This Wasn't the Game

Sunday night, 9:40. James was still in the armchair. The TV stayed off. The third beer had gone warm on the side table and the house was loud with its own patterns — the dishwasher he had run, the couch cushions he’d straightened at eight out of nothing but habit, the upstairs floorboard that popped on its own schedule.

She’d been gone three and a half hours. The porch light was still on.

At 10:30 he picked up his keys.

He stood in the hallway with them in his hand and worked out the drive. Twelve minutes to the place on Fourth. The lot would tell him everything — her car there or not there. Diane’s drinks, or not Diane’s drinks. He stood there long enough to understand that he wasn’t going, and then he understood why, and the why was worse than the not-knowing: if her car wasn’t in that lot, then the taunts at the vanity had been an itinerary, and he’d have to do something about it, and he had been not-doing-something-about-it since November with a discipline he had never applied to anything else in his life.

He put the keys back. He sat back down.

At midnight he ran the inventory again, the way he’d run it a hundred times. The necklace gone from the clutch and the jewelry box — it must be on her, tonight, under the wrap top he’d watched her check twice in the mirror. The medium plug gone from the vanity drawer — in her, maybe, right now, the one he’d rolled onto his own fingers with lube from their nightstand, the one from their play that was supposed to be for him. The underwear from the benefit, heavy on the tile, soaked through from the inside, the bleach-salt smell that hadn’t come from anyone’s ass. *The story she told was anal.* He’d known since two in the morning after the benefit that the story was a lie, and he’d spent a week not saying so.

*What if I slide under the table. Guess what I just did.*

The buzz came at 1:07.

His phone lit up face-up on the arm of the chair and he knew before he looked, because nobody texted him at one in the morning, and he sat there watching the screen glow and dim and he almost didn’t open it. That was the last exit. He watched himself not take it.

He opened it.

The photo filled the screen and the room went out from under him.

No face. It was worse than a face. His wife’s thighs, spread wide, her skin flushed and shining — and between them a cock, softening, still thick as his wrist, dark and glistening, lying beneath her. Ray’s. He knew it the way you know a voice. And out of her — out of his wife — cum, a slow white tide of it, so much of it, leaking down over the stretched pink of her and over the silver base of the plug seated in her ass and pooling on the dark skin beneath. The plug. But not the medium from their drawer — the base was wider, the neck thicker, a size he’d never seen. Ray had taken theirs out of her and put his own in. And held to the side, her wrists — bound, crossed, a leather belt looped around them, the prints of it raw and red at the edges of her skin.

*Ooops, got a little carried away and broke our rule. You like it when I’m naughty though — right? Don’t wait up.*

He stood up. The chair rocked. The fury came up out of him so fast his vision pulsed — because this one had no accident in it. November was a condom that broke. The couch was a condom that shredded. Every single time there had been a story with an accident in it, a version where the thing happened *to* her, and this was a photograph. Framed. Lit. Captioned. Sent. She had let him finish inside her and then she’d held still for the camera and written *ooops* about it in the voice she used in their bed, their voice, the tongue-out-eyes-crossed voice, and aimed it at him from another man’s couch.

He typed *come home. now* and his thumb hung over send.

And underneath the fury — fused to it, the same compound, the thing he’d been failing to separate since November — he was hard. Granite. Because he couldn’t stop the inventory: he had never been inside her bare. Not once in eleven years. And there was so much cum in the photo that it was still running out of her, which meant Ray had filled her, deliberately, hugely, and she’d kept it. As her husband, he had never tied anything around her wrists — he’d never asked, never thought she’d want it — and the prints on her skin said the belt had been there a while. Said she’d strained against it.

He tried not to imagine what came before the photo and imagined it anyway.

A hotel room, his mind supplied — because it was always hotels. The conference. Dayton. The Worthington. A king bed and blackout curtains and an ice bucket sweating on a dresser.

The gag. His mind went there and he couldn’t call it back — her own underwear, the black pair, soaked and folded and pushed into her mouth while Ray fucked her from behind, her sounds muffled and frantic. And the belt — the prints said *belt* and his mind ran with it: across her ass, stripes rising, her forehead down on the carpet and her bound hands up behind her, Ray making her say *thank you* for it, making her say *sir.*

He made himself stop. His hand had moved an inch.

Or worse — the version where nobody forced anything. Her on top, slow, comfortable, laughing at something he’d said — laughing, in the middle of it, the way she laughed in their kitchen over the pepper grinder — and at the end looking down at him and asking. *Cum in me.* No accident. No excuse. The photo said she’d asked — *ooops, broke our rule* — and if she’d asked for that, she’d said other things too. Maybe the worst one. *I love you,* in the dark, in the wrong bed, in the voice—

He couldn’t finish that one.

