More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 11 by DefeatedDamsels DefeatedDamsels

True or False?

True

Your first instinct is of course that your daughter is way too sensible to have had sex without a condom. She's never been in a serious committed relationship that you know of, so it would make sense that any men she had played around with would need to wrap their tools.

But then you remember how Finch got the previous question wrong. Could this be another situation where you all have no idea how promiscuous and - dare you say it - slutty, your daughter really is?

You can't afford to take any chances - you NEED those condoms. So despite your desires for what you want to be the truth, you have to go with your gut at what, based on new information, seems quite possible to be the truth.

Not that all sluts are frivolous enough to not enforce strict condom usage, of course. But, well, you now have serious doubts about your daughter's reliability.

"True." You say.

"True." The man beside you says, sounding a bit dejected.

Again, the man running the show finds an excuse to laugh.

"Bravo, bravo. You're quickly cottoning onto the idea that perhaps your girls aren't the angels you thought they were, hmm? You're both correct."

And without another word, he unceremoniously drops another red and another purple condom down to you, and then returns to watch the spectacle behind you.

Jasper is doing his best to worm his monster meat into your daughter. Meanwhile, a skinny looking chap who should be trying to get inside his sister as quickly as possible is instead stunned, watching your brother with mouth agape. Whether it's feeling sorry for your daughter, or pure penis envy, it's difficult to say, but he can't look away.

Jasper's dick does not get in easily. He has to put just the tip in, and work it back and forth for a bit to build up lubrication, to beat the friction.

Your daughter's vagina is visibly stretched to its limits, and looks almost warped out of shape by its gargantuan invader.

Against what feels like should be physically possible, slowly but surely, the hulk-sized rod is sinking into your daughter's depths.

Just picturing what that must be doing to her inside makes you shiver.

But somehow that greedy gash keeps gobbling up your brothers meatstick, until the entire beast is inside her, except for maybe a single inch at the base. Still, that's really impressive.

At this point, Jasper settles into a rhythm of short fast fucks, likely anticipating that full long strokes in and out would be too much for this overstretched orifice to handle. The fourth brother finally snaps out of his stupor and realizes that he should be doing the same, and so quickly sets to work sliding his comparatively tiny tool into his sister's ready and waiting hole.

Despite Jasper's headstart, it's this skinny wimp that wins the race, making a meek sigh as he empties his gonads while whipping it in and out of his sister's snatch. Meanwhile, Jasper's Pussy Pounder appears to have more endurance, and continues its brutal **** on your daughter's nether region.

The skinny brother attaches this fourth condom to his sister's toe, completing the first set. They're officially in the lead now.

Hurry your brother up?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)