Try to stay awake

I blissfully laid there, nestled in the warm comfy sheets of our bed. Basking in the afterglow of some amazing sex.

Well, we didn't technically have sex yet. But we came close enough! Penetrative wasn't a necessity for sex, so I count that as losing my virginity!

I don't know what I was so worried about. It had been an amazing experience, even with Sarah's dad's date in the next room over screaming her brains out. Sarah's looks, or her 'sexual abilities' weren't something I loved her for.

I loved her for her smile. Her warmth. How she always had to help people, with no concern for herself. So that experience I just had... it was icing on top of an already delicious cake!

I wanted nothing more than to snuggle up to Sarah right now. To cuddle with her and peacefully fall asleep together. But she still hadn't come back from the bathroom. I tried to look and see if she'd thrown her shirt back on, but I couldn't from my angle and honestly couldn't be bothered to move and see. Her dad was right out that door, of course she put a shirt on. That just made sense.

"Fuuck daddy... I've missed this..." A whisper just barely made its way into my ear.

I couldn't hear it well, but it must have been Amy. I thought they had finished up, but I guess it was just a break.

"Can, can I taste it again daddy? Is that wrong?"

Yep. That was definitely Nolan's date. Still hungry for his cock even after the room shaking pounding he already gave her. I didn't like to be the judgy type, but that girl must have been an S class slut!

"You know you can baby girl. Somebody's gotta clean this mess up." I heard Nolan softly chuckle. He was speaking a little louder than the girl, bust still whispering.

I didn't get why they were trying to be so quiet now when a few minutes ago they were being loud enough that astronauts on the space station would be complaining about the noise. We'd already heard them going at it like rabbits, so why be shy now?

Then, it hit me.

Sarah.

It was her. She was the reason they were being so quiet now. Obviously she'd bumped into her dad by the bathroom and asked him to keep it down. She could tell it had been effecting me earlier, and was looking out for me!

"He, he might hear though... I ... " The woman whispered so softly, I couldn't make out every word. "He might... sleep..."

I might have been too hard on her. She was definitely a slut, but she was a nice enough girl to worry about how loud they were being. I gave her credit for that even though Sarah had to ask them to be quiet first.

"You know there's nothing wrong about this. I thought I taught you better than that." Nolan whispered. He was being much more vocal with his date now.

A date that I thought he had just met? But it was sounding like they'd actually known each other for a while.

Well, it wasn't any of my business, and honestly I could care less. I was riding high from the rush of our first sexy time, and nothing was going to bring me down!

"Things are different now, I have a..." The woman protested. But even though I was barely able to hear what she was saying, it was obvious she wanted him. "He's... in the... room... can't... love him...".

Oh? Did she have a boyfriend? Or maybe she just felt weird about doing it when I might be listening? I couldn't really figure out what she was trying to say.

"Just give it a kiss for me baby. That's all it'll take after the pounding I gave that slut."

This was getting harder to track. Why was Nolan referring to her in the third person? Was it a role play thing? Is that why their tones were so different now?

I guess I could understand the fantasy there. She pretends to be an innocent girl meeting him for the first time, and then they immediately get into things. In fact, this all being an act made more sense than Nolan picking up some random girl and making her scream like that on their first night together. He wanted to open the door naked for her for god's sake! Of course he already knew her!

"Fine... can't... a regular thing... want to... Daddy..."

The girl's voice was still soft, but that didn't stop her mouth from making some noise.

At first, there was just the one wet pop of the woman's lips kissing Nolan's dick, presumably. But it didn't even take ten seconds for the one kiss to become a second. And then a third, and another and another, until I could hear the distinct sound of a girl deepthroating a huge cock with gusto!

It didn't take long for Nolan to burst. He couldn't hold back his volume anymore. He asked his 'little princess' if she wanted his load all over her face, and from the sounds he was making I think she agreed!

This was feeling a little uncomfortable now though. Snooping on their whispers was one thing, but listening to her make Nolan cum felt a little creepy.

I tried to tune them out. Even as the girl started gushing about her daddies cock. About how much she loved it and how there wouldn't ever be another cock for her. Standard stuff for a slut to say, so instead I focused on listening to my breathing. Letting my thoughts wonder.

My eyelids got heavy again, sleep trying to take me. I held it back as best I could, but just where was Sarah? She'd been gone for a little while now... I wasn't sure-

The bed jolted me up. Sarah was finally back. Sitting on her side of the bed, facing away from me. I hadn't seen her come in, so I didn't know if she wore a shirt or not then, but she wasn't wearing one now.

"Hey, what took you so long?" I asked.

"Hmm? Oh... you're... you're awake..." Sarah's voice sounded a little shaken. Maybe she was just tired. It had been a long day.

"Didn't want to get to sleep without you." I put my hand on her thighs. Trying to subtly hint for her to get under the sheets with me.

She stayed sitting up. Facing away from me.

"I was in the bathroom. Alone." Sarah said softly.

"You don't have to specify that last part. At least I hope!" I gave the joke a weak chuckle, but Sarah wasn't biting.

"You didn't, umm... you didn't hear... anything... umm...." Sarah sounded a little lost, but she turned her head around just enough for me to get a glimpse at it.

There was something on it. Moisturiser, or maybe a face mask for her skin. That must have been what kept her so long. Her skincare routine. That probably should have been obvious, but I'd never lived with a girl before. Stuff like that was all new to me. It must have been why she hadn't gotten into bed fully yet. She was waiting for it to dry or whatever first.

"I heard your dad and his girlfriend going at it again." I told her. Trying to keep the conversation going.

"She's not his girlfriend." Sarah said firmly. "It's not like that, it's... You're sure it was her you heard?"

"Yeah of course. Who else could it be?" Something was off with Sarah. Maybe it was just her being tired, but I wasn't sure. It felt like something more was bugging her. "Thanks for asking them to keep it down by the way. You're too good to me."

Normally when I said something like that to her it would make her smile. She'd blush and say something cute back. But today she was silent. Stuck in contemplative thought.

She did have a lot to think about. Her parents were probably splitting up. Her dad was living with us now. I wanted to be there for her and talk this out, but every time I tried I just put my foot in my mouth.

I had to decide what the right thing to do would be. Talk about her thoughts right now? Or let her sleep it off and see how she feels in the morning...

It wasn't much of a choice really. I knew what I needed to do.