Every version he invented made him harder and angrier in equal measure, and he hated his hand for wanting to move and hated his cock for wanting his hand.

He looked at the draft on the screen. *come home. now.*

Did a stag send that? He didn’t know anymore. The husband in the story she’d been living since November — the one who asked for it, who set the rules, who got off on the breaking of them — that husband answered *that’s my girl* or *can’t wait to hear about it* or nothing at all because he was too busy enjoying it. Ray’s voice from the benefit bar, two minutes of advice that had worked exactly as designed: *keep acting like a man with a secret and she does the rest herself.* An angry reply tore the frame. The frame was the only cover he had.

And he couldn’t write the playful one. He physically could not make his thumbs do it, not with that photo above the keyboard, not with her wrists in a belt.

And under both of those, the real lock: anger had a *why* attached, and the why led to the underwear on the tile and the necklace with dried cum on the *B* and the question of how long he’d known and not said — his whole drawer of secrets opening with hers. Silence was the only door that stayed shut.

He deleted the draft. Put the phone face-down on the side table next to the warm beer.

He made it four minutes.

Then he picked it back up and opened the photo again and looked at her — the bound wrists, the plug that wasn’t from their drawer seated in *her* ass, the slow white evidence of what she’d let him do, how small she looked stretched around a cock that thick, thighs open like she’d been told to hold still for the shot — and he stopped refusing. The thing he hadn’t done at seven o’clock with the old photo, the line he’d drawn and stood behind all evening, he stepped over it now without ceremony, his hand inside his waistband, his cock already aching. He thought of her ass on their own bed and then of whatever angle had produced this frame — her sitting on Ray with that plug in, asking for it — and both images hit at once, and he stroked to them with his jaw locked and his eyes open.

He stopped pretending the photograph was evidence and let it be pornography.

---

She came home at seven forty-five. Monday. The getting-ready hour.

James was at the kitchen table with coffee he’d made around four and never touched. Two days of stubble. Eyes that hadn’t closed. His phone sat face-down beside the mug — he’d stopped being able to look at it and stopped being able to leave it in another room.

He heard the side door before he saw her. Three seconds to decide which man opened his eyes.

She walked in wearing the whole night, and the smell reached him across the kitchen before she’d said a word — Ray’s apartment, stale cologne, sex, and under all of it, faintly, coffee and her. Last night’s skirt, wrinkled high on her thighs. The wrap top, creased from wherever it had spent its hours. Her hair tangled, yesterday’s mascara smudged soft around her eyes, her mouth bare and swollen-looking — that cute full mouth used hard and not sorry about it. She moved through the kitchen like a woman whose legs ached pleasantly. When she went to the pot, the skirt pulled across her ass with every step, and even wrecked, even smelling like that apartment, she was the hottest thing that had ever walked into a room, freshly and visibly fucked, and he hated how fast his cock understood that.

No chain at her throat. He looked for it — the gold script he’d found in her clutch at two in the morning — and it wasn’t there.

“Morning,” she said. Set her bag on the counter. Poured coffee from the fresh pot like she’d made it herself. Her eyes found his over the rim, and held them, and something in her face was waiting.

“So,” she said. Light. “Did you get my message?”

“I got it.”

“And?”

He looked at her. The anger came up clean and fast, and for once he let some of it out. “You let him finish inside you, Jenna. On purpose. That’s not a broken condom, that’s not — you *asked* for it, that’s what the caption says, you got carried away and broke the rule—”

“The rule.” She said it gently, like he’d misremembered a date. “James. This is what you’ve wanted this whole time. The hotel. The couch. The benefit. You watched every time. You asked for videos, for pictures, for the telling — you came in your own fist in our living room chair while he was still inside me. Don’t get precious now because I enjoyed it.”

He deflated. She was right — the role he’d been playing since the airport had no room for this anger, and they both knew it, and the fight went out of him as fast as it had come.

“I got carried away.” She smiled — the real one, the one that always undid him. “You like it when I’m naughty though. Right?”

He nodded. The nod cost him something visible, and she watched it cost him, and her smile didn’t change.

She crossed the kitchen and set her mug down and leaned in and kissed him. On the mouth. Slow. Deliberate. Coffee over everything — and underneath the coffee, something faint, something he could almost place, salt and something else. *Had she just sucked him off? This morning? Was that what was under the coffee — was he tasting Ray Vogler’s cock in his wife’s mouth at seven forty-five on a Monday?* He couldn’t be sure, and the not-being-sure was the point, he understood that even as his cock hardened under the sweatpants and his stomach turned over, both, the same compound, the thing he’d been failing to separate since November.

She held the kiss one beat past comfortable and pulled back and looked at his face.

