A Tale of Two Virgins: Hallowed to Hollowed

A Tale of Two Virgins: Hallowed to Hollowed

Two untouched pussies: one Baptist guilt trip, one arranged-marriage obligation, and a single forbidden craving.

Chapter 1 by remysloane remysloane

Claire: The Virgin Who Hides

I’m Claire, 22, a tall 5'11" in socks thanks to my Dutch ancestry, and I’ve spent my whole life trying not to take up space.

I slip into rooms quietly, shoulders curved forward, ill-fitting clothes chosen to hide the heavy sway of my breasts and the round ass I finally earned after months of squats and saying no to pizza.

I’m the quiet girl in the back row, little makeup, long hair twisted up so no one notices. I'm afraid to dress for attention I’m not ready to handle. I’m a nerd, I was chubby most of my life, and I’ve never had a boyfriend. I was raised Baptist, hands folded in my lap at youth group, promising I’d wait for marriage, for the right guy, for God’s timing.

I just moved across the country for my first real job out of college, left the small Midwest town where everyone knew my name and my parents’ rules. I lost thirty pounds along the way, carved a body I barely recognize in the mirror, and told myself this is my new start: stronger, braver, ready.

But I am super horny lately, the kind of horny that wakes me up at night with my fingers already between my legs, thighs clenched around my hand while I imagine a thick cock pressing against the tight seal that proves I've waited, stretching it slow and merciless until it snaps and I’m no longer the girl who’s never been fucked.

I tell myself I’m strong enough to hold the line.

I tell myself I’m waiting for love, for commitment, for a ring and a white dress.

But the truth is I’m not like those confident girls who walk into bars and leave with a man. I feel invisible, and when someone does look twice I blush so hard I want to disappear. So I hide the body I worked so hard for, pretend the ache between my legs isn’t there, and pray nobody ever guesses how desperately I want to be touched, filled, ruined.

Because as much as I say I’m waiting…

I really want to get laid, and I’m starting to think I won’t last much longer.

Ramya: The Virgin Who Swallows

I’m your cover girl, Ramya, 23, 6'1" in bare feet, lighter golden-brown skin from my North-Indian roots, and I’ve learned how to look like the perfect daughter while quietly breaking every rule that doesn’t show up on a gynecologist’s report.

My only rule: no vaginal penetration wider than one slim finger. One careless jab or overeager thrust could destroy the fragile seal between my legs, steal the blood my future husband will demand as proof, and drop my price to zero in the arranged-marriage auction I can’t escape.

I live for the loopholes: I’ve swallowed twenty-two loads from almost as many men, taken it up the ass four times, and my pussy remains a neat, sealed little slit no cock has defiled. My virginity is sacred, reserved for the husband my parents will choose, the one who’ll get the certificate proving I’m still hallowed down there.

I suck dick because it’s practice for when I finally have to perform, but also because it sharpens my edge. Swallowing a man’s secrets teaches me how they think, how they break, making me a killer manager at work and untouchable on dating apps where I hunt white guys for one-night stands.

At 23 I’m already considered “old” for an Indian bride; most girls my age are married with kids on the way, and every family gathering comes with the same worried glances at my height. Six-one is beautiful in magazines, but intimidating to the kind of traditional men my parents want for me.

What if the arranged marriage never comes? What am I saving myself for?

My body is the proof I fought for this life: heavy, pendulous breasts that sag with the weight I lost, stretch marks like silver lightning across the undersides, abs finally carved beneath them, and a thick black bush guarding the tiny, untouched slit I’ve kept sealed all these years. And, oh, by the way, a smoking hot ass that stops traffic, round and firm from a thousand squats, the one part of me I never have to apologize for.

But with every load I swallow, I’m left hungrier for the one thing I can’t allow, and the ache between my legs is starting to whisper that ruin might be worth the sacrifice.

The willpower it takes to keep my pussy locked is starting to feel like the cruelest punishment.


Choose your virgin and watch her break.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)