Yes, pretend to take off the condom

"God, you feel so good, you're gonna make me cum" you tell her between breaths.

"Cum for me, John. Cum for me." she exclaimed as she rode you, hard, and didn't think to check if the condom had broken.

She lifted up until she was just grazing the naked tip of your cock with her opening, but without warning she sank down again, oblivious that your entire cock was seconds from exploding inside her—nothing between you.

At the very last possible second, you pulled your cock out, sliding the broken rubber off and jerking your cum onto your stomach. It didn't feel as good as using her pussy, but it certainly was safer than busting inside of her.

She turned around, saying "What condom brand was that? It felt incredible." Before you could answer, she licked up your shaft, cleaning the remaining cum off of you. "Wow, we taste good together babe" she said as she sucked the tip. You almost rolled your eyes back as she played with the tip, but you were already spent, so your cock softened as she cleaned you off.

As you both caught your breaths, you got dressed and exchanged numbers. "You better text me!" she said, as she slipped out the door and back in to the party.