“Are you angry?” she asked, and there was a smile tucked inside it, like she already knew the answer was no.

“I don’t know what I am,” he said. The most honest sentence available to him.

“Poor baby.” She touched the skin beneath his eye with her thumb — the bruised half-moons. Gentle. “I’m going to shower. I smell like his apartment…. and cum.”

She was halfway to the stairs when she looked back. “Come up with me. Come get your reward for being such a good sport about last night.”

He followed her up. He watched her ass move under the wrinkled skirt on every step — the flex, the high round shape, a faint fingerprint shadow when the fabric shifted at her hip — and hated himself for the watching. Ray’d had his hands there all night. Ray had fucked that. And she was leading James upstairs to tell him about it like a souvenir.

In the bedroom she undressed in front of him — the wrap top over her head, the tank after it, the skirt unzipped and stepped out of — and she narrated her own state like a tour, warm and unbothered, watching him watch. The fingerprint bruises on her hip, purple-black, continuing back toward her ass where a larger hand had held her open. The red prints at her wrists, two neat bands. “He tied me up, James. With his belt.” She turned, showing him — ass first, on purpose — and let him look at the full bare cheek of it, faintly marked, still the thing that stopped rooms, and the marks on her wrists said *strained against it* and she let him read that too. “We’ve never done anything like that, have we.” She traced the prints with her own fingers, thoughtful, that sweet almost-smile on while she did it. “I kind of loved it. Is that terrible?”

He couldn’t answer. She ran a hand between her legs and winced theatrically and smiled. “Sore. Everywhere. In places that have no business being sore.” A glance back over her shoulder. “He couldn’t keep his hands off my ass. All night. You should see how red it got when he—” She laughed once, soft. “Anyway.”

She was naked and marked and obscenely beautiful, standing in their bedroom telling him about it like a trip report, and his cock was hard enough to ache, and the part of him that wanted to grab her by the waist and the part of him that wanted to grab her *by the shoulders* were the same part.

She showered. He sat on the edge of the bed and listened to the water.

She came out warm and damp, hair dark at the ends, dropped the towel at the foot of the bed, and nodded at his phone. “Open the photo.”

He did.

“Put it on the pillow. I want you looking at it while I tell you.”

She pulled him back onto the mattress and straddled his thighs — not his hips, lower, her weight settling on his quads, her damp tits swaying as she leaned to the nightstand for the foil square. Their brand. Extra-tight. She tore it with her teeth and freed him from the waistband of his boxers — he was already hard, had been hard since the kitchen — and rolled the condom on with two efficient strokes.

“Now,” she said. Her hand wrapped him through the latex, slow. “The telling. That’s what we do, right? Even when I break the rules.” Her thumb found the ridge beneath the head on every upstroke. “Especially then.”

“Jenna—”

“He tied my wrists behind my back and fucked me from behind” She said it warmly, conversationally, like the pasta. “He had his whole hand on the back of my neck. My face in the pillow. I was screaming into it and he just — kept — going.”

His cock jumped in her fist.

“And he fucked me next to the window, James. Holding me up in the air. Anyone in the parking lot could have looked up and seen me.” She shifted on his thighs, and her ass rose, and even now — even after everything the photo had shown him — the sight of it, full and high and faintly marked, made his hips move on their own. *Ray’d had this. Tied, bent over, filled. This body, the one that stopped conference rooms, the ass men built their afternoons around — Ray Vogler had spent all night using it, and she’d let him, and she’d liked it.*

She took his wrists and put his hands on her ass — both palms, full — and held them there while she stroked him through the latex. “That’s what he grabbed when he bounced me on his cock at the window,” she said, fond, almost helpful. “Go on. You can hold it while I tell you the rest.”

“And the plug stayed in,” she said. “The whole night. Even when I slept. I woke up with it still in me this morning and he was *hard again* and I—” her wrist rolled “—well. You’ll hear about that part.”

He groaned — low, involuntary, hating it — and the thing in him that pushed back shoved and shoved and lost again, the way it had been losing since November.

“And then I begged him. On his couch, tied up like a present. *Please, papi, cum in me.* I said it over and over. I meant it every time.” She leaned closer, her face over his, her damp hair falling around them. “He asked me if I was sure. And I said *yes.* And he filled me up, James. So much. Look at the picture. Look at it. That was minutes after and it was still coming out of me.”

He looked. She watched him look.

“Next time the telling will be even better,” she said. Soft. Promising. “Or maybe you’ll watch. Who knows?” She kissed the corner of his mouth. “Would you like that? Sitting right there, watching him do it?”

“Jenna—”

“I know you would.” Fond. “You’d be so hard. You’d be the hardest man in the world.”

