You oblige...

The thought of Natalie having even more **** material filled you with dread, and from the uneasy look Tammy had she felt the same. Both of you look each other in the eye and nod, and you slowly close your eyes as your hand loosens.

With your arms at your side there was a short awkward silence that's quickly interrupted by Natalie's sudden laughter

"Oh my god! You dorks are perfect for each other! I already knew my sister had such small tits but who would've thought her boyfriend would be packing a matching small wiener to go with them hahaha!"

You curse yourself for forgetting about your little secret. No one has ever seen your penis before and to think the first ones your expose yourself to would be your cute nerdy friend and her big sister was humiliating as hell.

You slowly open your eyes and see that despite witnessing Tammy closing her eyes at the same time you did, see she opened hers a tad bit earlier. Your embarrassment increased tenfold once you saw that Tammy is shamelessly fixated on your privates, almost as if mesmerized by what she's seeing.

Tammy on the other hand was already blushing like crazy but once she realizes you also had an unobstructed view of every bit of her womanly charms you didn't think she'd get any redder but she certainly did. Tammy let out a small yelp as she couldn't decide which was more embarrassing; that she was utterly exposed in front of her long time crush and her small yet perky boobs and her privates were bared before him, or the fact that she got caught shamelessly oogling his penis.

As soon as Natalie has stopped laughing at your predicament she hurried the both of you to resume dancing. True to her word she didn't seem to take any pictures of you yet nor did she seem to be recording your nudity.

Wanting to get the whole thing over with you place your hands on Tammy's hips and grab her hand as you got into dancing position. Tammy was startled by your forwardness but nonetheless followed your lead as she placed her free hand on your shoulder and the two of you begin dancing once more.

You could feel the heat radiating from both of your faces as both of you try to concentrate on dancing and not at staring at each other's bodies, although neither of you did a good job at it as you continue to catch each other stealing glances at each others privates, and each time you caught the other doing the deed you quickly focus on each other's face.

After about a minute of faux fancy dancing Natalie suddenly stands up and began clapping, obviously with a hint of teasing with every clap

"Bravo, bravo! Let's give it up for the lovely couple! I gotta say, I honestly didn't think you two would go through with it but you two naked lovebirds proved me wrong! You can stop now"

With that both of you quickly covered up and sat down

"Aw come one why acting so shy? Not like both of you haven't seen everything already"

Both of you share a glance before blushing madly and looking away from each other, though you could have sworn Tammy was smiling a bit before she turned away

"C-can we please get dressed now Nat?" Tammy piped up

"Alright, alright you held up your bargain. You guys were such good sports I'm almost tempted to delete the pics I took of you dorks, almost. Alright get dressed now, though I think both of you look way more adorable like this"

Natalie tosses your clothes, both you and Tammy stand up and slowly get dressed, unconsciously uncovering yourselves again giving you another unobstructed view of Tammy's naked form, while giving her yours.

"Well it was fun but I got stuff to do so I'll leave you lovebirds now, be sure to treat my lil sis real good shrimpy!" and with that Natalie leaves the room, you're anxious on whether she'll keep her word on not spreading the photos she took of you and Tammy butt naked, but you decide to trust her for now.

All alone with Tammy once more you both sit down at the edge of her bed, an awkward silence fills the room.

You decide to break the tension and lighten the mood a bit "Well, that must have been the most embarrassing moment of my life haha! But-"

Suddenly Tammy turns her head and looks at you, her face still flushed and red as a tomato

"I'm sorry I took it our game too far, if I didn't **** you to get naked and do those things we wouldn't have had to do something as embarrassing as that. I even dragged you into my sister's shenanigans, I'm really sorry Sam"

You can tell her words were genuine and she really feels bad about the whole thing, you didn't want her to feel any worse after the whole ordeal you went through

"As embarrassing as everything that happened tonight, I'd be lying if I said I didn't have fun at least, it was definitely exciting. And what your sister did wasn't your fault so don't feel to bad about it!"

"Really Sam? You mean it?"

"Of course, plus we're even since well I got to see more of you just as you got to see more of me heh"

Tammy blushed hard again when she heard that, even her ears got red. She playfully punches your shoulder and giggles

"Well, I'd just want to let you know despite my sister's teasing, I thought you and your little buddy were pretty cute"

Now it was your turn to blush, but it was all in good faith as both of you laughed at the whole thing.

"Well, what do you wanna do now Sam?" Tammy asked

"Hmm tell you what, I think I deserve a rematch on our game, same rules!"

"Oh you want to get naked again that badly huh? You're on!"

And with that both of you happily hopped off the bed and merrily made your way downstairs for another round of bonding, hand in hand