11. You’re the second person to take her like this… and make her cum like this (she doesn’t attract attention)

Eliza was putting her third hole on a silver platter and you weren’t about to waste time using it. You’d only been able to try anal a couple times, and while you’d loved every second most women couldn’t accommodate your girth easily. You grab Eliza by the hair again and practically throw her over the couch. Lubed plenty with her own juices, you place your cock at her back door and begin to push your way in.

Eliza’s face twists up in pain. The frat boy clearly couldn’t compare to you. You savor the feeling of the head of your cock popping past her anal ring and entering her barely touched depths. She whines softly, clearly fighting the intrusion but still enjoying it.

“Was he the first to take your ass?” You can’t help but ask.

“Yes,” she answers breathily and you can tell she is getting some pleasure out of this.

“And I’m the second?”

“Yes.”

You feel her muscles begin to squeeze your shaft rhythmically. You smile. You’ve barely entered her and already the pleasure is building between her legs.

“Did you cum for him when he fucked you?”

“Yes.”

“And did you cum for him when he fucked your ass?”

“Y– Yes.”

Eliza’s voice is halting and you could tell she was getting close to climax again, just from having your cock enter her tight little asshole. Only halfway in, you begin to rock your hips. She yelps softly as you fuck her ass properly, with each thrust getting deeper and deeper. She begins to shake, the pleasure building deep inside her.

“Oooh… oh god.” She whispers and you feel her body tense again.

Eliza cums hard. She practically explodes on your cock and you feel her muscles tense up. You can barely thrust the way she’s squeezing down on your cock. Her orgasm pushes you over the edge too and you feel your cock twitch deep in her bowel. You can’t help but groan as you do and you barely subdue yourself so as not to attract attention. She whines softly as you begin to withdraw, her orgasm continuing to milk your softening cock.

The head of your cock pops past her asshole and you look down at your patient. She’s dripping your cum from both her holes and you feel a sadistic pleasure taking her like this. And you’re thinking this isn’t the last time you’ll suggest exposure therapy for Eliza. You hear her mutter something, panting and whispering so softly you can’t make it out.

“What was that Eliza?”

“And then he made me clean him up.”