He wanted her mouth. It came up out of him before he could stop it — eleven years of marriage in the gesture, his hand finding her damp hair, the gentlest pressure, guiding her down —

She stilled.

“I’m not so sure, baby.” Warm. Smiling — the real one, girl-next-door, devastating over a sentence like this. A kiss to his jaw. “You’ll have to ask Ray.”

He went very still.

“Ask nicely and maybe he’ll say yes.” She stroked him, slow, watching his face. “And just so you know — he had it this morning. Just this morning, James. On my knees in his kitchen. He filmed it. I showed him my mouthful before I swallowed.” Her thumb circled the head through the latex, and his cock pulsed in her grip, and she watched it happen with the expression of a woman reading results. “So it’s his now. You understand.”

He couldn’t tell if it was a bit or a law. He didn’t push. Pushing was the thing he never did, and they both knew it, and the knowledge sat in the room between them while her hand kept moving.

“Come for me,” she said. “Come thinking about all of it.”

He came — his back arching, his hands gripping the sheet, the latex filling warm in her fist — and she stroked him through every pulse, gentle, almost tender, and watched his face while he lost the fight he’d been losing all morning.

She gentled him down. Peeled the condom off. Knotted it with care and set it on the nightstand beside his phone — beside the photo, still open, of another man’s cum leaking out of his wife.

“That’s where yours goes,” she said. “You know the deal.”

Then she was up — the alarm, the workday — and he watched her become a professional woman in forty seconds: the navy pencil skirt zipping over the ass he’d just had his hands on, the tucked white top, the blazer, mascara fresh over yesterday’s wreckage. The sex-object locking back into the analyst. She kissed his forehead at the door. She smelled like their soap.

He lay in the morning light with the tied condom on the nightstand and the photo on the pillow and one cold, quiet certainty: *this wasn’t the game.* Somewhere between Friday and this morning the game had become a punishment, and he couldn’t prove it, and he had a variance report due Thursday.

---

The drive to Meridian took twenty-two minutes and she spent all of them in the warm haze of the morning after.

Ray. She let herself actually look at it, in the car, where nobody could see her face. Three years of watching her. Thirty seconds with her phone at a dinner and a whole forged voice. A recording trimmed of its first ninety seconds. Her cycle counted off two data points and a calendar. A gas station outside Powell where he’d sat four cars back and watched her take her coat off. The necklace. The video on his phone now, the one that belonged only to him, her on her knees in his kitchen showing the camera her mouthful. It was obsession at a level that should have been called a crime, and it was depraved, and it was *perverted* in the truest sense — a whole man’s life bent around the shape of her — and she had sucked and fucked him anyway, all night, and meant it. And the part she didn’t flinch from: he’d done the same thing to James. Bent her husband around his design without James ever knowing, moved him like a piece. The two of them, both of hers, both arranged by Ray Vogler’s thick hands. The taboo of it should have sickened her. It did. That was the worst of it — the sickness was warm.

And underneath everything, low and constant: the memory of saying *cum in me.* She’d been the woman who took Plan B in a CVS parking lot and swore never again. She knew the odds the way she knew all numbers — one pulse at the benefit, one night in February, low percentages, and if the worst ever came she would face it then, the way she faced everything. She knew the reasoning was a wrapper around a desire. She let it be a wrapper. The one thing she’d never given anyone, the boundary she’d held through her whole marriage and every man before it, handed over in a shitty apartment because he asked and she wanted to give. Deeper than her knees. Deeper than the belt. At the red light on Fourth she sat with the memory of him swelling inside her — of her own ass in his hands at the window, of the plug, of *papi please* — and had to press her thighs together, and the light turned green, and she went.

James. He’d absorbed all of it — the photo, the kiss, the telling, the made up rule about her mouth — and said nothing. No floor found yet. Part of her grieved that, quietly, the part that had married him. Part of her was lit up by it. Both were true. Neither cancelled the other.

She didn’t know what came next. She knew the direction: more. She would keep going and keep watching, and somewhere ahead of her was the answer to how far James would let things go — whether there was a bottom to what he could absorb, whether he’d ever stop adjusting and stand in front of her honest. She didn’t know what she wanted the answer to be.

The Meridian garage took her card. She parked, checked her face in the mirror — mouth still faintly puffy, eyes clear, the professional putting herself back on — and underneath the blazer her ass was sore in the pencil skirt in a way that made her shift in the seat before she got out. Every man who looked at her today would be looking at something Ray Vogler had emptied himself into eight hours ago. The thought should have shamed her. It warmed her all the way to the elevator.

She went up to work.
---

This is the end of chapter 9, and the end of free posts of The Contact. To read the rest check out my profile links.

I'll be posting an entirely new story shortly!