Truth

“Truth, I guess,” I said, nervous for whatever Josh was about to ask me.

“What’s your favorite type of porn?” Josh asked.

“**** porn,” I said, a little embarrassed to tell the truth, especially in front of my own sister.

“Me too,” Stella said. “I was just showing him and Anna some **** porn earlier.”

“Does that mean that you and Anna are—” Danny started before me and Anna cut him off.

“No, no, of course not.” I interrupted.

“Yeah that would be so weird.” Anna added, but we were both blushing way too much to be believable.

“I guess it’s my turn now,” I said. I turned to Stella and said, “Truth or dare?”

“Dare,” she said, obviously.

“I dare you to let everyone taste your pussy.”

Stella hopped up immediately and shoved her crotch in my face. I stuck my tongue out and dragged it across her cunt, before burying my whole face in it. After like 10 seconds, I pulled away so that everyone else could try. Caroline went next, then Danny, then Josh, and they each ate her out for a little while. Anna went last, and Stella was pretty sensitive at that point, so her legs shook as she got her pussy licked.

“Thanks for that dare,” she said to me as she sat down. “That got me so turned on.”

“You got a nice pussy,” Josh said, and everyone agreed.

“Thanks!” She said, and rubbed her pussy, which was now covered in all of our saliva. “Truth or dare, Anna?”

“Dare,” she said.

“I dare you to make out with your brother for 20 seconds.” Stella said excitedly.

Anna looked at me, and I said, “I guess we have to.” She walked over to me and brought her face close to mine. She hesitated for a moment so I pulled her in and stuck my tongue in her mouth. Everyone cheered as our lips touched, and I could feel my sister’s tits pressing against my chest as we kissed. My right hand held the back of her head, and my left hand held her back as I mashed my face against hers. The taste of her lips filled my mouth, along with the taste of my girlfriend’s pussy that we had both just licked. I could feel my cock hardening in my pants while my tongue played with hers in our mouths. After 20 seconds passed, Danny started to interrupt, but Stella shushed him, hoping we wouldn’t notice how much time was passing. I knew the 20 seconds was over, but I just wanted to keep going, and continue tasting Anna’s mouth. After about 45 seconds, I finally let go of Anna, and I pulled my lips apart from hers.

“That was really good,” I told her as she went back to her spot in the circle.

“Truth or dare, Danny?” Anna said, since he was the last one to go.

“Dare.” he said, excited for what he would have to do.

“I dare you to tittyfuck me, like you said you wanted to at lunch the other day.” Anna said, pushing her tits together and looking at him with an inviting expression.

“I’d love to,” he unbuckled his pants, taking his cock out. “I got hard just by looking at you.” He got up and climbed on top of my sister as she laid back and got her tits ready for him. He slid his cock in between Anna’s tits and grunted as he started thrusting. Anna’s tits shook around beautifully as they got fucked.

“Your dick feels so good between my titties.” Anna moaned, her pussy getting visibly wetter.

“Your tits are so perky and warm. They feel like a tight pussy,” Danny said as his balls slapped against them. He brushed his fingers against her nipples, and took an hold of her tits for her, so she could use a free hand to finger herself. Stella rubbed my dick through my pants as we all watched.

Danny’s face went red, and it looked like he was getting close. “Hold up, Anna. I don’t wanna cum yet.” He said and started to pull away, but Anna only giggled and pulled him back in.

“Hee hee, you haven’t finished the dare yet,” she said, and pumped her breasts together faster. Danny immediately gave up on pulling away and moaned with pleasure. He humped her chest like he would fuck someone’s cunt.

“Oh fuck, Anna, your tits are gonna make me bust!” He shouted, and before he knew it, he was already cumming. His seed splattered across her chin and neck, before slowing down with each shoot until it pooled around her cleavage. Danny looked down at the mess he had made on her and smiled. Anna grinned at him as she sat up and licked the tip of his dick to get the rest of the cum off of it.

“Was it as good as you hoped?” Anna asked.

“It was better,” Danny replied. “That was one of the best titjobs I’ve ever had!”

“See, sis?” I said. “I told you your tits aren’t too small.”

“Are you crazy?” Josh said to Anna, “How could you think those are too small. They’re perfect!”

Anna blushed a little at the compliments and shook her tits with appreciation. “Thanks guys.”

Danny went next and asked Caroline, “truth or dare?”

“Dare.”

“I dare you to keep me hard so that I can cum again.”

Caroline licked her lips and crawled over to Danny and eagerly took his softening cock into her mouth. He moaned since he was extra sensitive and leaned back to let Caroline work on him. We all waited for Caroline’s next dare, but she seemed a little preoccupied. Josh cleared his throat to catch her attention and she realized she had to take her turn. She pointed at Stella, while still sucking on Danny, and she said, “dare.” It was a little hard to understand Caroline’s game of charades, but she made a jerking motion and then pointed at her cunt. Stella quickly understood it to mean to fuck herself with a dildo, and she ran to Anna’s room to get one.

Stella came back with a dildo that was visibly sticky and spread her legs wide so that everyone could see it go up her cunt. Once it was inside of her, she turned it on and started to vibrate, and she immediately cranked it up to the highest setting, causing her to scream and shake like crazy.

“Woah! I’ve never even turned it on that high,” Anna said. Stella could barely respond as she writhed on the floor. She rolled around on the floor as if she was on fire, and when I put my hand on one of her tits, I could feel the dildo shaking me too. Tears were flowing from her eyes and I could tell she was enjoying herself.

“Fu-fu-cu-cumming! I-I-I’m cumming!” Stella screamed and flung her hips around. She shook uncontrollably and squirted all over the floor.

“Oh-oh-my god!” She looked up at me with a huge smile. “I squirted! I’ve never done that before!” She shoved the dildo in herself harder. “I thought I wasn’t able to squirt! This is so hot!” She screamed and squirted again, leaving a massive puddle on the wood floors, as if someone had pissed all over the place. Anna giggled and also made herself squirt on the floor, adding to the puddle. Stella laughed and screamed hysterically for a few more minutes, cumming countless times, before turning off the toy. Her ass was completely soaked and she had an incredibly satisfied look on her face, as if she just defied the laws of physics.

Eventually, Stella calmed down from her huge realization and continued the game. “Josh, my pussy is sore, so I dare you to cum down my throat!”

“Finally,” he said, pouncing at Stella and fucking her face like a fleshlight. I figured they’d want to use Stella a lot since she was new to them.

Anna and I were left waiting while they finished up their dares, and we started getting a little bored…