Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 4 by carriekitty carriekitty

What's next?

The Conversation

The following afternoon found us in my living room, the weak January sun doing little to warm the space. Mugs of strong tea steaming on the coffee table between us. A comfortable, sated silence had settled over us, the kind that only exists after shared, profound exhaustion. Laura stirred first, stretching her arms above her head with a groan. “God, yesterday was great” she said, a lazy smile on her face. “69’ing with you and Carl banging my snatch”

“It was fab,” I replied, taking a sip of tea. The memory of yesterday was a warm, heavy blanket around my shoulders. But another memory, older and more specific, was pushing its way to the surface. One from the hotel. I set my mug down. “You know,” I began, my voice casual but with an undercurrent of intent. “There was one guy. At the Pendleton.”

Laura turned her head on the cushion to look at me, interest sparking in her eyes. “Oh yeah? Which one?”

“Alan,” I said, the name feeling significant. “He was… memorable.”

“In what way?” she asked, propping herself up on an elbow. “Big? Rough? Kinky?”

I shook my head slowly, a small, secret smile playing on my lips. “No. Well, he was decently sized, sure. But that wasn’t it.” I leaned forward slightly, lowering my voice as if someone might overhear, even though we were alone. “It was his *load*, Laura. The volume. It was… a lot.”

Her eyebrows shot up. “Oh, a big cummer was, he….mmmmmm”

“Oh yes, defo” I said, my tone utterly serious. “When he came… it wasn’t just a pulse. It was a *gush*. I felt it hit the back of my cervix like a warm wave, and then it just… kept coming. It overflowed. I mean, it literally dripped down my thighs. When Carl saw it. He loved it”

Laura’s mouth had fallen slightly open. “I do love big cummers, we only have one other in our group”

“It was… impressive. A real talent.” I paused, letting the image hang in the air between us. I watched her process it, saw the curiosity morph into something hotter, more covetous. “I have his number,” I added softly. “We exchanged numbers and most of all, he actually lives not too far away”

“Even better still” Laura repeated, her voice a hushed whisper. She was fully sitting up now, the blanket falling away. Her gaze was locked on mine, sharp and understanding. “What are you thinking, Carrie?”

I held her look, my own excitement beginning to simmer. “I’m thinking… we should invite him over. Here. When the boys are away”

A slow, wicked grin spread across Laura’s face, mirroring my own. “A threesome. You, me, and… Alan”

“Exactly,” I said, my heart beating a little faster. “But listen, there’s more. He told me he’s always wanted two women, a threesome, and also to cum on faces too”

Her breath hitched. The idea was no longer just about witnessing a spectacle; it was about fulfilling a deep, specific hunger. We wouldn’t just be an audience; we’d be the realization of a long-held dream.

“His fantasy,” she breathed, the words full of awe. “And we’d be giving it to him. We’d be the two.”

“We’d be perfect for it,” I said, my voice gaining conviction. “I want to see it again. I want to *share* it. I want to watch him cover you with it. I want to feel it on my skin and taste it on yours. But more than that… I want to watch his face when he sees both of us on our knees in front of him, or laid out side by side, waiting for it. Knowing we’re there to make his fantasy real.”

Laura let out a low, shaky breath, her eyes glazing over slightly as she pictured it. “God, yes. To be the object of that… of that specific desire. To be the reason a man’s deepest dirty dream comes true…” She bit her lip, hard. “It’s the ultimate turn-on. It’s filthy and intimate at the same time. Do you think he’d do it? Just… come to a random house to live out his fantasy with two women he barely knows?”

“I think a man with a gift like that, and a fantasy that specific, is probably *aching* for the right invitation,” I said, my voice now thick with certainty. “And we are the perfect invitation. We could make it everything he’s imagined. Slow. Let him savor it. Let him use both of us, any way he wants, until he’s ready to paint us.”

She was sold. I could see it in the flush on her chest, the darkening of her eyes, the way she subtly squeezed her thighs together. “Text him,” she said, her voice firm now, decisive. “Don’t be subtle. Be direct. Tell him you have a friend. Tell him we know about his fantasy. Tell him we want to be his two.”

I was already reaching for my phone, a thrill of pure, devious power running through me. This was beyond arranging a fuck; this was crafting a fulfillment. I opened a new message, to the contact saved simply as **A - Pendleton**. My thumbs flew over the screen, the words coming easily.

*Alan. It’s Carrie, from The Pendleton weekend. I hope this isn’t too forward. I was telling a very close, very discreet friend of mine about your rather exceptional performance. She was incredibly impressed. We got to talking. I remember what you said to me. About wanting two. We want to make that happen for you. My friend and I. Next Thursday evening. Private, informal, and entirely focused on you. Let me know.*

I showed the message to Laura. She read it, her lips moving silently over the words *‘wanting two’*. A shiver went through her. She looked up at me, her expression fierce and hungry. “Send it.”

I hit send. The message whooshed away into the ether, a direct, unambiguous offer. We both stared at my phone, lying silent on the blanket between us. The quiet of the living room was no longer just comfortable. It was electric, humming with the potential of a promise about to be made. We weren’t just co-conspirators anymore. We were about to become someone’s fantasy made flesh, and the anticipation of that role was more intoxicating than anything we’d yet planned.

Within a few minutes my phone pinged and I read the message.

*Hey Carrie, great to hear from you, yes absolutely I’d love to meet you and your friend for some fun, send me the details, Alan XX*

I showed Laura the message and she got excited, “mmmm, this is going to be fun”, she said with a wicked smile on her face.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)