Walking Nicole Home (Dark Reprise)

Author's note. Thanks to everyone who read the first story. I have doubts that I'll continue with the story of the Partonites but it was a fun if incredibly ridiculous idea I had late at night, I decided to write while doing prep for the Cthulu game I'm running on a Friday night. I think this is mostly going to be a series of short story ideas or alternate takes on chapters I have written elsewhere. I did put the category down as Humour and Satire but this next one is quite far from that. This is an alternative version of the chapter from High School Fantasy redux titled Walking Home with Nicole. I did consider writing this as an alternative version in HFR but decided to write it here instead. The dialogue has been changed a little.

The two of them left the detention classroom and started walking home, holding hands. Dan noticed she had a definite spring in her step and just seemed overly excited. She squeezed his hand playfully.

“I never thought I'd do that with someone else watching me. I know people have seen my video, but that's not the same as someone standing next to me.” Nicole told him in a happy tone.

“Did it turn you on?” Dan asked.

“I was so wet when you were fucking me. I loved it when Kaitlyn was watching us when the two of us were together.”

“Had you done anything like that before?”

Dan had never had anyone watch him before when he was with another girl. The video was one thing, but it was far removed from someone physically standing there and watching you in person.

“Honestly? I've never considered myself to be an exhibitionist, but it excites me knowing other people have watched me like that.

Dan was understandably excited about where the direction of this conversation was going.

“It really excites me, and it scares me at the same time. I like the idea of someone catching me the risk is such a turn-on”

“Yeah, apart from the video, I've never done anything like that. I had sex outdoors with Tessa, but that was like miles from anyone else. There wasn't anybody around to catch us.

“I'm think of other places in school we could try it.“

“We could sneak out between classes tomorrow.”

She squeezed his hand again. “There's that supply closet. That could be fun. “

“With Tessa it was some of the most intense sex we ever had.”

“What was she like? I'm not the new girlfriend jealous of her man's previous partners. Just really curious.”

Dan was surprised at Nicole's question. “She was sweet, cute, funny, adventurous I don't just mean sexually. But we knew it was only a short-term thing while she was here for a few months.

“Do you miss her? I won't be upset at your answer.”

“Yeah. I still think about her every so often. Not just the sex she was just fun as a person.

There was an awkward silence between the two of them for a moment. Nicole was the first to say anything.

“When we were having sex in front of Kaitlyn. I kept thinking, would it turn me on to see her with my boyfriend?”

Dan hesitated before answering so as not to come across as too eager. He realised Nicole's response may help when he eventually told her about the video with Addison.

“What did you think?

“I was having really mixed emotions. I think a part of me would be jealous and another part would really want to see you fuck another girl in front of me.”

Dan decided to test the waters and see how Nicole would react.

“I think I almost could have had sex with Ms Harris earlier.”

It was Nicole's turn to be silent for a moment. She took a minute before replying.

“Our history teacher?

“Yeah. There's always been this connection between us. An unspoken attraction that neither of us could act on, as well, she's a teacher, and I'm her student.

“How did it happen?

“A freshman collided with her, and I helped her into her classroom. I ended up massaging her foot, and things escalated a little from there. She stopped me more before anything could go any further.”

“You got a thing for older women, Dan?

“She's not that much older than me. She's hardly a cougar.”

“Would you have fucked her?

“Yeah, I wasn't really thinking at the time, but I would if she had wanted to.

“She is really pretty. I can't really blame a guy for being attracted to her.”

Nicole stopped for a moment and pulled Dan into a really passionate kiss.

“I needed that. I started getting wet thinking about the idea of you fucking her. “

“I wasn't sure how you would react.”

“I'm not saying I want an open relationship, Dan, but I'm weirdly comfortable with the idea of you fucking other girls. Just either let me watch or tell me everything.

She kissed him again. Moaning softly into Dan's mouth. He caressed her sides as they kissed.

Dan realised they were about halfway to Nicole's house.

“I know a shortcut,” Nicole told him.

Nicole led Dan to her a shrouded woodland area that was near her house. He began to doubt Nicole's description of this being a shortcut, as the area was really enclosed.

“This doesn't really look like a shortcut.” He commented.

“It's not. I want to feel you inside me again before you take me home.” She replied.

Nicole led Dan over to a downed log and put one leg up. He stood behind her and started kissing her neck while unzipping his pants. He reached under her skirt and slipped her panties to the side. He traced his fingers down Nicole's slit, and she was already slick with her juices. He pressed the head of his cock against her lips but did not fully enter her.

“Stop teasing,” Nicole complained.

Dan wrapped his arm around he waist to better support the pair of him. He inserted himself into her fully. He held Nicole down on his cock, while keeping himself fully inside her. She moaned at being so full with her boyfriend's cock. He started fucking her with slow, deep strokes. He watched Nicole reach down and slip a hand under her skirt. He felt her hand teasing his balls gently before starting to tease her clit.

Dan felt the urges overtaking him again. He had only felt like this once before but had found himself being compelled to submit to them as he had back then. He brought his hands up to Nicole's throat. At first, he just gently stroked her neck. He heard Nicole softly moan at his touch. He continued sliding himself into her and started to squeeze. At first, Nicole was enjoying the feeling of her throat being constricted; it made the sensations more intense for her. Then she found herself struggling to breathe.

“You're hurting me.”

Dan began to sob. He ignored her cries, he squeezed harder, feeling her windpipe being crushed beneath his fingers. Nicole started screaming, Dan used one arm to block her mouth. She desperately clawed at his hand in vain. He ignored the pain and continued until he felt her go slack in his arms. He laid her down on the ground and closed her eyes. She looked strangely angelic that way on the floor.

He stood there for some time. A mixture of satisfaction and self-loathing washed over him as he looked at what he had done. He took his phone out of his pocket and called Randy. He was in hysterics when his friend answered the call.

“I did it again.” Dan cried into the phone.

“Again..... oh fuck. Let me know where you are, and I'll come collect her. I'll get Emma to fetch any supplies we need. Think about anything you touched, what we need to get rid of. You were lucky last time because Tessa was in another State.” Randy replied.

“Thank you,” Dan answered.

“Stay there and don't let anyone find you,” Randy said, ending the call.