walk out on him.

“David, Jesus Christ, if you want to be my bull, you need to play by my fucking rules,” Sage said shortly.

David nodded, “right, I got it. Sorry, I thought… well I thought we had something going there.”

“We do have something fucking going here. I get turned on by it, obviously. So do you. But if I say no, you need to respect me and not keep fucking going like an animal,” Sage said. She wasn’t looking David in the eyes as she spoke. She was staring at his throbbing cock, doing her best not to leap on it as they were talking. David seemed to notice, and upon hearing, Sage wasn’t going to walk out on him right then and there, stepped forward again.

“I can do that, alright? But the banter we got going on, you resisting a little bit. I’ll be honest, it’s fucking hot. So maybe we don’t use ‘no’ for no? Because honestly Sage sometimes it seems like you don’t really mean it…”

“No should always mean no,” Sage shot back firmly, but quickly let out a sigh when she saw David’s cock pulse, “Fuck… but you’re right… it’s hot to resist sometimes... Fine, what about a safe word?”

“Safe word?”

“Yes, a word we wouldn’t normally use, and if I say it, we stop. No questions, no banter, no wondering if I meant it or not,” Sage said. As she spoke, she saw her phone buzz. It was Jeremy, no doubt replying to her text. She returned her attention to it for a moment.

Holy shit Sage, this is so fucking hot, hope you two are having a good time. Can’t wait to hear more about it! Jeremy had texted.

Sage was dumbstruck by the text, did that mean Jeremy wanted her to do things out of his sight? Had David been right? She wished Jeremy hadn’t texted that, she wished he had been at least a little upset. But instead, all Sage heard were the words that Jeremy spoke so long ago.

You have my permission.

In her foggy state, Sage knew she was barely holding on to her boundaries, and she knew she was going to have David make her cum before she left today.

“Alright, I like the idea of a safe word,” David said, watching as Sage read her phone slowly. “He likes it, doesn’t he?”

“He does,” Sage confirmed.

“Likes the idea of us being alone, right?”

“I wouldn’t go that far David,” Sage shot back. She knew it would bother Jeremy if she went all the way without him seeing it. “Our safe word will be midnight. No way that would come up normally.”

“Fine, midnight it is,” David said, walking toward Sage again. He thrust his cock between Sage's legs once more, but Sage stepped back.

“We’re going to save that for when Jeremy can see,” Sage said, making David groan.

“Fuck, fine but I know you still want to cum,” David said, his hands quickly finding their way back to Sage’s pussy, which he promptly began to rub.

“Oh my god, David,” Sage said, thrusting against his fingers without thinking. David smirked, and allowed Sage to grab onto his burly shoulders as he continued to rub her clit. As her juices poured onto his fingers, David began to explore her opening, his fingers casually dipping into Sage slightly as he explored beyond her clit.

“David, fuck… no… no penetration,” Sage said, still rubbing against his fingers. David smirked, his fingers still playfully entering her slightly. Only fingertip deep, as Sage moaned.

David leaned down to Sage’s ear, and whispered, “I don’t hear you saying midnight.”

Sage knew what he meant, she knew if she didn’t want him to penetrate her, now was the time to say something. But she kept silent, and David smiled wickedly. He kissed Sage deeply, and his two fingers slid deep into Sage. She moaned loudly as he worked inside her, his fingers moving rapidly as she rubbed violently against his fingers, making sure her clit hit against him with every thrust.

“Keep going… keep going…” Sage said, completely lost in a fog as she came close to cumming. David happily obliged, moving Sage to the couch and throwing her on it as his fingers continued to move in perfect unison with her humping.

He had a much better angle leaning over her and happily groped at Sage’s breasts with his free hand as he shoved his fingers deep inside her. She moaned, David played with her clit, she thrust against his finger fucking. David felt Sage's inside walls begin to tighten, and he felt her thrusts grow more rapid.

“I’m going to cum David… oh fuck… I’m going to…” Sage’s body tensed. She shivered as she squirted on David’s fingers. In a moment of passion, David lost himself once again, he repositioned himself over Sage while she stared, lost in the high of her orgasm. She felt David’s large body press against her and his throbbing cock rest on her pussy.

“David, we can’t!” Sage shot back.

“Say midnight if you want me to stop, otherwise, shut the fuck up and enjoy it. I won’t go inside, I just want to rub against that wet pussy of yours,” David said, now thrusting against Sage’s lips with a level of vigor Sage had never seen before. He was like an animal, and she loved that she had made him that way.

Sage didn’t say midnight as David thrust violently against her. She opened her legs wider so he could plow more easily. The girth of his shaft and his giant head hit her clit perfectly with each long thrust. He grabbed ahold of her ass as he sawed his cock back and forth, pulling her into him with each aggressive thrust. Sage’s pussy was gushing, her juices easily lubricating the entirety of his shaft. He had no condom on, and on more than one occasion, Sage felt the head of his cock dip into her pussy, only slightly entering, before popping out and sliding along her clit in a long smooth motion.

It was risky, it wasn’t anything she or Jeremy had agreed on, and she loved every minute of it.

He gave me permission Sage thought to herself as she began to grow closer to orgasm once again.

It was the last coherent thought she had before becoming lost in sex. David's thrusts began to become more vigorous, his jaw clenched in an all too familiar way to Sage.

“I’m going to fucking cum,” He said shortly, which in turn, made Sage’s body erupt in orgasm. As she squirted on David’s giant cock as a large shot of cum sprayed up onto Sage’s stomach. Then another, and another. Sage looked down, shocked to see how much cum David had produced. This was the first time she had seen all of it out in the open. She watched as thick wades of cum spurted from David’s cock as his thrusts became short and deliberate.

He let out a sigh, kissing Sage deeply as the thrust a few more times against her wet pussy, before finally pulling away with a smile.

Then, guilt hit Sage like a train. None of this was planned, none of this was in control. She couldn't believe how powerless David had made her.

“We-we didn’t record any of that…” Sage said in disbelief.

David simply smiled and said, “Don’t worry Sage, it can be our little secret.”

Hope you guys have enjoyed the story so far! I've actually started up a Patreon if you'd like to read things early / give me some support. Happy reading!

patreon.com/mrjakobs

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)