Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 2 by Woodtale Woodtale

What's next?

Tim; his wife suggests using the babysitter

"What're you thinking about, Tim?" Sarah asked her husband with a knowing smirk on her face.

Tim shook his head and stammered, realizing he'd been caught staring at their babysitter as she leaned over. "I just, I wasn't sure... umm I don't know."

Please log in to view the image

"She's pretty cute, isn't she? I wouldn't blame you for looking. I think she's pretty hot too," Sarah diffused the situation. Her blunt opinion is what attracted Tim to her in the first place. "It's been a bit for you hasn't it?"

"Sorry, I was just caught in a day dream, hun."

"Oh you don't need to apologize. I like seeing that fire in your eyes. Honestly, there'd be something wrong with you if you weren't looking. Amy is one hot piece of ass. Why do you think I hired her?"

Tim perked up at her teasing, "Really?"

"Sure hun. I mean you've let me live out some of my fantasies, why shouldn't you try one of yours? How about you ask her to join us for dinner tonight?"

It didn't take any more convincing to get Tim to in board. Soon Amy was canceling her plans for the evening and staying for dinner with the couple.

Amy was in college and she did some babysitting in her free time to have some extra spending money. She knew right away that Tim and Sarah would be a fun couple to work for when she met them at a local club. They'd been very flirty that night and she found both of them extremely sexy. What a perfect combination - easy money watching their toddler and some eye candy, so she never hesitated when offered a job the next weekend.

Dinner was fun tonight and Amy noticed how Tim and Sarah kept popping bottles of wine. Something was clearly up because they'd never drank like that at home before. Amy put their son to bed after dinner and she noticed a romantic ambiance when she returned to the living room.

"How about you stay and chat for a little?" Sarah offered her another glass of red wine. "Come join us on the couch," she invited warmly as she patted the open seat between the couple.

Amy was already feeling the warmth in her chest from dinner drinks, so another glass sounded enticing. She settled in between them on the couch with her legs crossed.

"I can't believe the boys at school aren't calling you every night, Amy," Sarah complimented her as she brushed Amy's hair behind her ear. "I wish I still had your complexion."

Amy blushed and took a long drink.

"I was just telling Tim how envious I am of you. You keep yourself in such good shape and you have such a gorgeous face. Those boys don't know what they're missing out on."

Amy blushed again and looked down shyly. "Oh those boys are immature. I wouldn't even know what to say to them if they did hit on me."

"Sounds like you just need some practice sweetheart! Men are easy. A couple simple compliments and then touch their arm and they're putty in your hands."

"Really?"

"Sure. You should try it. Use Tim for practice. Give him a compliment, then rest your hand on his thigh and I bet you'd be surprised."

Amy looked at Tim who was already red faced between the wine and the conversation. "Well I've always been impressed with how well he's stayed in shape. You really do look good." And with that she lightly rested her hand on his thigh as instructed.

Tim looked at her hand resting on his thigh. His heart was pounding and he was at a loss for words. "Well... Thank you... I... ummm... I try to stay in shape..."

"See sweetheart, you've got him all flustered. Now tell him exactly what you like about him and run both of your hands up his thighs. You'll own him in no time."

Amy followed Sarah's instructions. "I've noticed how good you look in those jeans and how your arms look in that T-shirt." She turned directly towards Tim and leaned into him while placing both of her hands high on his lap.

Tim gulped noticeably.

Sarah urged him on, "Go ahead Tim. Tell Amy what you're thinking."

Tim looked Amy up and down, feeling the intensity of the situation. The wine had removed his barriers. He stared at her pouty lips as she leaned towards his face. They looked so soft and plush. Instead of saying anything he leaned in and kissed her. Amy kissed him back and leaned into him more until she pushed him back into the couch. They continued to kiss and soon they were wrapping their tongues together.

Sarah quietly sat back drinking her wine and enjoying the show.

Amy began running her hands up Tim's shirt, exposing his tight abs. She ran her fingers up and down his muscles as she continued to wrestle tongues.

