Truth

"Truth" I said, my voice shimmering. The image of Sarah's mouth running over Callum's cock as it slapped into her face fresh in my mind.

Maybe picking truth was the coward's option, but I needed a moment to settle down and an easy truth question was the best option.

"Hmmm." Callum laid back with his arms behind his head, the bulge between his legs becoming tauntingly obvious.

"Here's a question." Lacy interjected. " Between you and Cal, who's the bigger man."

Her line of sight and lip bit made it obvious what she was referring to and I began to regret my choice. I wasn't ashamed of my size, or at least I wasn't before today. I was perfectly average, but it still stung to admit Callum's manhood was bigger than mine.

"C-Callum is bigger." I said, staring down at the floor. I could hear the chuckle coming from Callum and didn't want to see his smug face while I admitted that.

"It's OK baby." Sarah kissed my cheeks, still flush from the drink I had earlier. "I know I'll love your little man just as much."

Why did she have to call it that? I understood the meaning, but in the moment it sounded like she was calling it small. And wait a second, what did she mean by 'just as much'? Before my mind could dwell on that question, Callum interrupted by thoughts.

"I'm glad you felt like sharing that Liam, now are you ready for your truth?" His face glowing with amusement.

"Wait, wasn't that my-"

"Mmmm you've fallen for the oldest trick in the book, little man." Daniel told me. "It wasn't Lacy's turn to give you a truth, she just asked you a question."

It took a moment for the gears to turn in my mind as I realised what had happened. I couldn't believe I'd fallen for something so simple, my mind just wasn't working like it normally did.

The group had a good laugh and I tried to chuckle along. I didn't want them to think I was a bad sport, so I took the hazing as a sign we were getting closer.

"Alright then, here's your real question." Callum raised his hands to quieten the others as he made the announcement. "In great detail, how good does it feel to be inside Sarah's tight pussy."

My heart skipped a beat, I could physically feel everyone's intense gazes pressing into me from all angles. The crushing weight of the realisation of what I would have to admit welling a knot deep within my gut.

Sweat beaded down my forehead. I wanted to stare down at the floor again but mustered enough strength to look at Sarah.

She was smiling that beautiful smile of hers. It helped lift my heart, and made me remember there was nothing to be ashamed of. Yes we hadn't done anything else, but that was only because we were waiting for the perfect night. A night which would have been tonight, but would still be coming very soon.

"I." My voice wavered, and I took a moment to steel myself. "I don't actually know."

The three newcomers erupted into a loud mix of shock and laughter. I couldn't help but feel the humiliation, even knowing waiting for a girl like Sarah was the right thing to do.

What really twisted the pit of anxiety in my guy was Callum's face. There was no shock or laughter at all, just the same level of amusement showing as he'd had before asking. He couldn't have known could he? Is that why he asked the question in the first place? He must have guessed somehow, there just wasn't any other way he could have known me and Sarah were both virgins.

"Settle down now guys, Liam isn't like all of you." Sarah reprimanded the others while wrapping an arm around me. "He's not a sex crazed party boy, he's a gentle soul."

"I don't care how little your man is dude." Steven said between laughter. "How can you not be ploughing a fine piece of ass like her every night?"

"He'll plough my fat ass when the time is right." Sarah said. Defending my honour as much as I wished she wouldn't. "And my slutty ginger tits or wet sloppy cunt. However you want to put it, we'll get there when the time is right!"

She really did think she was helping but I don't think she understood the effect her vulgar words were having on these guys. I could see the desire dripping from their eyes, and Daniel even began rubbing himself through his pants.

"Yeah babe I'm sure he will, but first there's the matter of his punishment." Callum was leaning forward now. Of all the guys stares, his was clearly the hungriest.

"But I answered the question!" I said, my eyes darting between the floor and the others. I told them the truth, wasn't that all I had to do?

"The question was to describe how good her pussy feels, you just answered with 'I don't know'." Callum gleefully explained. "That's a failed truth if I've ever heard one."

The others nodded and murmured in agreement, even Sarah nodded and then gave me an apologetic look.

"Since you failed to tell us how good it feels, it's only right we find out." He smiled wide and the bulge in his pants twitched in anticipation.

"You either get in there right now so you can tell us, or let us all get a feel deep inside that wet cunt of hers."