"No, but now it's your turn"

"So was that it?"

"No," Scott answered. "But now it's your turn."

I let out a yelp as Scott grabbed and me rolled me onto my back.

__________

SCOTT

__________

"To be honest, I don't think my time was as fun as yours."

"Oh yea?" I asked, concerned. "Why is that?"

"It wasn't terrible. It just was... a bit frustrating. I drew Robert," Mandy said as I kissed my way down her body. "I was in the bathroom freshening up and, when I came out, he was standing there. He seemed a bit nervous too but he made a joke that, if he was one of the girls, he would have just been naked in bed waiting for whatever guy came into the room. Oh-"

My lips found her pussy. I split her folds and pressed my tongue into her hole.

"So I went back into the bedroom and waited a few minutes and, when I came back out, he was naked lying in bed. He was still nervous but it definitely seemed to ease some of the tension. I climbed in bed next to him and we started making out and then I started rubbing his cock under the covers. Then I started to go down on him."

"How as it?" I asked.

"It was..." I took a split second to consider my answer. I didn't want to oversell it, but also, I had to be honest. "Big."

"Thick?"

"Pretty thick."

"Hard."

"Very hard.

"Did he know how to use it?"

"Well..." I paused again. Scott looked up at me. "Let's just say, I didn't have to do too much work."

"Oh wow," I said with a chuckle. I shouldn't have laughed but it was unexpected.

"Yea, he was pretty quick to shoot," Mandy continued. "I felt bad because he felt embarrassed. It was so cute and innocent. Like, it just snuck up on him and he started twitching and, next thing I knew, he was cumming in my mouth. Oh, God, Scott."

I had resumed my oral efforts.

"And he told me that, if we went down on me, by the time I came, he'd be able to get it back up again. So he did. And I came. And he was right. Oh, God, Scott. Keep going."

Her fingers found my scalp, pulling me into her. At the same time she began grinding her pussy into my mouth.

"So I grabbed him by his big cock and pulled him into me. It felt so big and full. It took a bit of getting used to and it seemed like, just when I was getting used to it, he... well..."

"Again?" I asked. "That quick?"

"That quick," Mandy replied. "It felt good while it lasted, I'll give him that. But it was definitely more than a bit frustrating."

"Damn," I said. I felt bad that Mandy had such a rough experience. I mean, it could have been significantly worse, all things considered, but it still was tough hearing that I might have had a much better time than she did.

"That wasn't it, though," Mandy said. "We laid in bed and talked for a bit then we started making out and I just let him suck on my breasts until I decided that I wanted to give it one more go. So I started rubbing my breasts all over his cock. That worked. So I hopped on his lap and started riding it and it felt so good and he was really sexy and I felt myself getting close and then, you wouldn't believe it!"

"Popped early again?"

"Right before I was about to cum." I laughed.

"Damn," I said. "That's rough. Did he go down on you again?"

"No," Mandy answered. "We didn't have time and I was too frustrated at that point. He was fine at it but at that point I figured I'd just wait for you."

"No wonder you were so horny when I walked in."

"That's why I needed your cock inside me so badly," Mandy said. "And why I need it again now."

Mandy grabbed my shoulders, directing me upwards. I kissed her as she reached down and grabbed a hold of my cock which wasn't quite cooperating the way I would have liked.

"I honestly don't know if I have another in me," I said. "But I can go down on you for as long as you like."

Mandy looked at me and said, "I believe in you."

I laughed and shook my head.

"Why don't you tell me about the rest of your night?"

"OK..." I began, knowing where I was headed. I didn't plan to keep it from Mandy but I also wasn't exactly looking forward to telling her. I have no idea how she'd react. I couldn't quite explain it, but I felt like it was somehow different. Maybe it was because we both had been so adamantly against doing it and it was the first real curveball in our swinging escapades. No matter what it was, I had to tell her and I trusted that we would figure it out.

"Before you continue with your story, I have a confession to make," Mandy said.

OK, now this was really getting interesting

I looked at her, now seemingly the one nervous to tell me something.

What the heck could it be? Was it something with Robert? Was it bad? I know he came quickly a few times but was that the extent of why she didn't have a great time with him? Was it something worse? How worse?

"I drew our room."

