Truth... with fewer consequences

First half written by tacheet. I've blatantly stolen that part, but I'm branching off differently.

"T...Truth," you manage to find the resolve and make what you know to be the right choice, but barely. You look up at Steve who just chuckles.

"Alright babe, there is one thing I do want to know about you, I've been curious this whole night," Steve paused and you wondered what he was going to say next. "Who are you, really?"

You were suddenly filled with surprise and confusion and embarrassment, "I... umm.... what?" Did Steve somehow know?

"Come off it, babe, you can't really be Alicia's virginal cousin," you and Alicia just looked at each other as Steve went on, "your body and face is simply perfect. Now, don't get me wrong, Alicia is a straight up hottie, but you're something else. You're a little too perfect..."

You blushed as Steve kept checking you out, "In fact, the only time I've ever seen anyone look as perfect as you is when someone takes an X-Change pill. You can't tell me that perfection is natural, or that, if you really are that hot, you haven't already been fucked by now."

Shit. The whole room was looking at you now. You could feel your face turning bright red as you sat there, without pants even, as Steve exposed your secret.

"So my question is, who are you really, 'Blake'?"

The room was waiting. You gave Alicia a pleading look, but she simply shrugged. The rules of the game compelled you to tell the truth right now. You thought you were taking the safe way out but Steve had outplayed you after all.

"I... I..." you start to answer, "I'm really... Blake... but y..you're right... I took an X-Change..." you admitted.

Liz gasped and covered her mouth. You could tell by her eyes that she recognized you now. "So... you're... Blake?" She stared at you in disbelief.

"Y..Yes.. I thought there wouldn't be boys here so I would have to become a girl to come and... Alicia helped me and... um..." you looked over to Alicia but she just sat there with a sultry look, biting her lip.

"Fuck!" Max exclaimed, "no wonder you weren't picking up your phone!"

"Hahaha, I fucking knew it!" Steve laughed triumphantly, "the girl with the perfect body! The name, 'Blake', showing up to this party of all places! It was too much! I knew who you were! It couldn't have been a coincidence!"

Somehow Steve's triumph, as embarrassing as it was, was only making you hornier. He was dominating you just as he always had, only this time all you wanted to do was to give in.

"Now, I'm guessing," Steve continued, "based on your pregnancy worries from before, that you didn't just take a regular X-Change pill did you?"

Fuck. He really did figure it all out. "N...No, the pharmacy was out of regulars... S..So I took a B..Breeder pill..."

"Oh Fuck! A Breeder! Nice." Steve looked your body up and down as he licked his lips. Finally he grinned that seductive grin of his, "Okay Blake, it's okay. You can come over here now."

There was nothing you could do at this point. You stood up and walked over to Steve. He walked around you, admiring your body as he stroked his rock hard cock. When he got behind you, he gave your ass a good smack and bent you over a little. Then he tucked his fingers in and started rubbing your pussy from behind.

"Umm, Blake?" Alicia said to you, "What do you think you're doing?"

And then, you thought about what Alicia said and you started to come to your senses. You stood straight up, turned around, and faced Steve.

"No, I don't think I can do this," you told him, even though every fiber of your being was screaming to just let him stick his dick into you.

"Are you sure, Blake?" he said as he held his dick suggestively. "Don't you want me to fuck you and get it all over with?"

"Oh, god yes," you said before you realized what you were saying. But then, using every ounce of your mental strength, fighting against your every desire, you added, "But I can't. I don't want to be stuck as a girl."

Steve looked disappointed at being refused, almost as if that had never happened to him before. But then, as if trying not to lose face, he said, "Well, that's okay. I just shot a load into Liz already. I need some time to recharge anyway. And maybe by then you'll change your mind."

The general mood around the room seemed to be changing. It seemed like the boys were overstaying their welcome. Apart from Kay and Alicia, everyone was naked, though you were only naked from the waist down. And all the boys had already fucked a girl, meaning that they weren't too interested in any more sexy fun.

Eventually, the boys realized that it was time to leave, so they got dressed and quietly snuck out of the house, with Steve whispering one last "See you tomorrow night," to you. The girls got dressed as well, not so interested in being naked just among themselves.

The game of "truth or dare" had ended. The girls had had so much excitement for one night that they would ready for milder fare and started playing some card games instead. There was still the issue of your true identity but the others decided to accept you as one of them for now. After all, you had had to deal with the same issues (almost getting fucked by Steve) as the rest of them, though that didn't stop them teasing you occasionally about being a girl when you should be a guy.

Liz asked you, "What was it like watching Steve fuck me? Were you jealous?"

"Yeah," you answered. "But it was also hot. I mean, I wanted to be the first one to fuck you, so I was jealous of Steve, but..."

"But what?" Liz asked.

"Well, I mean now, as a girl, I was jealous of you too, seeing you get fucked like that," you said, sheepishly.

"But you managed to say no to Steve when he was ready to fuck you," Alicia pointed out.

"Yeah, barely," you reply. "I just had to focus on how much I wanted to have a penis again, so I could fuck a girl like Steve had just done."

"Oh, really?" Alicia asked. "Any girls in particular you want to fuck if you were a guy?"

"Well, Liz mainly," you answer, "But also you, Alicia." Then, seeing all the other girls looking at you, you add, "Well, anyone really. I'm not picky."

"You know what?" Alicia whispers to you. "If you become a man again, you just might get your wish."

Those words had a strangely erotic effect on you. Your horniness level had cooled down after the boys left and everyone put their clothes back on. But now, the thought, that you might actually get to fuck Alicia in a few days...

Well, wherever that thought was going, it was interrupted as Liz's father Brad came into the room to check on the girls to make sure nothing untoward was happening. He saw that there were no boys around and the girls were just playing cards, so he was relieved, and went back to bed. And eventually, the girls went to sleep as well.