More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 9 by backnumber backnumber

Does Gary cheat on Bernie?

yes of course

“Do I want her? If that’s not an open invitation to a good fuck I don’t know what is,” muttered Gary “stuff the love business she’s already says she opens her legs to just about anyone. Anyway I owe it to Lillian- I ought to use her and discard her like the slut she is.” He passed Colleen her drink. Her fingers stroked his hand as she took it. Gary sensed an almost electric tremor as she did so. “But is it fair to Bernie, well she’ll never know- not at least if I’m more careful then Steve was. And is Colleen really a slut or just a bit mixed up Lil did like her before she found her with Steve who’s a no hoper anyway”

"Colleen just a sec please I need to ring Lil" he said then sms'ed his sister "Cum home urself plz visitor here 4 u"

He thought he was still unsure when Colleen finished her drink put it down and took him by the hand drawing him down to sit on the sofa next to her. He smiled, patted her arm in a friendly way saying “Sure I want you any guy would but don’t you think asking that question is going to get you into trouble? You’re not going to find someone who will love you like you want that way.” He kissed her cheek and went on, “Talking that way is only going to get you jerks like Steve who use you.” Still undecided but thinking to test just how pliable she was he slipped his arm round her waist pulling her closer to him.

Colleen replied, “You're sweet and honest and I like you; I don’t even mind that you're going out with Bernie Bernstein." and flung one of her arms around his neck kissing him, he felt her tongue slide on his lips; her other hand groped for his cock.

“Hell she wants it badly” he thought and made up his mind- in fact he knew he had made it up as soon as he saw Colleen. He knew then he wanted to fuck her senseless; he knew how the other thoughts had been merely rationalisations to prove to himself he was a better man then he was.

His free hand crept over Colleen's body and kneaded her right breast gently while he returned her kiss, his lips nibbling first her top then her bottom lip and then parting to let her tongue in his mouth. Colleen responded by unzipping Gary’s pants then stroking his cock now freed from its confining clothes while her tongue darted in and out of his mouth.

Gary pushed her away for a moment – long enough for him to lift her sundress up and off her body and unhook her bra while she busied herself pulling down her panties and kicking them off before she undid Gary’s belt and unbuckled his pants. Then she gently pushed him back onto the sofa and knelt one leg on each side of his body before lowering herself on his cock. She moaned softly as his cock slid into her then turned to Gary with a look of surprise as he chuckled.

“Um… well” he muttered shamefaced as his hands stroked her nipples “I wondered earlier if your pussy hair was the same colour as the hair on your head and I just found out it is. You were right I wanted you from the moment I saw you.” He dropped one of his hands to her pussy and stroked it too while his mouth closed on the nipple where his hand had been sucking and nipping it gently.

"Doesn’t matter," she murmured as she dug her fingers into Gary’s back and used her legs to bounce up and down on his member. Then she yelled “Oh yes fuck me fill me with your cock!”

As she sensed he was about to cum she slowed down her rhythmic bouncing to easing herself oh so slowly up and down.

“Hey Colleen what are you doing? I want to cum, this is torturing me!” moaned Gary.

“Good things cum to boys that wait,” Colleen chuckled slowing even more. “Take me with you!”

Gary stroked her pussy mound harder till Colleen threw back her head gasping “Ohhhhhhhh yesssssss!” which was enough to trigger Gary’s orgasm too.

“Steve’s right,” thought Gary afterwards while Colleen still sat on his lap. “she is a pro- nah she's a fucking slut but he’s a fool, for properly handled she’ll be there whenever I want her and I will be wanting her again.” Aloud he said “Mmm that was one of the nicest ways of filling in time I know, hope it was good for you too and I hope there can be many more time fillers like that for us both. But it was more then just time filling for me and more then just mindless sex.” Again he thought “ok well I lied she wont know about that”.

Colleen smiled “Yes it was good so much better then with Steve. I could tell you liked me for myself and not just as a fuck.”

Smiling inwardly at Colleen's naiveté, Gary replied “Steve was stupid he never did appreciate a lady.” and he kissed her lips softly. “Colleen I think you had better go soon I’d hate my sister and Bernie to come home and get the wrong… ur right idea about what we were doing. I’ll make you a coffee while you get dressed.”

So when Lil and Bernie returned they found Colleen sitting at the kitchen table sipping coffee and chatting quietly to Gary.

Colleen stood up. "Lil I want to say how sorry I am for what happened with Steve. He told he and you were over. I wouldn’t have had sex with him otherwise. I am so sorry. Please forgive me.”

Gary listened to Colleen prattle on and thought “you’re a lying bitch for you know Bernie and I are going out but you did me. You’re no more then a whore but well that’s fine so long as I don’t get found cheating on Bernie. Just have to be careful.”

A few minutes later Colleen left. Gary showed her to the door and said “till next time.”

Is Colleen really such a slut? Does Gary feel remorse?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)