The words hit me like a ton of bricks - an initial smack followed by a pause, followed by me looking around, wondering where I was. Thoughts and emotions flew through my mind.

She heard us. She had to have heard us. Madeline was loud. I was probably very loud. She was shouting for me to cum in her ass. My wife heard another woman beg me to cum in her ass from the room next door. What did she think when she heard it? Was she disgusted? She was probably disgusted. She doesn't seem disgusted, though. Maybe she's hiding it and trying to be nice about it? Was she with Robert when she hard it? Did Robert... No way. She wouldn't do that. Then again, neither would I but I did it.

"So..." I finally said, though I the next words hadn't entered my brain yet.

"I heard you," Mandy said.

"You heard us..."

"I heard you," Mandy said again. "I heard you loud and clear. Both of you. The first time was the time you described earlier. I heard her - Madeline - calling your name. I heard you calling her name. I heard you guys cum."

"Mandy, I-"

"Then I heard you again. I heard you both grunting like animals. Then I heard her tell you to..."

"Mandy, I'm sorry. I didn't - I didn't," I couldn't find the right words. I was sorry but I wasn't exactly sure why. I just knew that I felt bad that she heard it all.

"I heard her tell you to cum in her ass."

The words dropped like a ton of bricks, leaving a wake of silence behind.

"I..." I tried to begin again. "I -"

"It's OK," Mandy said. "I promise. There's nothing you need to feel sorry for."

I let out a long exhale of relief. "But I do want to hear all about it."

"It just... happened," I said, still struggling to make any sounds with my mouth.

"It just happened?" Mandy asked with a giggle. "Like, oops, I'm in your butt now."

"Actually," I said, bursting into laughter. "Yea, that is actually sort of how it happened. Not entirely, but pretty much."

Finally, the tension seemed to be lifted and we were back to being our normal selves, laughing along with what was an extremely awkward situation just moments ago.

"After I came all over Maddie's tits, we went in the shower. We took our time washing each other and just talking. It was really nice. By the time we got out it was almost 12:45. She asked if we could just lay in bed for a bit and cuddle naked so I spooned up behind her and, god her ass is incredible. Next thing I knew I was sort of grinding myself into her ass."

"Mmm... I love when you do that," Mandy cooed. Her hand slipped downward and began rubbing over my cock and balls. "I bet her ass felt so good."

"It did," I confirmed. "I was hard as a rock and hornier than a porcupine and I started to get really into it. I guess I sort of pulled back a bit too much and had an awkward angle of attack but, when I pushed forward, the tip of my cock got caught on her asshole. We both sort of froze and, I don't know what came over me, but I pushed forward a bit. She didn't protest. Instead she pushed back against me. I pushed forward some more and she pushed backward some more and, next thing I knew, I was balls deep in her asshole."

"What was it like?" Mandy asked. Her hand had begun sliding up and down my shaft, trying desperately to get me going again.

"Hot," I answered quickly. "Very hot and very tight. I pulled out and pushed back in. I was barely in control of my own movements. I rolled her over onto her stomach and really drove into her. She seemed like she was enjoying it. She certainly wasn't stopping me and soon she was begging me to cum in her ass and, my God, she started to cum and her asshole just gripped me and squeezed the life out of me. For a second, I thought I might black out. It was intense."

"So, you enjoyed it then?" Mandy asked. Suddenly I felt self-conscious though I knew that wasn't her intention.

"Yea," I said. My face turned read a bit. "Yea, it was really fucking sexy. I don't know if I'd like it in a different way or anything but, in that moment, it felt right and it felt so fucking good."

"But I don't expect you to want to do it or anything," I said, suddenly realizing what I might be implying. "Like I said, I'm not sure how I really feel about it all."

"Well, I'm glad you enjoyed it," Mandy said. "And I'm glad you enjoyed your night with Madeline."

"I'm sorry you had a tough night."

"It's OK. It was bound to happen at some point if we kept all this swinging up. Not everybody can be as good as Billy or Manny. Or you. That's why we need to get this guy going again."

I laughed as Mandy emphasized her last words by squeezing my frustratingly soft penis.

"I told you, I don't know if it's got another one in it tonight. It's done a lot of work already."

"I have an idea!"