Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)
Chapter 18
by
namenotfound
What does Olivia say?
"Sure! Sounds fun!"
"Sure! Sounds fun!" Olivia says.
The full meaning of their words don't really hit you until you feel Olivia pull back, sliding the dildo fully out of you. As you feel the tip exit, your body reacts instantly, thrusting your hips back, as if trying to catch it.
"Oh look at that!" Vivien says, gleefully. "How badly he want's you back in his ass." As much as you hate it, you can't even deny it as you feel your ass aching. "Don't worry hun." Vivien says. You look over at just the right time to watch her slide her member out of Dan. It's even larger than you thought before, as she seems to even be struggling a bit to get the tip fully out. You suddenly hear a loud pop, followed by a howling groan from Dan, as the giant cock now waves free. It looks almost comical hanging off her body. It however, becomes less funny as she moves over towards you.
"He's all yours!" Vivien says to Olivia as she point towards Dan who is now fully collapsed on the floor. "Just give him a second, his insides had to do allot of shifting for this bad boy."
You watch, now extremally nervous as Dan slowly begins move, his face is still bright red as he breaths deeply.
"Come on Dan!" Vivien shouts. "You're not done yet." The seemingly defeated man, lets out another grunt as he forces himself back into position. Don't worry about being gentle, dear." Vivien says to Olivia, who is now readying herself behind Dan. "He can take it."
Olivia gives a look of pure joy as in one swift motion, she slams the entirety of her fake cock into Dan's ass.
"Oooh!" Dan gasps. Though his sounds are nowhere near as loud as they were before.
"Oh, you're lucky." Vivien says to you as you feel her getting ready behind you. "She's a lot of fun."
You make no effort to agree or disagree as you are fully focused on the excruciating horrors you're about to be put through.
You close your eyes as you feel Vivien press the tip of her monster against you.
"Aw! You've got such a cute little tight ass." Vivien says as you feel her pushing harder. "I'll help change that." The pressure against your asshole increases as the dildo pries it to open. For a moment, you're not sure if you'll be able to open enough to allow it to enter, but it works well at stretching out your entrance as it slowly forces its way inside of you.
"GAH!" You gasp as you feel the pain of being stretched farther than you thought was possible. The sensation increases as more and more of the mammoth object makes its way through you.
In an attempt to distract yourself, you look over at Olivia who seems to be greatly enjoying herself as she slams in and out of Dan's ass rapidly. The moans and grunts from Dan seem to be more from pleasure than agony now.
"It looks like those two are having fun, doesn't it?" Vivien says as she firmly grabs your hips. She uses her grip to pull you closer, inching even more of the massive rubber toy into you. "Maybe I should try keeping up with your girlfriend here."
Does she try keeping up with Olivia's pace? Or take is slow?
Your Girlfriend's Plaything
Your girlfriend decides that you'd make a better plaything than a boyfriend. Is it a dream come true or a living nightmare? You decide.
Your girlfriend decides that you'd make a better plaything than a boyfriend. Is it a dream come true or a living nightmare? You decide. Additions are more than welcome, please add!
Updated on Apr 15, 2026
by namenotfound
Created on Feb 14, 2021
by namenotfound
- 9,948 Likes
- 2,652,485 Views
- 1,394 Favorites
- 1,262 Bookmarks
- 290 Chapters
- 25 Chapters Deep
Comments moved below the chapter.

Comments