Tim responded by grabbing her tight ass as she laid on top of him. It felt so good. Fresh, firm and young. It reminded him of what Sarah used to feel like when they were first married. He'd introduced a couple guys into their marriage, but this was the first time for him to feel up another woman and it was almost like making love again for the first time.

It wasn't long before both of their shirts were off and Amy was shimmying out of her tight jeans. They continued passionately kissing as they undressed. Tim ran his fingers along Amy's young, tight skin.

Amy was enjoying the attention Tim was giving her body. His experience and slow movements felt so much better than the younger guys she'd been with before. They always felt like they were in a rush. Not Tim. His movements felt intentional. It was especially arousing. Sarah was right.

As her jeans slipped down and she kicked them off, Tim wrapped his large hands across her half exposed butt and squeezed. She could feel his exploring down between her thighs, seeking her warm mound. Once he finally got there, he carefully rubbed her entrance and then her bare inner thighs, then back to her pussy, back and forth, teasing her.

Amy spread her legs giving him unencumbered access to her tingling crotch. Then she began kissing down his neck and collarbone. "Oh Tim! Touch me! Rub my pussy!"

Her excitement only aroused him more. He slid a hand down the back of her panties as she began grinding up against his hard member. She moaned as his fingers finally landed on her warm, wet slit.

Sarah couldn't stand it anymore. She reached up and tugged Amy's panties down exposing her husband's fingers as they played with Amy's labia. Sarah was surprised how much it excited her to watch Tim play with their babysitter's pussy young pussy.

Some more urging and finally Amy had removed her bra, releasing her firm titties. She leaned over, away from Tim, exposing her aching twat to his craving eyes. She reached back and spread her butt, giving him a better view.

"Give it to her baby! Give her that monster cock!" Sarah encouraged as she watched from a distance, slowly rubbing her own clit with her legs spread through her black yoga pants.

Please log in to view the image

Tim took aim and first slowly pressed his thick, throbbing cock head against her moist opening. As he began to penetrate her, she bit her lip and cringed to the pressure as he stretched her open. Her cunt was slick, but she'd never had so thick a dick inside her. Soon it have easy and he was sliding in and out with ease.

Tim continued to thrust inside her. Sarah was enthralled, watching him fuck Amy. Her breathing began to synchronize with his movements as he impaled her. She could see his thick base spread Amy open even more as he pushed deeper and deeper into that sweet cunt.

Amy moaned loudly. She'd never been fucked so thoroughly. Her brain could hardly keep up as she began to climax. Tim noticed her reaction and he reached around, tickling her clit as he continued to pound her from behind. Amy's body began to quiver as she felt a flood of release wash over her body. She pushed back into him, pressing his dick as deep as possible inside her.

Tim couldn't hold it back much longer. Her tight hole gripped his cock like it was milking him and he could only ignore the feeling for a little more. It wasn't long before he felt his scrotum tighten and the buildup before he pulled his cock out and gave a couple final strokes. Ropes of white semen sprayed across her tan lower back. Once, twice, three streams sprayed across her amazing skin.

As it finally seemed to stop, Tim rolled his sloppy tip up and down her reddened pussy. The final touch made Amy sigh heavily.

Sarah was the first to speak as the two naked bodies began cleaning themselves up, "You two were so fucking hot. We probably owe you double pay for that performance Amy!"

"Oh no, absolutely not! That was an education for me. You don't have to pay me for that. I just appreciate the lesson that you were willing to teach me," Amy responded once she caught her breath.

"I hope you'll join us again sometime," Sarah said as she helped Amy find all her clothes.

"Oh definitely! I'd love that!" Amy replied with a smile. She quickly got dressed and headed for the door. "Thanks again. Do you want me to lock up as I leave?"

"Yes please sweetheart! I still have some unfinished business to attend to tonight," Sarah called out as she stared at Tim, still lying there naked and worn out.

"Ok, have fun you two!" Amy said with a grin as she took one more look at Tim's thick cock and walked out the door.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)